Loomis coins by any chance? I went through three by boxes of them with similar luck. 1 wheatie and that was that. Also, many of the coins were in terrible shape. The few 2009s I pulled looked god awful.
Dozer, I'm mostly just keeping them to fill books, since I still need all of the P ones. They do seem to be somewhat rare though, like all the other 09 coins. Really nice ones might be worth a little extra someday!
Pete, that's the way I feel, that just someday in the far future (30+) years, my grandkids might have some serious sleepers. I save all 2009 dimes & cents. Who knows?