I have had this coin for some time but haven't had a place to ask, until now. I hope someone out there can help me out. Is this somehow man made or is it an error. If man made, how did they do it. If error, how did it occur? Value?
I'm thinking PMD. Looks melted to me.
Interesting that they are both 1972 D. Does it have a value?
Its actually a Die break and its definitely legit I have seen others just like yours here is an example. This one sold for $440.........
Should I submit it to get certified or just try to sell as is?
Interesting that they are both 1972 D. Does it have a value?
Personally, I'd spend the money to have it graded. They will always command a higher price over a non graded coin. Especially on an error coin such as this. Also, a scammer could buy it from you ungraded, then claim it was post mint damage after he gets it, then send you back a different coin. Being slabbed eliminates this possibility.Should I submit it to get certified or just try to sell as is?
Personally, I'd spend the money to have it graded. They will always command a higher price over a non graded coin. Especially on an error coin such as this. Also, a scammer could buy it from you ungraded, then claim it was post mint damage after he gets it, then send you back a different coin. Being slabbed eliminates this possibility.
As everyone knows, I am usually for having a coin certified, graded and attributed (when an Error or Variety is involved) but it depends on the coin! In the case of the O.P.'s coin which will likely only grade as an Extra Fine, when compared to the MS-65 Brown specimen that was sold by Heritage, I just don't think the O.P.'s coin warrants the expense of $50 or more to possibly only fetch $100 to $150. I could be wrong and since the one that was sold by Heritage was sold almost 2 1/2 years ago, they both have surely gone up in value!
Frank
Personally, I'd spend the money to have it graded. They will always command a higher price over a non graded coin. Especially on an error coin such as this. Also, a scammer could buy it from you ungraded, then claim it was post mint damage after he gets it, then send you back a different coin. Being slabbed eliminates this possibility.