Toned Morgan and Walking Liberty

[RustyRelics]

My grandfather was a big coin collector from the 1960s, until he died. He had them stashed everywhere and I still find them when I go up to my grandmas house in PA. He had mostly junk silver, but he also had a few nice ones stashed away. I'm keeping those for sure.

Below, is a fascinating Morgan dollar that he had stuffed in a drawer for who knows how long. It has some amazing toning from maybe something that was in the drawer? I don't know how it got like that, but he had a few others like it that I left up in PA for now.






The one below is what I would call artificially toned. He was an experimenter of sorts, and he left this one in a cabinet with cleaners and solvents along with a few other examples since I'm assuming the 1980s or something judging by the age of he bottles. Honestly, how the man didn't burn the house down with those chemicals, I'll never know. The rainbow toning is spectacular, but I'm guessing artificial since I suppose this was the wanted end result.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!

[cudamark]

A lot of the early coin folders and other paper products were acidic in nature which can cause toning/tarnish on coins. You can also duplicate that yourself with various substances. Sometimes the results look nice, sometimes they look awful. It is corrosion after all, so, I wouldn't want to add any more to the coin than it's going to get naturally. It probably will detract from the value eventually.

 

[ArfieBoy]

I wouldn't purchase one for a collection like that... but, it sure is pretty!

 

[RustyRelics]

I wouldn't purchase one for a collection like that... but, it sure is pretty!

They're not my cup of tea, I like the black tarnish in the recessed areas kind of look. I might try to sell the Morgan or trade it for a cob or pistareen. I've been wanting one of those.

 

[WannaDig3687]

That walking liberty looks pretty cool. It would make a neat necklace, maybe, for mom.

 

[IDXMonster]

Where exactly did you say that house is? Pretty cool to go treasure hunting in the house! It might not be a “purists” cup of tea...but I like the look of both!

 

[RustyRelics]

Where exactly did you say that house is? Pretty cool to go treasure hunting in the house! It might not be a “purists” cup of tea...but I like the look of both!

At an "Undisclosed location" lol! He stashed stuff in the ceiling, in the walls, in the floor, buried stuff, hid it in the chimney, anywhere where he could store something, he did. I was on the phone with my grandma last year, and she said that he had a secret panel where he hid Japanese sniper rifles! He probably sold them, but it's another hiding place to search.

 

[ANTIQUARIAN]

Years ago I received a '41 Walker from my grandfather's estate after he passed.
It was pretty worn and had been cleaned years earlier, so it had little numismatic value.

I sent it to a guy in Virginia and had it made into a ring.
Dave

 

[bartholomewroberts]

That is very cool Dave.. I have thought that I would like to get one made...Perhaps

that would be something to do in these, the dog days of spring [as it were]

Micheal

 

[Swaveab]

Rusty Relics, don't listen to these guys as a very nicely toned coin can fetch far more value, not less. That Morgan is great and may command a high $ value so get it checked out. The walker is worn even though nicely toned and the toning there is negated by the wear on it. As was stated, they may have been in contact with papers or containers that reacted on the silver.

 

[Woodsy]

I agree, your grandfather did great with those. The toning is very nicely aged and people look for coins that have that natural toning.