QUESTIONABLE INFORMATION POSTED AS FACT CONCERNING THE BEALE TALE

[ECS]

"ARM-CHAIR" CRITIC, eh...

Is that one of those "caustic" remarks you keep mentioning?

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Agony and Death on a Gold Rush Steamer: The Disastrous Sinking of the Side-Wheeler Yankee Blade - Grab it through Amazon!

[Rebel - KGC]

Nope... none from me; you've NEVER been in this area, have NO "documentation" for YOUR constant "abuse" of "believers". ALL of it is just your opinion; you have a "right" to your opinion; YOU have! CONSTANTLY; only on this FORUM. We ALL know "where YOU "stand".

 

[ECS]

Pointing discrepancies and false or manufactured facts is not considered "abuse" in logical discussions, except to those which post questionable information stemming from their imaginative "opinion"as "fact".
Motives become suspect when one attacks the messenger while avoiding discussion of the content of the message.
The exposing of "fauxfacts" seems to threaten some, even those who have alleged spending years on research without uncovering one minimal piece of information that can prove the Beale perilous adventure treasure story happened outside of the imagination of this "unknown author" of Ward's 1885 published BEALE PAPERS.
But thank you for your opinion of me that you "CONSTANTLY" post on this forum. We ALL know "where YOU "stand".

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Do You...? HA!

 

[ECS]

Do You…? HEH!

 

[Rebel - KGC]

No, yer not... I will continue to let you know what I find; for an example, Beale Treasure plaque in OLD City Cemetery...

Just "google" Beale Treasure Plaque in Old City Cemetery - Lynchburg, Va. HH! Good Luck! Have FUN!

 

[releventchair]

Just "google" Beale Treasure Plaque in Old City Cemetery - Lynchburg, Va. HH! Good Luck! Have FUN!

Coat-hangers......? Danged diviners beat us to it!

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Naw, I have seen the "spot"; gotta know that TH'ers ALWAYS should dig BEYOND the Coat-Hangers, HORSE SHOES, etc below. City employees DIDN'T know & just gave up!

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Naw, I have seen the "spot"; gotta know that TH'ers ALWAYS should dig BEYOND the Coat-Hangers, HORSE SHOES, etc below. City employees DIDN'T know & just gave up!

AND! NOTHING to do with DIVINERS nor Dowsing, Medium, etc. FACTS: BT Plaque is THERE! HOLE is THERE! NOTHING is QUESTIONABLE!

 

[ECS]

I am personally NOT out to prove the BT Story; "boots-on-the-ground" for me is to state what I have seen/heard about CSA/VMI involvement with Lynchburg, Va. & "points" WEST;
ECS, YOU stay "stuck" in YOUR "BOX" of the "BT Story". Even PV went beyond the "Box", before he passed.

Because of the ambiguity of the Beale story, and the very obvious fact that NO outside of the pamphlet's pages collaboration exists in support of the Beale treasure story, it could be CSA/VMI involvement or maybe plundered loot from Andrew Jackson's raids in Spanish in which James Beverly Risqué took part, or possibly Jean Lafitte, or Sheriff Otey killing Thomas Reed, or whater current speculation one can create.

 

[releventchair]

AND! NOTHING to do with DIVINERS nor Dowsing, Medium, etc. FACTS: BT Plaque is THERE! HOLE is THERE! NOTHING is QUESTIONABLE!

You wrote , "have fun!".

Beale treasure legend has been on a long run of tenacity. Got to give it that.

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Well, at least you've seen the PLAQUE... FACT!

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Because of the ambiguity of the Beale story, and the very obvious fact that NO outside of the pamphlet's pages collaboration exists in support of the Beale treasure story, it could be CSA/VMI involvement or maybe plundered loot from Andrew Jackson's raids in Spanish in which James Beverly Risqué took part, or possibly Jean Lafitte, or Sheriff Otey killing Thomas Reed, or whater current speculation one can create.

YOUR opinion...

 

[ECS]

Would you care to share your "opinion" in relation to the ambiguity of the narrative text of the Beale Papers that freely lends to the creation of alternative stories such as CSA/VMI, Thomas Reed, the Hart tale, and so on?

 

[ECS]

Adding to the plethora of Beale story alternative versions is the book by Emma Jean H Rose, "Mystery Beneath THE BANEBERRY BUSH".

Concerning the three ciphers of Thomas Jefferson Beale, the description mentions that "only paper number two had been deciphered...however, a new story emerges in the deciphered pages one and three...from the Beale cryptograms built around the life of an actual person in an actual place".
Of course the "actual person" is not Thomas Jefferson Beale and the "actual place" is Bedford, Pennsylvania, NOT Bedford count Virginia.
Another example how the ambiguity of the original Beale Papers lends to creative alternative versions.

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Would you care to share your "opinion" in relation to the ambiguity of the narrative text of the Beale Papers that freely lends to the creation of alternative stories such as CSA/VMI, Thomas Reed, the Hart tale, and so on?

NOPE!

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Adding to the plethora of Beale story alternative versions is the book by Emma Jean H Rose, "Mystery Beneath THE BANEBERRY BUSH".

Concerning the three ciphers of Thomas Jefferson Beale, the description mentions that "only paper number two had been deciphered...however, a new story emerges in the deciphered pages one and three...from the Beale cryptograms built around the life of an actual person in an actual place".
Of course the "actual person" is not Thomas Jefferson Beale and the "actual place" is Bedford, Pennsylvania, NOT Bedford count Virginia.
Another example how the ambiguity of the original Beale Papers lends to creative alternative versions.

Haven't read it; NOT gonna... DON'T CARE! PA... BLAH!

 

[ECS]

YOUR opinion...

No, it's your opinion...

 

[Rebel - KGC]

INDEED!

 

[ECS]

Because of the ambiguity of the Beale story, and the very obvious fact that NO outside of the pamphlet's pages collaboration exists in support of the Beale treasure story, it could be CSA/VMI involvement or maybe plundered loot from Andrew Jackson's raids in Spanish in which James Beverly Risqué took part, or possibly Jean Lafitte, or Sheriff Otey killing Thomas Reed, or whater current speculation one can create.

Let us not forget the Jackson Ward Alderman of Richmond, Thomas J Beale , a free born man of color, that was linked to the Beale story due to the description of Beale and the mention of Richmond in the original Beale Papers of 1885.
Or the really far fetched concerning Mathew "Mexico" Sherman, a relative of John William Sherman, printer of the Beale Papers, who was the Captain of Patterson's ship, TORPEDO, and ran opium and guns for Stephen Girard...
Or the French "connexion" of Lallemand and Champ 'd Asile as the source of the Beale story.
It is amazing how a would be obscure dime novel pamphlet of 1885, if not for the Innis book, has generated so many speculative alternative version as the "actual" basis of the Beale perilous adventure treasure tale.