Another season ..is this a joke?

[Mike Mercury]

Yes. Plenty of people on here would do the same and then as the rest of ya'll nik pic-ed their show to death like they are currently doing now, they would have a whole different attitude towards it..

exactly. We have threads specifically about Oak Island , and then threads specifically about the show... and those that don't like the show seem to be the most active posters in these threads.

On any other forum, that would be deemed "trolling", and dealt with.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[Singlestack Wonder]

No trolling. Just asking for actual, documented proof that anything was ever at oak island vs. the 200 year old hoax it has proven to be. Zero has ever been provided. Just fairy tales from investors seeking money...

 

[Ben Cartwright SASS]

Oak Island, the Lost Dutchman, the wagon of gold around Granby CT from the British, all these things keep dreamers going.

My wife refuses to watch since they will never find anything, I DVR it and watch while I am riding my exercise bike, it is either that or "Combat" or "12 O'clock High" Often I just fast forward through most of it. It is like watching Gold Rush, thank God for the fast forward!

 

[Bud Aurum]

No trolling. Just asking for actual, documented proof that anything was ever at oak island vs. the 200 year old hoax it has proven to be. Zero has ever been provided. Just fairy tales from investors seeking money...

Hey Singlestack, If the sisters can be believed and indeed the cross came from the money pit, and according to Dr. Lori, (Antiquities Specialist) the rose gold Christian cross from the Spanish indies is dated to 1550-1700 and missing it's emeralds. That is evidence of a past treasure.
Your Bud Aurum

 

[GarageSaleKing]

I have watched every Oak Island episode from the start. If the lady is correct, and they said she is from Penn State, the metal that was dated from 1650 to 1800 is proof that something else was or is there. Nobody dug that far down prior to 1800, except maybe the ones who buried the treasure. I guess I will have to wait till next year.

 

[Raparee]

Hey Singlestack, If the sisters can be believed and indeed the cross came from the money pit, and according to Dr. Lori, (Antiquities Specialist) the rose gold Christian cross from the Spanish indies is dated to 1550-1700 and missing it's emeralds. That is evidence of a past treasure.
Your Bud Aurum

Not really. Unless we can definitively prove that the cross came from the Money Pit, it's still just a story.

Also, I haven't seen the finale yet ... does the specialist describe how she determined that they were emeralds on the cross and not rubies, or diamonds, or glass?

 

[Charlie P. (NY)]

She has a Ph.D in Art History from Penn State. She is under hire of the History Channel. What's she going to say? "Nope, junk. Turn off the cameras and pack up, boys."

Dr. Lori | Ph.D. Antiques Appraiser | History channel

 

[gazzahk]

Nobody dug that far down prior to 1800, except maybe the ones who buried the treasure.

It is not the case that if pre-treasure seekers activity is discovered this means there must of been treasure hiders... For example J.Steele gives a plausible explanation for pre treasure seeker activity on the island. Even if there were treasure hiders the chances that treasure remains are pretty small.. People mostly hide treasure to come back and get it...

 

[alec]

It is not the case that if pre-treasure seekers activity is discovered this means there must of been treasure hiders... For example J.Steele gives a plausible explanation for pre treasure seeker activity on the island. Even if there were treasure hiders the chances that treasure remains are pretty small.. People mostly hide treasure to come back and get it...

Everybody hides treasure to come back and get it but we all know that lots of treasure still exist to this day all over the world because people didn't make it back to retrieve it. I think at one time there was more than one treasure on Oak Island and I believe there still may be treasure there but finding it will prove difficult because a majority of the real clues that were left behind have been destroyed by hole diggers, not actual treasure hunters, just hole diggers or they would have tried to use the actual clues to find what was there. I'm a big believer in Nolan's Cross and I think it can be used to get to something. It's a "simple" mathematical and geometric layout often used by the Spanish and the French not to mention several other groups.

 

[Stretch Da Truth]

I haven't seen the finale yet ... does the specialist describe how she determined that they were emeralds on the cross and not rubies, or diamonds, or glass?

Did you get to see it yet? I hope so as I don't want to spoil it for you.
She puts on her loupe and hems and haws a bit and then says "Yep, carnival crap!"
No seriously, she looks at it for a few and then gives her estimate of the date, kind of gold and all the jewels that were in it.

 

[Stretch Da Truth]

I'm a big believer in Nolan's Cross and I think it can be used to get to something. It's a "simple" mathematical and geometric layout often used by the Spanish and the French not to mention several other groups.

So do you think it is like Petter Amundsen said, Nolan's cross forms an image of the Tree of Life? The bros did try that out one time, dug up some stones that were flat on one side but like every other thing on the show, their ADD kicked in and they went and did something else instead of finishing.
Curious what you think as there is more to the cross, like the Bacon and Shakespeare stuff.

 

[alec]

So do you think it is like Petter Amundsen said, Nolan's cross forms an image of the Tree of Life? The bros did try that out one time, dug up some stones that were flat on one side but like every other thing on the show, their ADD kicked in and they went and did something else instead of finishing.
Curious what you think as there is more to the cross, like the Bacon and Shakespeare stuff.

Personally, I think the tree of life stuff is BS.
The cross has specific measurements and angles that I think are made to be used to find what you are looking for from a specific point on the cross.

 

[Stretch Da Truth]

Personally, I think the tree of life stuff is BS.
The cross has specific measurements and angles that I think are made to be used to find what you are looking for from a specific point on the cross.

So what theory or group do you tie the cross in with? What do you think it points/leads to?

 

[lokiblossom]

Personally, I think the tree of life stuff is BS.
The cross has specific measurements and angles that I think are made to be used to find what you are looking for from a specific point on the cross.

One pointer on Oak Island that is well documented is what was called the "stone triangle" and it pointed to a trail alongside the Gold River. This old trail led to Charing Cross, now New Ross. Easy to check out as there are drawings on-line.

Cheers, Loki

 

[Eldo]

Can you imagine the money they are making back thru tourism to the Country now.

No I cannot,

Neither as a Businessman,

Nor as a traveler to Nova Scotia and other parts of Canada.

Can I see the value in that type of wandering tourist trap for an American? NOPE

How much does a few hotel rooms for a few nights, a few meals at restaurants, and the munchies from the roadtrips and the pit stops bring from MAYBE a whopping 1000 people a year to the Island?

Do you think it brings in that much a year in TAX REVENUES back to the Govt? Or is that the GROSS value of the commerce.......the Govt gets but pennies of every dollar

To just hand out a grant that is supposed to be going to Canadian Filmmakers that produce valued landscape and cultural heritage videos......

The Nova Scotia Govt pumped out 1.25 mil.......on the erection of the Lagina fallacy.......to dig 4 holes and still not find their vault......how precise is that....bunch of Klutz's with heads so far up their own......you know the rest....



And the sad part is a Canadian is out of a job making films because they sucked up almost ALL of the grant in that fund, for one production.......hell that much could have made a film about every part of nova scotia for a full look at the province....

For footage they cant even use for Canadian Heritage or Education....its all given to them to help them film.......for their show to own the footage.

History wont pay for digging.....and Prometheus already scraped the barrel through the wood ......

These guys are extreme liars acting like they are now broke.....

If I was Canadian, I would have a thousand people there touring the island every day.......just to protest what is going on.......

They are lucky to get 1000 a year....to see their equipment laying around the site.....lol

 

[gazzahk]

Can I see the value in that type of wandering tourist trap for an American? NOPE

Do you think it brings in that much a year in TAX REVENUES back to the Govt? Or is that the GROSS value of the commerce.......

To just hand out a grant that is supposed to be going to Canadian Filmmakers that produce valued landscape and cultural heritage videos......

The Nova Scotia Govt pumped out 1.25 mil........

These guys are extreme liars acting like they are now broke.....

If I was Canadian, I would have a thousand people there touring the island every day.......just to protest what is going on.......

An interesting view... Oak Island is a fascinating part of Nova Scotia history.. It does seem reasonable that the government helps fund a 'serious' show about Oak Island. Before the Laginas started this effort there was doubt about wether a treasure could exist under OI (I think this doubt has well and truly been put to rest).

The question really is more are the Laginas being honest?... If so I think the government grant was justified. However if the Laginas are now misleading everyone simply to spin their show out into a 5th season then this could be considered close to fraud... The taxpayers deserve the truth as they have part funded the effort...

So to me that is the question.....

 

[n2mini]

Eldo,
Obviously The Canadian/Nova Scotia Govt. sees it much differently then you do, or they would not be doing it... year after year!!!!!

 

[Raparee]

I don't know, Eldo. If your claim that the show got $1.25 million from NS is accurate, then it can't be the majority of the fund, as the maximum allowable grant for any one production is $4 million (https://www.novascotiabusiness.com/sites/default/files/Guidelines-Nova-Scotia-Film-Fund.pdf).

Regardless, the show has brought money into the province... Irving Equipment, Huntley's Sub-Aqua, Valley Well Drilling, etc, etc, etc.... all local businesses that have been hired to work on site. I wouldn't doubt that the taxes paid by these companies, and the taxes paid by the employees of these companies, not to mention the other spin-offs, would more than pay back that $1.25 million.

 

[alec]

So what theory or group do you tie the cross in with? What do you think it points/leads to?

It would be impossible to tell what group left the cross behind without doing a lot of searching on the island to see what other clues may still be there that would help with identifying a specific group. Lots of people over the centuries have used math and geometry to hide things. You would have to figure out how the cross is to be used and then follow it to what ever it leads you to.

Based on the little bit of information I have gathered and playing with the layout I think the cross takes you to the exact location of the money pit. I also think it takes you to at least two other specific spots for unknown reasons. The additional measurements could be used as a map for the tunneling, telling you how deep to go before going horizontal. If there is a "treasure vault" connected to the money pit then the cross could also take you to a secondary entrance (possibly to bypass any flooding caused by digging in the money pit). I had mentioned to Marty Lagina that it could be possible the money pit was designed to hold back water, kind of like a cork and act as as a deterrent to the multitude of idiots that continued to dig in the pit past a certain point. Think of the money pit as a cup turned upside down and stuck into a body of water vertically. As long as the top and sides of the cup stay sealed the water remains out of the cup however, as soon as you put a hole in the top of the cup the air leaks out and the cup fills with water.

If this is the case then I feel the hiders of the treasure probably would have been smart enough to make a second hidden entry into the vault that completely bypasses any water.

Keep in mind I'm am pretty much making this up based on the limited information available on the internet and the show. I have never been on Oak Island and don't know what other clues may still be there however I have worked several treasure sites based on geometrical shapes like the cross which leads me to believe the cross is an actual and very important clue to something hidden on the island. Is it still there? I don't know but the chances of finding anything dwindle daily as people continue to destroy clues without sometimes even knowing they are clues. That's because these guys aren't treasure hunters, they are hole diggers with no concept of how treasure would have been hidden or how a site would have been laid out so that it could be found again without having a map in your hands.

 

[dieselram94]

I always watch the show. I like it, so I watch it. It's simple, if you don't like it don't watch it...why is this hard again?


Sent from a spun out toilet paper tube (one ply)!!!