IDENTITY CRISIS
A good friend of mine uncovered this shield-shaped brass tag while detecting in Indianola, Texas. The front has an eagle on it, and the name "W. M. FROBESE." On the back is "PAT. DEC 29, 1868" and the number "27." Can you help us out on this one?
Often sold by mail order, personal identification tags like this one were common not only during the last half of the 19th century, but at least as late as the 1930s. Unfortunately, your friend's find is a "maverick," bearing no indication of the city and state in which the owner resided; so, any attribution must be based on circumstantial evidence and conjecture. Having said that, I can tell you that Indianola, the town where it was found, was once the home of William Frobese, a prominent businessman of the late 1800s. Born in Germany in 1838, he came to Texas in 1859 and became a partner in-and eventually president of- Runge & Co., a banking and mercantile firm. Some years later, when a hurricane devastated Indianola, he and his family moved to Cuero, Texas. What's more, they took their house with them, having it dismantled, transported by ox cart, and then reassembled at 305 East Newman in Cuero. Named a Texas Historical Landmark in 1970, the home is reportedly still owned by Frobese's descendants. Did this tag belong to William Frobese? My guess is yes, but there's no way to prove it. I located no listings for him which included the initial M, as on the tag; but one plausible explanation is that the W. M. was intended to be read as Wm., an abbreviation for William. I should mention, too, that in some texts he's referred to as William Frobese, Sr.; so, it's also conceivable that the tag was his son's. Obviously, with these unanswered (if not unanswerable) questions, an estimate of value is impossible.
Incidentally, you and other readers in the region might like to know that Frobese and a partner, Emil Reiffert, Sr., issued trade tokens for their business in Runge, Texas. Our thanks to Texas tokens specialist Travis Roberts for providing these fine photos:

|