Awesome find, Ang. Next time, please take a picture of it before you lay a hand on it to go with the cleaned up pic. That way, it's like we're there with you when you find 'em. I was thinking Etley. If that's your first one, you're off to a hell of a start!
I borrowed a book, Indian Artifacts of the Midwest, and I've poured over it for hours, but everytime I think I've identified it, I immediately question myself. I also found this brown one-could it be some sort of tool or is it one for my garden?