what should you be able to buy an 1877 indian for in G shape ?

[Goes4ever]

My local coin shop has 3 in stock and I wanted to know what should you be able to get one for if it is graded G ? any clues?

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Diving for Pleasure and Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[Groovedymond]

My coin book (of last year) lists this coin at about $850 at good condition. My local coin shop is selling theirs for $1299. I suppose the price would have gone up a little in my book if I were to check this year's values.

Hope this helps.

 

[Goes4ever]

$1299 wow what grade is it?

 

[hyperion]

Are the coins slabbed or raw? Be very, very careful of a raw 1877 IHC. These have been widely counterfeited and some examples fool even the veterans. If they are raw, I would expect you could get one for between $500-600 graded G-4. My next step would be to send it in for grading and certification by a reputable firm (PCGS, NGC, ANACS) and if not genuine, return it to the dealer for a full refund. If they are slabbed by one of these firms, you would need to add about $100 to the above prices. What is the dealer asking for them?

 

[allen]

around here they where going for
about $1100 in good shape...

 

[Goes4ever]

where is the best best to have one graded and slabbed? I have never sent a coin in, so I need some advice on this one? When I look at different sites I get a bit confused on what I am gonna pay, looks like it is gonna cost 60-70 bucks at least with shipping both ways and their fee??

 

[PBK]

You might be better off buying one that's already been authenticated, graded, and slabbed by ANACS or PCGS. As noted, you'll pay a premium for it, but probably not a lot more (if any) than the cost of getting a raw one certified, plus shipping & insurance both ways. Also, this way you'll avoid the possibility of having the coin come back with an unfavorable report (fake, lower grade, etc.) and then trying to get a refund from the dealer.

 

[Goes4ever]

well the thing is I have bought from my local dealer for quite some time, I trust him and he gives me great deals. I have never found a coin dealer I have trusted. This guy I trust. To me that means a LOT. He is an honest guy, and I choose to deal with him. He showed me the ways to authenicate an 1877, I looked at the coin under a microscope and it is clearly not a fake.

 

[PBK]

That does make a difference!