|
-
Feb 25, 2012, 11:29 AM
#1
Opinions please, Encrusted Silver Pine Tree Shilling from Saltwater
Hi All,
I got this encrusted PTS, looks like theres a solid core and some detail under there.
I am in a complete quandry as to how I should proceed.
NCS claims their methods do not result in a coin that grades 'Cleaned'
how can this be so  they describe soaking in various chemicals.
and their result here surely looks cleaned: http://forum.treasurenet.com/index.p...,369328.0.html
of course expect a hefty fee.
Sedwick also offers 'restoration' using 'proprietory methods' and specialize in shipwreck coins, @ $150 per hr.
I am now considering just soaking it for a few months and enjoying it as is,
though of course I would rather have a coin with more visible detail.
should I just do this: http://forum.treasurenet.com/index.p...tml#msg2688580
Does anyone have experience with 'professional' restoration of encrusted silver coins ?
I would really like to hear some opinions on how you all would proceed,
especially from those who recover coins in similar condition from saltwater.
thanks for looking  Herbie.
2013 Finds:
Iron, Lead, Aluminum, Pewter, Copper, Silver, Gold.
Rare Coins Recovered since 2-2012:
1640-54 Portugal Johannes IV 400 Reis, Undated and non revaluation example.
1652 Oak Shilling, Noe-3.
1652 Oak Three Pence, Noe-28.
1722 'Vtile Dvlci' Rosa Half Penny, Breen 132. He called it "Woods first prototype HP".
1796 US Half Cent, No Pole.
More to Come....
www.pinetreeshillings.com
-
Feb 25, 2012 11:29 AM
# ADS
-
Mar 13, 2012, 10:14 AM
#2
Re: Opinions please, Encrusted Silver Pine Tree Shilling from Saltwater
Oy vey! The potenial for such a great coin is there. Take your time in deciding how to proceed - don't rush it. I wish I could say "oh, that's easy just do..." but all I can say is take your time. It may be a while before you find the right method. Good luck.
-
Mar 14, 2012, 04:56 AM
#3
Re: Opinions please, Encrusted Silver Pine Tree Shilling from Saltwater
Thanks Fever87,
I appreciate your response,
seems that the options with a crusted coin like this
are 1) leave it alone
2) have it stripped with no patina left, either 'professionally'
or on your own.
I've had some communication with conservers of silver shipwreck coins
and this is the conclusion I've come too.
seems there's really no middle ground.
HH to you !!
2013 Finds:
Iron, Lead, Aluminum, Pewter, Copper, Silver, Gold.
Rare Coins Recovered since 2-2012:
1640-54 Portugal Johannes IV 400 Reis, Undated and non revaluation example.
1652 Oak Shilling, Noe-3.
1652 Oak Three Pence, Noe-28.
1722 'Vtile Dvlci' Rosa Half Penny, Breen 132. He called it "Woods first prototype HP".
1796 US Half Cent, No Pole.
More to Come....
www.pinetreeshillings.com
-
May 10, 2012, 10:30 PM
#4
CANE FIELD BANDITS and IRON BRIGADE MEMBER
Well, if you have it professionally cleaned, the end result is almost certain to be better than what you started with, unlike that NCS Indian Head in the link you posted. But go to someone who has experience with Saltwater coins! It Can be done. The thing is silver, so it should turn out well. Sedwick is what I'd do.
-Buckles
OUR 2012 YEAR END POST IS UP!! Check it out here:
http://www.treasurenet.com/forums/20...ml#post3120940
Spring 2013 CaneField Bandits Totals:
18th c. Engraved Silver Friendship Pendant
1722 Colonies Francoises French 9 Deniers Copper
"Le Bon Temps" Pocketwatch Winder
1774 Two Reales
1797 One Real
1831 Mexican Republic One Real
Four dateless Half Reales
1740, 1799, 1807, and 1811 Half Reales
1840-O Seated Half Dollar with MS details
1847-O Seated Quarter with AU-50 details
1838 Seated Dime
1840-O and 1853-O Seated Half Dimes
1824 Matron Head LC
Dateless Matron Head LC
Regiment of Artillery button (1811-1813)
1812 era Artillery button
One piece Eagle General Militia button(GI56)
1700s Navy Cuff Button
pre-CW Navy Cuff Button
GS Eagle Button
.31 cal. Brass Bullet Mold
1873, 186?, and 18?? Shield Nickels
1884 and 1905 V Nickels
1908-D Barber Dime
Trade Beads, Musketballs, Minieballs, etc.
Any relics, coins, or other items appearing in my finds signatures were found on PRIVATE PROPERTY with total consent and permission from the owners of said property.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
Search tags for this page
encrusted gold coins, encrusted silver coin, metal detecting how do you clean encrusted items, pine tree cent, pine tree shilling, pine tree shilling -, pine tree shilling cookies, pine tree shillings cookie, salt water encrusted coins, silver pine tree
Click on a term to search for related topics.
|
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Reply With Quote
