Yet ANOTHER Paterson N.J. "only known" rarity...

epackage

Bronze Member
Sep 16, 2010
1,970
2,327
Hewitt N.J.
Detector(s) used
Whites Silver Eagle
Primary Interest:
Other
Some of you may have heard thru the grapevine that I happen to collect Paterson N.J. stoneware, this LONG WINDED post is about my newest acquisition.


Back in 2010, about a year after I started collecting glass bottles, I got my first Paterson stoneware jug thanks to my mentor giving me a call about one being sold at a local sale at a record store of all places. Since that day I am now up to about 275 stoneware jugs and bottles from Paterson. My research thru the years led me to finding Adolph L. Schwarz having the largest liquor store in N.J. at the turn of the century, that's where this post becomes relevant.

While my first Paterson jug was acquired in 2010, it wasn't until July 1, 2012 when I acquired my first script Schwarz 1/2 gallon with the attractive diagonal name in cobalt blue glaze, with the ink stamped "REGISTERED" above the script and "PATERSON N.J. / THIS JUG NOT TO BE SOLD BELOW IT". Then in March 2014 I acquired the same style jug without any of the ink stamps, then in June of 2018 I acquired another jug similar to the first one, but "REGISTERED" was in larger hollow letters instead of the single line letters seen on the first jug.

By this time I was made aware a jug that had a cobalt stripe around the neck, I was also made aware of another 1/2 gallon jug with a body that was grey, and that had a cobalt top that went from the lip to about 1/3 the way down the jug, including the handle, thanks to a pic from longtime N.J. stoneware collector Henry Cross had sent me from his collection. So it became my mission to to hunt those "last two" know variants down so I could have a "complete set of 5".


Then a few weeks later in June of 2018 yet another "new variant" was offered to me by the owner of an antique shop here in N.J., he is a longtime friend of my mentor, and I couldn't get to the store fast enough. This now meant there were actually 6 1/2 gallon variants, and not the 5 I thought there were. On the base of the jug in black marker it says "J.E. Riley's / Vinager Jug", research showed he was a train engineer in Paterson, a central hub when it came to locomotive building in the U.S.A., needless to say I was elated, and it made me crave the 2 remaining jugs more than ever.


Well as luck would have it a Facebook friend I made from the area, who also happens to collect stoneware, shared a pic of the 1/2 gallon with the blue band around the neck in October of 2018. I didn't ask if it was for sale, nor did I offer to buy it, I simply said how nice it was and that it was one of two I needed to complete the "set of 6". The next day he was kind enough to offer it to me, and of course I jumped at the chance, leaving me with only the Henry Cross variant to find to complete the set. As luck would have it in May of this year a Facebook friend had PM'd me about a jug he saw at an antique show and sale about 1-1/2 hours from me the day before, he wasn't sure if it was still there, but I had to take the ride just in case it was. As soon as I walked in the pavilion the dealer was in there it was, I ran over and grabbed it, as I stood up I saw another SUPER RARE N.J. jug that I knew was of great value, but that's a story for another time.


Since it was late in the day I made a fair offer for the jug and the seller accepted, I cradled that jug like a newborn baby all the way back to the car, My "SET OF 6" 1/2 gallons from Schwarz was COMPLETE!! Or was it???


I tag 99% of my photos with "Paterson N.J. bottles wanted - [email protected]", this has lead to hundreds of emails over the years from people looking for values, or when I'm lucky, looking to sell what they've found. 3 weeks ago I got such an email from a niece woman in Maryland, and when I looked at the pics my jaw dropped, it also has the blue band around the neck, a short tailed "Z", and "A.L. Schwarz / Paterson / N.J.", a variant I have never seen, the only question I had for her being "How tall is it???" When she told me 9" I knew there were now 7 Schwarz 1/2 gallons, but I made sure to keep my composure until I knew why she had contacted me. It turned out she owned the jug for over 40 years, took it with her to all 4 houses she had owned, and had given it to a neighbor to sell for $10 at the neighbor's garage sale that weekend. LUCKILY the neighbor told her "this is not a $10 garage sale item", and told her to research it online.


Well her Google search brought up dozens of pictures of Paterson stoneware, 90% of which had my "Want Ad & Email" at the bottom of them. She asked for a value and if I was interested, and I was happy to tell her what I thought it would bring on Ebay and I made her an offer, which she very happily accepted. I was lucky enough that Facebook bottle collector Eric Gunn travels thru Annapolis for work where she lives, because she had never shipped stoneware before, and that scared us both, and Eric was kind enough to pick it up and ship it for me. Today it arrived safe and sound, it's as nice as the day it was made, but I will not "assume" this makes a "Complete set of 7" 1/2 gallon Schwarz jugs based on how this has all played out over the last 7 years. Paterson seems to be the land of never ending bottles and stoneware, and I'm very thankful and honored to have the majority of them...

$1 1aa111.JPG
$1 1aa1.JPG
DSC01092.jpg
 

Last edited:

villagenut

Gold Member
Oct 18, 2014
5,760
10,248
florida
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Congrats on your complete set.....until variant number 8 shows up. I could feel your excitement:thumbsup:
 

glass half fool

Bronze Member
Jul 17, 2017
1,042
1,862
North of the Mason Dixon line
Detector(s) used
White 5900DiPro
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Great looking collection! And a great adventure as to how you have come to own them . I worked for a stoneware company that has history back into the early 1800's . And even though I worked there a long time ,I was always impressed with how the different pieces where made .Congats on your continuing additions to your collection
 

jgas

Silver Member
Apr 23, 2008
3,793
2,469
Midwesterner
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
DFX, Pro 6000XL, SunRay Probe, Centech Pinpointer
A continuation of your museum quality stoneware. Awesome. Never ending is right E! Glad you don’t collect what I collect lol. Great stuff and congrats on furthering your collection. Jgas.
 

glass half fool

Bronze Member
Jul 17, 2017
1,042
1,862
North of the Mason Dixon line
Detector(s) used
White 5900DiPro
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
A continuation of your museum quality stoneware. Awesome. Never ending is right E! Glad you don’t collect what I collect lol. Great stuff and congrats on furthering your collection. Jgas.

I agree with that thought 100 % .But it is good to see someone preserving history . Once those rare old items are gone they are forgotten .
 

OP
OP
epackage

epackage

Bronze Member
Sep 16, 2010
1,970
2,327
Hewitt N.J.
Detector(s) used
Whites Silver Eagle
Primary Interest:
Other
I agree with that thought 100 % .But it is good to see someone preserving history . Once those rare old items are gone they are forgotten .
That is why I enjoy researching the merchants as much as owning their wares, the history is extremely important to me and those who read my post 100 years from now...
 

A2coins

Gold Member
Dec 20, 2015
33,807
42,606
Ann Arbor
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
3
Detector(s) used
Equinox 800
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Amazing great post Thanks for sharing
 

unclemac

Gold Member
Oct 12, 2011
7,009
6,893
Primary Interest:
Beach & Shallow Water Hunting
long winded is what we want. the back story with the pix is what keeps me interested. Have you noticed an uptick in prices since you started collecting? being over in the left corner i know nothing of these jugs but it sounds like they have quite a following in your parts.
 

OP
OP
epackage

epackage

Bronze Member
Sep 16, 2010
1,970
2,327
Hewitt N.J.
Detector(s) used
Whites Silver Eagle
Primary Interest:
Other
long winded is what we want. the back story with the pix is what keeps me interested. Have you noticed an uptick in prices since you started collecting? being over in the left corner i know nothing of these jugs but it sounds like they have quite a following in your parts.
Yes there has been an uptick thanks to a few deep pocketed collectors I know I getting involved, I expected them to stay level or drop a bit as two long time collectors got out of the hobby, but the new guys changed that. I am friends with one and competitive with the other, so when I lose out on something Paterson I want it to be my friend, because I end getting stuff to use in trades with him for stuff I need or want. The other guy thinks everything he has that I want is worth double what it truly is, but when I have something he really wants he thinks it's only worth half of what it truly is, frustrating to deal with to say he least.
 

No gold in NY

Bronze Member
Mar 22, 2015
1,688
2,921
Detector(s) used
Whites Coin Master,
Whites Gold Master GMT, Whites MXSport
High banker/dredge,
DIY hand trommel,
DIY Miller table,
DIY fluidbed gold trap sluice,
Keene A-52 A-52s
2186 Wheaties
Primary Interest:
Other
Hats off to you again e. Nice score.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Top