1909S VDB, thoughts? Real? Grade? Value?

[buncle]

Just picked up this coin. I think it is gorgeous and genuine. I have taken many pictures, blown them up and compared online. What do you guys think?

1909 S VDB Cent - Imgur

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[Diggin-N-Dumps]

Man!!..That thing is a Beauty for sure, I hope for your sake it is the real deal. How did you get this coin if you dont mind me asking?

 

[buncle]

I'll tell the whole story in a bit after I get some responses. I don't want to sway anyone either way on their thoughts about the coin with the story.

 

[DeepseekerADS]

I'd say this must be true!!! You've been here over 3 years, and as I type this, you've only made 9 posts!

When I looked at the first pictures, I thought the mint mark was suspect. But then in the other pictures, my doubt was removed! It's all in the lighting, and thank heavens you had the multiple pics.

Appears to be REAL to me! Great find however you got it!

 

[Tedyoh]

The only thing I would question is why is it so clean and not more brown? I sure hope you have the real deal.

 

[dejapooh]

The S seems kind of Mushy to me. I would like to see a better close up of that S... Other than that, it is a great piece.

 

[jerseyben]

No red flags that I can see. I would lean towards genuine, IMO.

 

[bofusmosby]

A good closeup of the mint mark. They have gotten very good at adding a letter to an otherwise no mintmark coin. Remember, a 1909 VDB penny is of no great value. With an added "S", that would be a game changer. The mint mark needs to be inspected under a microscope to be sure. One more thing. They will sometimes drill a small hole in the rim of a coin and "raise" the metal to create a mint mark. Look closely around the rim area.

 

[Diggin-N-Dumps]

The mintmark doesnt look fake to me, it looks like the lighting is weird

 

[dejapooh]

I am still very suspicious of it. I do not trust how uneven it is. It is much thicker on the bottom. It very well may be real, but I would want to get papers on it.

 

[Diggin-N-Dumps]

I am still very suspicious of it. I do not trust how uneven it is. It is much thicker on the bottom. It very well may be real, but I would want to get papers on it.

I agree..if your spending what that coins worth, it better be certified

 

[buncle]

I took these at an angle some to try to get the lighting correct, so that may be throwing some people off. I plan on sending it in to either PCGS or NGC. It looks like if I sign up for their membership I can get 6-8 coins graded for around $25 each. I also have a 1801 Large Cent with the 3 errors on it that I will be sending it. Thanks for all who replied and I will try to get new photos up, plus obviously report back once I send it in for grading.

 

[Scrappy]

Everything looks correct, except for the 2nd 9. Hopefully it's just the lighting but it looks more flat than pointed.

Maybe not though, I looked at the other pics and it looks better in those.

 

[coinguy*matthew]

If you have a microscope and can get us a good clear close up of the mint mark I could identify without a doubt if its real or not. If this coin is indeed fake its a really good one, it has all the things others most often over look take a look at reverse all genuine 1909 S have whats called a shallow N.

FAKE

REAL

Also on your coin as well as genuine coins on the reverse the dot in between the D and the B will be in the center and not to one side.


FAKE

REAL

So after looking over your coin good its looking like you may have indeed a genuine coin but the last thing i like to look for is the die chip and that's why we would need the close up pics of the mint mark. I will also say that most of the real 1909 S VDB coins have already been slabbed making the ratio of fakes very very high and is why i seldom give these coins a second look.

Most if not all this information was learned from a member of a different forum and i simply cannot take credit so i must absolutely link to the more in depth guide here. https://www.cointalk.com/threads/how-to-tell-if-your-1909-s-v-d-b-is-real.78043/

 

[Buckeyedon]

On 1909 VDB S coins the top of the S is higher than the end of the tail on the first nine on the horizontal. And the S tills slightly to the right. On all the examples I have seen the original planchets have a wood gain type look and can still be seen though the flow lines. I would have it looked at by a local reputable coin dealer before sending it to be graded. It may come back in a body bag money wasted. Just my two cents worth. Life member ANA 6041

 

[buncle]

http://www.treasurenet.com/forums/coins/442826-update-1909s-vdb-thoughts-real-grade-value.html It came back real! MS62RB