Related 19th Century News Paper article

[jeff of pa]

The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.), 20 Jan. 1893.














The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.) 1890-1895, January 20, 1893, Image 1 « Chronicling America « Library of Congress

Speaking of Robert Morriss makes this little article interesting to me if the same Morriss or his son maybe

The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.), 20 July 1893.



The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.) 1890-1895, July 20, 1893, Page 5, Image 5 « Chronicling America « Library of Congress

Only Mention of Thomas J. Beale also unrelated but figure I'd include

The daily dispatch. (Richmond [Va.]), 25 May 1884.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Diving for Pleasure and Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[Rebel - KGC]

The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.), 20 Jan. 1893.

View attachment 1151142
View attachment 1151143
View attachment 1151144
View attachment 1151145
View attachment 1151146
View attachment 1151147
View attachment 1151148
View attachment 1151149
View attachment 1151150
View attachment 1151151
View attachment 1151152
View attachment 1151153

The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.) 1890-1895, January 20, 1893, Image 1 « Chronicling America « Library of Congress

Speaking of Robert Morriss makes this little article interesting to me if the same Morriss or his son maybe

The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.), 20 July 1893.

View attachment 1151162

The Roanoke times. (Roanoke, Va.) 1890-1895, July 20, 1893, Page 5, Image 5 « Chronicling America « Library of Congress

Only Mention of Thomas J. Beale also unrelated but figure I'd include

The daily dispatch. (Richmond [Va.]), 25 May 1884.

View attachment 1151168
View attachment 1151169

INTERESTING, since Robert MORRISS died in 1863...

 

[jeff of pa]

the same Spelling of Robert Morriss can be found throu-out the U.s.
[147,374 Historical Documents with Morriss on Ancestry]

in the Loc news papers , One Charged with bunco another suing over Millions of acres in N.Y. I Believe
I just decided to just stick to the Roanoke . As I didn't know when he died
or where

Search Results « Chronicling America « Library of Congress

 

[bigscoop]

I find it interesting that the published story has embellished the tale further to include "boxes of gold and sliver."

 

[Rebel - KGC]

the same Spelling of Robert Morriss can be found throu-out the U.s.
[147,374 Historical Documents with Morriss on Ancestry]

in the Loc news papers , One Charged with bunco another suing over Millions of acres in N.Y. I Believe
I just decided to just stink to the Roanoke . As I didn't know when he died
or where

Search Results « Chronicling America « Library of Congress

j/pa; RM died at the home of his niece in 1863; will get info, or franklin may have it...

 

[jeff of pa]

I find it interesting that the published story has embellished the tale further to include "boxes of gold and sliver."

being this one was published over a hundred years ago, I'd say it's closer to the original story
then anything posted in books, TV or the internet from other sources recently.

I still have hard time believing the code saying what was buried, was easy to break.
but the other two were not. that in itself sounds fishy to me.

I would be more inclined to believe the code saying who gets to share would be easiest. and that it would take them to decode the others.
this would keep the treasure safer .

I think Beale may have scammed Morriss somehow & when
the men never showed, he eventually decided to try & get his money back
by adding to the story, & selling the codes
because he needed cash & tried to get his money back

 

[Rebel - KGC]

being this one was published over a hundred years ago, I'd say it's closer to the original story
then anything posted in books, TV or the internet from other sources recently.

I still have hard time believing the code saying what was buried, was easy to break.
but the other two were not. that in itself sounds fishy to me.

I would be more inclined to believe the code saying who gets to share would be easiest. and that it would take them to decode the others.
this would keep the treasure safer .

I think Beale may have scammed Morriss somehow & when
the men never showed, he eventually decided to try & get his money back
by adding to the story, & selling the codes
because he needed cash & tried to get his money back

Well, MY question is... does the 2nd Beale Cipher (DOI) REALLY give us what was "decoded"... OR! Was it just a "PLANT"...? SO... !!!

 

[bigscoop]

The original source of the tale never mentions "boxes of gold and silver" but rather it claims the wealth was packed in iron pots. So I think the article is good example of how things can get quickly distorted and embellished. Years later local authors/researchers would produce materials claiming to have seen the iron box and its contents and yet they all failed to provide any evidence to those "profitable claims" - despite being fully aware of the importance in producing that evidence. So is there any truth in the tale at all? I think we need to tread carefully before deciding what we should and shouldn't believe.

 

[bigscoop]

"Only Mention of Thomas J. Beale also unrelated but figure I'd include.."

Could be it is very related.

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Robert Morris died at the home of David Saunders and his wife, Rosalyn. Rosalyn was Robert Morris' niece. There is a street named Roslin in Lynchburg City today could be the street where Robert Morris died?

That is correct franklin; I have been on that street; VERY short street... NO old homes. On a ridge above several old Tobacco Warehouses; one collapsed last year & ppl were buying the old bricks, to have a piece of OLD Lynchburg, Va. history.

 

[masterpoe]

Cool!

 

[bigscoop]

The original source of the tale never mentions "boxes of gold and silver" but rather it claims the wealth was packed in iron pots. So I think the article is good example of how things can get quickly distorted and embellished. Years later local authors/researchers would produce materials claiming to have seen the iron box and its contents and yet they all failed to provide any evidence to those "profitable claims" - despite being fully aware of the importance in producing that evidence. So is there any truth in the tale at all? I think we need to tread carefully before deciding what we should and shouldn't believe.

 

[ECS]

The original source of the tale never mentions "boxes of gold and silver" but rather it claims the wealth was packed in iron pots. So I think the article is good example of how things can get quickly distorted and embellished. Years later local authors/researchers would produce materials claiming to have seen the iron box and its contents and yet they all failed to provide any evidence to those "profitable claims" - despite being fully aware of the importance in producing that evidence. So is there any truth in the tale at all? I think we need to tread carefully before deciding what we should and shouldn't believe.

The "boxes of gold and silver" statement's origin came from a book review of the BEALE PAPERS that appeared in the LYNCHBURG VIRGINIAN, April 10, 1885-Page 1, Column 3.
That book review also mentioned that the treasure was buried by "several miners in 1828".
These discrepancies could be regarded as simple errors by a newspaper writer...except this writer of this piece was John William Sherman- James Beverly Ward's cousin who set the type and printed the Beale Papers at the VIRGINIA PRINT SHOP.

 

[franklin]

The "boxes of gold and silver" statement's origin came from a book review of the BEALE PAPERS that appeared in the LYNCHBURG VIRGINIAN, April 10, 1885-Page 1, Column 3.
That book review also mentioned that the treasure was buried by "several miners in 1828".
These discrepancies could be regarded as simple errors by a newspaper writer...except this writer of this piece was John William Sherman- James Beverly Ward's cousin who set the type and printed the Beale Papers at the VIRGINIA PRINT SHOP.

John William Sherman did not set the type.

 

[ECS]

Who then set the type and John William Sherman would have proof read the copy before the type was set.
Still, that doesn't explain the obvious errors in his book review, the boxes not iron pots, the miners, the 1828 date.
Its as if it was further confirmation that the Beale Papers was not about a real treasure, but just a story.

 

[franklin]

Who then set the type and John William Sherman would have proof read the copy before the type was set.
Still, that doesn't explain the obvious errors in his book review, the boxes not iron pots, the miners, the 1828 date.
Its as if it was further confirmation that the Beale Papers was not about a real treasure, but just a story.

Your post only proves that John William Sherman did not write the "Beale Papers"

 

[masterpoe]

Your post only proves that John William Sherman did not write the "Beale Papers"

I agree with this conclusion! Just don't let ECS know.

 

[ECS]

After speaking with James Beverly Ward's grandson, Gorham Walker, Lt Thomas Fawcett stated in his April 30, 1949 report to Col William Friedman, "Undoubtedly Mr Ward was the true author of the Beale Papers...unanswered is the question as to why he wrote the story".
James Beverly Ward, as Fawcett concluded, was the prime author of the Beale Papers, but he probably had input from immediate family, his wife Harriet, cousins Hutter and Sherman, and longtime trusted friend, Max Guggenheimer.

 

[Garry]

I apolgize if this question has been covered before as I know little about the post Beale pamplet publication period or the Hart connection.

Who or what was the source of the information in the Roanoke Newspaper of 1893 (Article posted by Jeff)

I initially thought it was the Hart Brother's (from Roanoke) but they didn't get involved with the story until 1897 and didn't contact Ward until 1903.

It seems to closely follow the story in the Beale pamplet? Even though the Hart's were from Roanoke they apparently weren't aware of the article?

It seems that the story was pretty familiar to a lot of people in 1893 (Certainly the readers of the Roanoke newspaper.)

It just struck me as strange.

Did a Roanoke reporter simply run across a copy of the pamplet and decide to write the story and the Harts had never heard this account until they began researching? That may be the simplest answer?

Garry

 

[ECS]

The wife of John William Sherman, work at the Roanoke Times and was responsible for that "human interest" story about the Beale Papers, which makes the "James B WADE" typo interesting.
It is a very basic retelling of the story narrative contained in the pages of the 1885 Beale Papers, no new revelations.
John William Sherman was James Beverly Ward's cousin, and printed the Beale Papers at the Virginia Print Shop.