some idiot on craigslist

[jerseyben]

Sorry for the rant but I gotta share this so others can beware:

Long story short, I answer an ad on craigslist. Guy is buying Silver Dollars (Morgan or Peace) for $25 each for his kids. There are NO stipulations in the ad as to year or condition. He even mentions that his price is $3 over melt value. Sounds good to me to move some of my common dates (3 to be exact).

I email him and ask what is the minimum condition. He tells me he will pay melt value for the "junk" ones but never defines the term "junk". I email him back, if he wants to buy 3 common dates (one is an O mintmark) for the $25 he had in his ad. All 3 are VF-XF, none cleaned.

He responds, well silver dipped and he will only pay me melt plus 50 cents per coin. Claims his is the best price around even though I have to drive an hour to meet him. I knew it was too good to be true. Even though you can get comparable prices on ebay for even most fine condition common dates. Watch out for that crap, a "cash for gold" guy in disguise. End rant.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Family Maps of Hinds County, Mississippi, Deluxe Edition - Grab it through Amazon!

[Adventure Wolf]

I've been there and done that. Their all over now a day because the silver and gold prices keep going up.

 

[MentalUnrest]

Who puts an ad on CL and then expects someone to drive an hour to meet them? That is more ridiculous than him changing the price.

 

[SFBayArea]

Sorry for the rant but I gotta share this so others can beware:

Long story short, I answer an ad on craigslist. Guy is buying Silver Dollars (Morgan or Peace) for $25 each for his kids. There are NO stipulations in the ad as to year or condition. He even mentions that his price is $3 over melt value. Sounds good to me to move some of my common dates (3 to be exact).

I email him and ask what is the minimum condition. He tells me he will pay melt value for the "junk" ones but never defines the term "junk". I email him back, if he wants to buy 3 common dates (one is an O mintmark) for the $25 he had in his ad. All 3 are VF-XF, none cleaned.

He responds, well silver dipped and he will only pay me melt plus 50 cents per coin. Claims his is the best price around even though I have to drive an hour to meet him. I knew it was too good to be true. Even though you can get comparable prices on ebay for even most fine condition common dates. Watch out for that crap, a "cash for gold" guy in disguise. End rant.

He says your coins were dipped so he'll pay melt plus 50 cents? Dipping does not devalue any coins since they can be re-toned. Often if it's too good to be true, chances are they're not. I had a dealer low ball me once too. He quoted a price over the phone and when I showed up 2 hours later, he lowered his bid price. Although, getting 50 cents over spot is good for some average circulated Morgans.

 

[fistfulladirt]

Sorry for the rant but I gotta share this so others can beware:

Long story short, I answer an ad on craigslist. Guy is buying Silver Dollars (Morgan or Peace) for $25 each for his kids. There are NO stipulations in the ad as to year or condition. He even mentions that his price is $3 over melt value. Sounds good to me to move some of my common dates (3 to be exact).

I email him and ask what is the minimum condition. He tells me he will pay melt value for the "junk" ones but never defines the term "junk". I email him back, if he wants to buy 3 common dates (one is an O mintmark) for the $25 he had in his ad. All 3 are VF-XF, none cleaned.

He responds, well silver dipped and he will only pay me melt plus 50 cents per coin. Claims his is the best price around even though I have to drive an hour to meet him. I knew it was too good to be true. Even though you can get comparable prices on ebay for even most fine condition common dates. Watch out for that crap, a "cash for gold" guy in disguise. End rant.

He says your coins were dipped so he'll pay melt plus 50 cents? Dipping does not devalue any coins since they can be re-toned. Often if it's too good to be true, chances are they're not. I had a dealer low ball me once too. He quoted a price over the phone and when I showed up 2 hours later, he lowered his bid price. Although, getting 50 cents over spot is good for some average circulated Morgans.

Did he mean the price of silver dropped? Dang, at $30 I was ok to pay $25 ea. on Morgans/Peace.

 

[Hi Ho Silver!]

Find a dealer you trust and buy and sell there! Only other I trust is the US Mint if you are into collecting.

 

[DigginThePast]

Post em here:
http://forum.treasurenet.com/index.php/board,404.0.html

 

[Goes4ever]

I run ads on CL to buy coins all the time I pay under melt.....lol

 

[JD-GA]

Nothing wrong with advertising no Craigslist. Hate the bait and switch though.

 

[jerseyben]

I run ads on CL to buy coins all the time I pay under melt.....lol

There are tons of ads on CL advertising to buy coins under melt. I have no problem with this and I'm sure you get lots of business. This guy pulled a "bait and switch" on me. That's what I was ticked off about.