LIVE IT UP, BY GEORGE!
I located this "Long Live the President" button while searching along an old lane. I know it's a rare Washington Inaugural- Albert # WI 18 A, Fifteen Star Pattern, 20 mm, rated R7- but as you can see, the front is corroded and pitted, although it's readable, and the shank is missing from the back. I was just wondering if you think it's worth telling anyone about it.
You just did! And yes, condition notwithstanding, it's an important discovery in terms of documentation of the Washington Inaugurals. Unfortunately, it's also a classic case of the great divide between historians, who will no doubt find it appealing; and collectors, who are sure to call it appalling. In a highly publicized auction last year, the smaller, 15 mm variety of the same button in Extremely Fine condition brought a staggering $17,000. How much might yours fetch? I asked both a buttons specialist and a professional appraiser of Americana, and their best estimates were nearly identical- $1,000-1,200. Of course, there's always an outside chance that its extreme rarity would persuade someone to ignore its problems and offer far more. You may also be wondering whether an expert conservator could enhance its eye appeal and marketability. Possibly, but attempting to "improve" any rare piece is a serious risk at best, and there's no undoing the outcome. My advice? Keep it as is, and let its next owner make that decision.
|