I found this button in a celler hole on the banks of hudson river not far from sarratoga battle field.ive done some research and got as far as it being british and from the time of the sarratoga battle .i have found pictures of a few but they are in poor condition .this one is in great condition .any ideas if pewter silver .it was found in this condition .
In that condition, I'd think it'd have to be silver rather than pewter. Most of the pewter ones are in horrible shape after being in the ground. Could you post some close-ups of the button? This could be a phenominal find. Thank you for posting it!
-Buckleboy
Spring 2012 CaneField Bandits Totals: TEN Half Reales:
1740, 1777, 1784, 1796, 1801, 180?, 1806, 1807, 1808, and 1814
1836 8 Reales
A 17?? One Real
1819 Token/Jeton
Two "Russian Blue" Trade Beads
Henry Clay Campaign Button, 1820s or 1830s FIVE Early New Orleans Seated Coins:
1838-O Dime (no stars), Two 1839-O Half Dimes, an 1840-O Dime, and an 1842-O Half Dime
1892 Barber Dime
1918 Walking Liberty Half
1866 and 18?? Shield Nickels, and some GawGag V's and Beefaloes. Military Relics: Possible Spanish Colonial Era Cap Badge
FOUR War of 1812 Artillery Buttons
1820s Pewter Militia "U.S." Button
CW Eagle Artillery Cuff Button
CW Eagle Infantry Officer's Coat Button
3-Ringers, Enfields, Musketballs, and Shell Fragments
Any relics, coins, or other items appearing in my finds posts were found on PRIVATE PROPERTY with total consent and permission from the owners of said property.
sorry cant seem to get the pics to be any clearer .any help in finding out value would be appreciated .im new here and dont realyy know who to contact about it
OK .just heard from a Button collecter .seems what i thought could be a great find is more than likely a button that came off a reanacter .Its nice to find this out but still BUMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OK .just heard from a Button collecter .seems what i thought could be a great find is more than likely a button that came off a reanacter .Its nice to find this out but still BUMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Did the collector state why, what basis did he use to determine that, curious. I agree that it most likely is a reenactors button but would have liked to hear why a "collector" said so.
There is a master list of all the units that have known reenactors and the 24th is on that list btw.
"The mantra has always been don't clean a (copper) coin or it will lose value.
For undug coins this is true. For dug coins this is untrue.
The value will increase with judicious cleaning."
He said that the shank on he back would not have been solid as mine is .my question is did the soldiers ever mold and pour their own buttons .he mentioned that mine was a pewter remake but if it was in where i found it i would think pewter would have had more damage
He said that the shank on he back would not have been solid as mine is .my question is did the soldiers ever mold and pour their own buttons .he mentioned that mine was a pewter remake but if it was in where i found it i would think pewter would have had more damage
Well from what I can find out, a British 24th(which I think it more closely represents) would have had an iron loop shank and not an integral type, an the American 24th, which would have an integral type shaft I believe was of plain pewter and I saw none with any type of border around it in my references.
It is possible your reenactor button was made of a higher quality pewter, which would substain some time in the ground, which is most likely the case. I do think it is pewter and not silver, but hard to tell for sure from the photos.
Nice find regardless, but sorry it appears not to be the real thing.
Your question on a soldier casting his own, sure, but I am not sure it would be of that quality of pewter done in the field and if anything would have been done in lead or low quality pewter. I do not think that is the case, the button is of high quality and just has the appearance of newer.
"The mantra has always been don't clean a (copper) coin or it will lose value.
For undug coins this is true. For dug coins this is untrue.
The value will increase with judicious cleaning."
What are the odds of finding a modern 24th on the Hudson so close to the Saratoga battlefield ?? Unreal !
I have a farm site 'over there' adjacent to the battlefield and hunted it back 2002-3 and did pretty well !
Found a few buttons ,musketballs,and KG coppers....Really need to go back but the owner is hard to catch at home and its a 118 mile drive one way and well with high gas prices
Brad I think it's British too! And I think it's real too! But am not professional collecter. A few years back I hunted in that same area and found some nice relics. Love to make another trip up there soon. Maybe we and maybe Derek can get together and do some detecting.
Here is a few finds that Rodger & I found up there.
That's too bad but even just seeing the front on your other post I had my suspicions. Now that the back doesn't match it pretty much confirmed it as a repro. in my non-expert opinion.
To me it looks like they were copying the officer's pattern (silver on bone back) which would mean the reverse is drastically wrong. Damn if only it was old!!!
AMERICAN DIGGERS ON SPIKE: THE TRASH WE WOULD LIKE TO DISCRIMINATE OUT!
That's too bad but even just seeing the front on your other post I had my suspicions. Now that the back doesn't match it pretty much confirmed it as a repro. in my non-expert opinion.
To me it looks like they were copying the officer's pattern (silver on bone back) which would mean the reverse is drastically wrong. Damn if only it was old!!!
Correct, definitely a repro, probably made by Imrie Risley of Burnt Hills, NY near the Saratoga Battlefield. They made 24th buttons for the National Park in the 70s.
LinkBack URL
About LinkBacks
Reply With Quote
Originally Posted by bradgny
