Need help with Indian ax

[cheech]

Pick these up the other day just wondering if they are genuine Ax head and if possible where they might have come from thank you

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

How to Research for Treasure Hunting and Metal Detecting From Lead Generation to Vetting - Grab it through Amazon!

[jmaschal]

Picked up? Can you provide more details? If purchased where? Any background? Better pics of both bits and close ups of the groove on dark one. They look good from a distance but they are often faked. I am more skeptical of the dark one.

 

[ToddsPoint]

I agree. The black one doesn't look right. The other two look good from where I sit. Gary

 

[joshuaream]

What do you know about the belt buckle? Fake Civil War relics and fake Indian relics are a combo I used to see at a
couple of shows.

One if the axes looks ok, but could be modern as well. One looks odd.

 

[cheech]

Picked up? Can you provide more details? If purchased where? Any background? Better pics of both bits and close ups of the groove on dark one. They look good from a distance but they are often faked. I am more skeptical of the dark one.

I bought them from an estate sale along with the US belt buckle the owner of the house was into metal detecting here is a few more pictures

 

[jmaschal]

I would lean to say yes on the axes. Nice ones if real deal. I see a lot of pecking and imperfections to indicate by hand. Just my opinion curious on other thought... I would have grabbed them.

 

[Reanm8er]

Say Cheech, Before judging the black axe too harshly see if a magnet will stick to it. If so, even slightly, it may be meteoritic iron. Very, very rare but they do exist. I have a piece in my collection that I accidently discovered was magnetic. Its very black and has a high luster like your piece. The deep black color comes from nickel that has been heated to a very high temperature. The reason it's, only mildly, magnetic is it's basically stainless steel. How in the world they ever shaped it is a total mystery to me. abrasion I suppose.
You won't have much luck searching for them on the net although once I found one on a Latin American auction site. About the size of the plate in your photo and brought a significant price. I attempted to find out who had confirmed the content but never got answer back. Nice Finds.

 

[vpnavy]

I pulled these from other TN threads...

United States Department of Agriculture
A Practical Ax Manual Brief History of the Ax. Here are a few pictures - a bunch more on the website

Axe Head (Mar 18, 2010)

Hammer (Better Pics) (Feb 20, 2008)
​

 

[georgia flatlander]

Great finds! Would love to hear about how you got them.

 

[cheech]

Say Cheech, Before judging the black axe too harshly see if a magnet will stick to it. If so, even slightly, it may be meteoritic iron. Very, very rare but they do exist. I have a piece in my collection that I accidently discovered was magnetic. Its very black and has a high luster like your piece. The deep black color comes from nickel that has been heated to a very high temperature. The reason it's, only mildly, magnetic is it's basically stainless steel. How in the world they ever shaped it is a total mystery to me. abrasion I suppose.
You won't have much luck searching for them on the net although once I found one on a Latin American auction site. About the size of the plate in your photo and brought a significant price. I attempted to find out who had confirmed the content but never got answer back. Nice Finds.

No luck with the magnet sticking thanks for the advice

 

[cheech]

Great finds! Would love to hear about how you got them.

I pick them up at a estate sale for $20

 

[arrow86]

I pick them up at a estate sale for $20

I think anybody with sense would have picked them up for that