For your sake, PLEASE DO NOT TALK TO THE POLICE

[Ocaliman]

First, let me preface this post by saying that I am a law-abiding citizen who feels very strongly about big government stepping on the toes of us little guys. I would not consider myself to be a "tinfoil-hat wearer" or anything to that effect, and I respect the job that law enforcement does each and every day to help keep us safe. But after reading some of the posts on here, I felt compelled to post something that I found on youtube a couple of years ago. The following is from a law professor and former defense attorney that talks about using your 5th amendment right against self-incrimination. The video is a bit on the long side, but for your sake, please take the time to watch it. I don't want to see any of my fellow treasure hunters landing in jail, losing their equipment, finds, and possibly more because you said something that you shouldn't have, even if you had nothing to hide.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[cudamark]

Even though I've never known of anyone getting ticketed, let alone getting thrown in jail, or having their equipment confiscated for detecting a legal site, I found this video very informative and interesting. Thanks!

 

[jeff of pa]

Video is too long & lawyers tend to ramble, so no thanks on the Vid.

Personally I already try to live my life by your title unless they talk to me first,
not even to Nark on people.

If it's a law Nazi asking, just call me Sargent Schultz




so just let it at that

 

[doc-d]

The video is well worth watching...........I am a law abiding citizen also.......never been arrested........
BUT we live in days where the rule of law if no longer, and the entire justice system in the US is rotten to the core.......yes there may be some, a few good people in it.......but far too many bad ones and far too many people who ignore bad things and allow evil to triumph......

 

[jeff of pa]

The video is well worth watching...........I am a law abiding citizen also.......never been arrested........
BUT we live in days where the rule of law if no longer, and the entire justice system in the US is rotten to the core.......yes there may be some, a few good people in it.......but far too many bad ones and far too many people who ignore bad things and allow evil to triumph......

Well until someone puts me on the "overpaid more then I'm worth list"
I do allot of ignoring

 

[Rich in Texas]

That guys is on point. When I went through the police academy, they taught us to elicit information. Any and all that could be used. The more you talk, the more likely they can get you on something. Even if you didn't do anything.

 

[Ocaliman]

If you do a search on YouTube, you will find a shorter version of this with just the attorney speaking. About halfway through the video I posted above, he turns the microphone over to a police officer who says pretty much what you said, Rich.

 

[golden ray]

Seen this video on 'you tube' before, and you are correct; its a real eye opener.
When I was in my teens(my trouble making years) I had to go to court, and the
arresting officer told the judge that I would not answer their questions, etc.
The judge asked the cop to read him the statute that said I am required to
answer his questions. The cop said that I must be guilty because I wouldn't
say anything. The judge dismissed the case.

 

[Sawyer]

If a police officer reads you your rights and then asks you if you understood them, and you say one word, you did not understand them!

 

[skeeter86]

I,ve found that if your first stop is the police station a lot of misunderstanding can be avoided.

 

[cudamark]

Your first stop should be the published ordinances for that particular piece of ground. Asking ANY public official is just asking for a no. Most don't even know what the law is and just go by their own whims and biases.

 

[Terry Soloman]

I guess I metal detect with too many cops to take any of this seriously..

 

[Treasure_Hunter]

I guess I metal detect with too many cops to take any of this seriously..

Just remember......

"Anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law."



We will NOT go quitely into the night!

 

[Tom_in_CA]

reply

I,ve found that if your first stop is the police station a lot of misunderstanding can be avoided.

Skeeter, this technique of asking at police stations, has come up before threads along this line. And yes, it stands-to-reason that the cops have BIGGER fish to fry, and are going to be less inclined to care less about something so seemingly innocuous. But question for you: what do you do if whomever your asking there, at the police station, gives you any of these type answers:

a) "No you can't". So you, the md'r, asks "where is that written?" or "what's the law/rule that says that?". And the desk-clerk at the police station cites something silly like "disturbing" or "vandalism" or "digging" etc... (even though perhaps you never even MENTIONED digging or anything, yet it's just some desk-clerk's go-to mental image). What do you do then ? Does this mean, therefore, that you can't? Perhaps detecting is just common-place already there amongst others, and no one's ever cared. So are they now somehow at fault or illegal, since you've gone and found yourself a "no"?

b) "go ask at the park's dept, as that's there jurisdiction to answer". So Skeeter waltzes off to the parks dept, and gets the same answer as (a) above.

So then, why can't a person just look up the laws/rules for himself? Why have to ask ANY live person ANYWHERE? I mean, if you would expect that their answer be based on some sort of real law or rule (rather than just whimsical opinion or mood), then that merely pre-assumes that they'd be having some sort of written rule or law to base their answer on ... TO BEGIN WITH. And that being the case, presto, YOU TOO can just look that up, rather than risk someone's arbitrary "no" or interpretation of things you let them morph to fit your "pressing question".

 

[cudamark]

I guess I metal detect with too many cops to take any of this seriously..

If my hunting buddies were a bunch of cops, I wouldn't ask either! Must be nice!

 

[Chug And Red]

I and / or We Chug and Red, Have been approached Over 12 time By The Police And Never Have Had Any Problems!!! Remember Only Hunt Where You Are Allowed, Always Be Respectful Of Others And The Area you are Hunting!!!

When An Officer Approaches, Be nice and Ask what Is Going on!!!! Most of the Time It is They are Coming Over to See How you are Doing On your Hunt!!! Show Them the Dangerous Stuff you are Removing From the Grass, Sand Playground Chips First, Then Show Them A Few Coins!!!

Once In A While It's that they Received A Call only three time So Far!!!! for Us Usually it A Nosy Busybody the Complains And The Officer is Just Going through the Motions!!!

I Repeat the Process Again

Show Them the Dangerous Stuff you are Removing From the Grass, Sand, Playground Chips Then Show Them A Few Coins!!!

HH Chug and Red

 

[smokeythecat]

Funny, I have never ever ever ever hunted anything but farms and my own property. ALWAYS with permission. Never wanted to hunt a park. Figured I'd just get yelled at or something. I found out this year it's illegal in my county, so probably better I hadn't hunted any parks.

 

[cudamark]

You can look it up for yourself and find out for sure. You might be pleasantly surprised! Not all county (or city, state, federal for that matter) property is under the same laws.

 

[lisfisher]

Posted by cudamark: "Asking ANY public official is just asking for a no. Most don't even know what the law is and just go by their own whims and biases."

I agree 100%. They do NOT know. I tend to detect anywhere there are NOT any posted signs, { aside from obvious private properties } or in obvious high profile places where I could be asking for trouble. Been at this for 20 years and never been bothered. Asking any public official or Poice officer is asking for a no. If by some chance I am asked to leave, then I will politely do so. Aside from that, this is one of those hobbies where keeping your mouth shut can only do you good, just my humble opinion.

 

[Red James Cash]

even if you had nothing to hide.

Unfortunately now a days it isnt up to you to decide whether or not you have anything to hide.Guilty until proven innocent.