Post By Sandman
Post By Dwight S
Post By Ace350
Aug 15, 2012, 04:54 PM
AT Pro vs AT Gold?
So, I took my ACE 250 out to hit some beaches this week and found my first gold! It was just a 10k white gold ring, but it gave me the itch to start hitting up beaches. I enjoyed walking the wet sand, but just a little ways out into the water was very tantalizing for me, and I knew I wouldn't be able to recover targets without risking my 250. So I have been considering a waterproof detector.
I know that both the AT Pro and Gold are waterproof which is one of the main appeals for me, along with the roll on audio. What I don't know and would like some help with are what are the trade-offs between the two machines? I would primarily be looking for coins and jewelry, though I would be open to relic hunting in the future if I found a good site.
Garrett had this chart comparing the two detectors:
AT Gold vs AT Pro | GarrettCentral.com
My questions are:
Being from Michigan, and having no saltwater around, what is the benefit of 18 vs 15kHz?
What is "True- All metal mode"? How is that different from no discrimination?
I'm also not really sure what Threshold Adjustment means.
If any of you Garret Gurus have any knowledge to impart on these machines, please share!
Aug 15, 2012, 06:03 PM
Director-Search & Recovery Team of Oakland County.
Hi Chris..... I am in Michigan now too and the main difference between the two operating frequency's is the higher one is better for id'ing gold nuggets of tiny sizes. The True All metal means the return signal doesn't have to go through so many filters. The Threshold adjustment is like a sliding scale that increases the threshold strength which is different than volume. Silent search detectors have to have a return signal strong enough to come thru the threshold strength. You would be lots better served with a true water detector like the 1280, or Tiger Shark since you won't be near saltwater and believe me these machines last a lifetime and don't false when holding them still as they are built like tanks. Your going to need at least two detectors to do it right and you only need one ring to pay for it.
Last edited by Sandman; Aug 15, 2012 at 06:05 PM.
(C) Sandman, 2005. All Rights Reserved.
"TIME IS THE ONLY THING YOU NEVER GET BACK, WHY WASTE IT SWINGING A DETECTOR THAT ISN'T UP TO THE TASK."
Aug 15, 2012, 08:09 PM
Alright, thanks Sandman, I will look into those detectors. Thanks for answering! As far as threshold goes, would the Ace 250 be considered a "silent search" detector? I guess I'm still fuzzy on threshold.
Between starting the thread and reading your post I went out and found a small ladies 14k ring! Slowly working towards paying off my 250 and propointer This was in a park setting though, no water to worry about.
Aug 16, 2012, 07:05 AM
I do believe the 250 is a silent search. I've never used one. If you don't hear a constant "hummm" between target hits, then YES it is a silent search detector. The silent search vs threshold was something I had to get used to coming from a White's XLT detector to the AT Pro. With a threshold you have a constant "hummm" that you will hear, you are listening for fluctuations and changes to the hum to indicate a target. Sometimes, you'll hear only a slight rise in the tone for a deep target. To start, I wondered if I was getting the depth with the AT Gold that I was accustomed to seeing with the XLT, but that was soon put to rest. With the Pro, you listen for the quiet hits. Turn the headphone volume high and listen... The All metal mode is essentially like hunting in pin-point. It removes all descrimination, and goes deeper. Yes, it can be noisey, but if you are relic hunting in a locaton that has been pounded for years by other detectorists, it is a very desirable feature to find those deep targets.
As for the AT Pro or AT Gold, if you don't see yourself using the detector in salt water, I'd go for the Gold. I like the thought of a threshold, the higher frequency and All Metal. The 5x8 coil is PERFECT for the detector, it has depth and allows you to hunt in trashy locations, picking out the good finds amongst the trash. The 9x11 coil on the Pro is fine in good, clean locations, but with lots of trash, the smaller coil shines and still goes deep. I have the Pro with the 5x8 & 9x11 coil, I live on the east coast and hunt salt water beaches, so the Gold won't work for me in salt water. After I got the 5x8 coil, I put the 9x11 coil in the cabinet and that is where it stays.
Good luck with your decision.
Anyone up for some Dirt Fishin?
Aug 16, 2012, 07:52 AM
Big Boys Hobbies
Originally Posted by Talon
You already have some great replies here! The Gold because of higher frequency is more sensitive to smaller lower conductors. The true all metal mode will give you more "punch" as well. It will have a threshold and on very deep targets you may not get a tone but a break in the threshold hum telling you something is there.
The Gold is HARD to beat! Give me a call with questions on either. I would love to answer all your questions and make you a great deal!
Aug 16, 2012, 08:17 PM
Well guys, as it turns out, I went with Sandman's suggestion on a bit of an impulse and bought a used Tiger Shark. It was a decent price and I liked the idea of being able to go snorkeling with it and not worrying about depth. I'll see how I like it and if it isn't working out, I might go back to Garrett. Thanks for the answers though guys, I really need to find a chart explaining all the acronyms and hot button words with the hobby!
Aug 17, 2012, 12:12 AM
Below is a graph showing the differences in depth using the sniper coil during an air test. The AT Gold can not be used in salt water, as it can't be ground balanced to that degree. The AT Pro can be used in salt water.
Wife + 4 kids (no grandkids yet)Orthopedics RN, photagraphy,writer, build electronic gizmos, previous hot air balloon pilot, coin collector for 40 years.
"METAL DETECTING IS A HOBBY AND HOBBIES ARE MEANT TO BE ENJOYED"
Aug 17, 2012, 08:00 PM
Those depths are with the small 4 1/2 inch coil. The 5 x 8 double d coils goes quite a bit deeper. I have found coins at 12 inches with the AT Gold in wet sand. No, there is no ID number, just a tone. I also found a silver dime at 8-9 inches in moderate soil. I was in Disc 1 and it gave a high tone and 82 ID number.
Where your heart is, there you will find your treasure.
O God of compassion, You alone can justify me and Your will never reject me when I, contrite, approach Your Merciful Heart, where no one has ever been refused, even if he were the greatest sinner. For Your Son assured me: Sooner would heaven and earth turn into nothingness than would My mercy fail to embrace a trusting soul.
Aug 17, 2012, 08:05 PM
That's a neat chart, it's nicely put together. Looks like the AT Gold edges out the Pro.
Aug 17, 2012, 08:05 PM
The AT-Pro is my choice if I'm hitting the beach and doing dry and wet sand.
One must be smarter than the equipment they are working with!
Apr 01, 2013, 05:34 AM
Keith Mooney -WP Member
both will find gold nuggets though right
Apr 01, 2013, 05:36 AM
No they won't as I've found them all.
Lol jk, yeah they'll both find el nuggitos.
Originally Posted by NJnuggetpirate
"The pieces of the Triforce are resonating."
Apr 02, 2013, 05:19 PM
They will both find nuggets, but the AT Gold will find sub gram gold.
Originally Posted by NJnuggetpirate
Apr 04, 2013, 03:27 PM
Keith Mooney -WP Member
By tymcmurray in forum Today's Finds!
Last Post: Oct 28, 2012, 12:02 PM
By dede1965 in forum Garrett
Last Post: Feb 16, 2012, 11:10 AM
By golden retriever in forum Beach and Shallow Water
Last Post: Aug 24, 2010, 08:13 PM
By ron lord in forum Beach and Shallow Water
Last Post: Aug 16, 2010, 05:39 PM
By JerV3 in forum Today's Finds!
Last Post: Jul 22, 2006, 08:31 PM
Search tags for this page
at gold vs at pro
at pro vs at gold
at pro vs at gold air test
at pro vs at gold depth
difference between garrett at pro and at gold
garrett at gold vs at pro
garrett at gold vs garrett at pro
garrett at pro vs at gold
garrett at pro vs at gold air test
garrett at pro vs gold
Click on a term to search for related topics.