✅ SOLVED 12pdr Napoleon solid shot?

Matej

Newbie
Nov 14, 2024
4
9
Hi,

a few days ago I recived 12pdr Napoleon solid shot. What would you say, is it original? I asked this question on a few FB groups and the replies said it is original, but I would also appreciate your opinions. I bought it from civil war relic shop trough their website, where it says that it was found (excavated) in northern Verginia. The cannonball has quite a lot of pitting all around. You can barely see the mold seam. 90° from mold seam is a really small flat area or depression (about 0.6 inch) which I belive is where the mold vent was. Maybe the molten iron there collapsed a little while cooling? (Or is just heavier pitting). Otherwise is nicely round. The ball is a little lighter at 11.68 pounds (5.3-5.4 kg on a bathroom scale) maybe due to heavy pitting, air bubbles inside cannonbal (casting flaw) or exposure to acidic groundwater? The diameter is also a little smaller at 14.46 inches, but probably because of a lot of pitting?

Thanks, and have a great day!
 

Attachments

  • 20241104_195544.jpg
    20241104_195544.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 25
  • 20241104_195224.jpg
    20241104_195224.jpg
    462.3 KB · Views: 10
  • 20241104_195840.jpg
    20241104_195840.jpg
    841.8 KB · Views: 11
  • 20241106_154641.jpg
    20241106_154641.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 10
  • 20241104_195138.jpg
    20241104_195138.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 9
  • 20241104_194919.jpg
    20241104_194919.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 8
  • 20241104_194908.jpg
    20241104_194908.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 8
Solution
Matej, your correction of the ball's diameter measurement puts it back in the ballpark for a 12-Pounder caliber cannonball. Congratulations, your purchase is the real thing.

Let me also say, somebody educated you real good with several reasons why a genuine cannonball's diameter-&-weight measurements can be a bit "off" from the US 1861 Ordnance Manual's specifications. (12-Pounder = 12 lb 4 oz and diameter 4.52-inches.) Civil war cast-iron was notoriously porous, typically containing many internal casting-flaw airbubbles. Though the bubbles are usually small, the cast metal can contain enough of them to reduce a 12-Pounder ball's weight by several ounces. Due to the internal airbubbles, a genuine cannonball can be "too light"...
Hi,

a few days ago I recived 12pdr Napoleon solid shot. What would you say, is it original? I asked this question on a few FB groups and the replies said it is original, but I would also appreciate your opinions. I bought it from civil war relic shop trough their website, where it says that it was found (excavated) in northern Verginia. The cannonball has quite a lot of pitting all around. You can barely see the mold seam. 90° from mold seam is a really small flat area or depression (about 0.6 inch) which I belive is where the mold vent was. Maybe the molten iron there collapsed a little while cooling? (Or is just heavier pitting). Otherwise is nicely round. The ball is a little lighter at 11.68 pounds (5.3-5.4 kg on a bathroom scale) maybe due to heavy pitting, air bubbles inside cannonbal (casting flaw) or exposure to acidic groundwater? The diameter is also a little smaller at 14.46 inches, but probably because of a lot of pitting?

Thanks, and have

Hi,

a few days ago I recived 12pdr Napoleon solid shot. What would you say, is it original? I asked this question on a few FB groups and the replies said it is original, but I would also appreciate your opinions. I bought it from civil war relic shop trough their website, where it says that it was found (excavated) in northern Verginia. The cannonball has quite a lot of pitting all around. You can barely see the mold seam. 90° from mold seam is a really small flat area or depression (about 0.6 inch) which I belive is where the mold vent was. Maybe the molten iron there collapsed a little while cooling? (Or is just heavier pitting). Otherwise is nicely round. The ball is a little lighter at 11.68 pounds (5.3-5.4 kg on a bathroom scale) maybe due to heavy pitting, air bubbles inside cannonbal (casting flaw) or exposure to acidic groundwater? The diameter is also a little smaller at 14.46 inches, but probably because of a lot of pitting?

Thanks, and have a great day!
TheCannonballGuy is who you want to wait for. He can identify every true projectile and weed out the fake ones
 

Upvote 3
Matej, your correction of the ball's diameter measurement puts it back in the ballpark for a 12-Pounder caliber cannonball. Congratulations, your purchase is the real thing.

Let me also say, somebody educated you real good with several reasons why a genuine cannonball's diameter-&-weight measurements can be a bit "off" from the US 1861 Ordnance Manual's specifications. (12-Pounder = 12 lb 4 oz and diameter 4.52-inches.) Civil war cast-iron was notoriously porous, typically containing many internal casting-flaw airbubbles. Though the bubbles are usually small, the cast metal can contain enough of them to reduce a 12-Pounder ball's weight by several ounces. Due to the internal airbubbles, a genuine cannonball can be "too light" (according to the Manual), but it will never be "too heavy" (correct diameter but weighs more than the Ord. Manual says) -- unless somebody filled its cavity full of a much heavier metal, such as lead.

The "Shot Tables" in the US Ordnance Manual of 1861 can be viewed for free online at
www.civilwarartillery.com/shottables.htm
The Shot Tables contain very precise diameter and weight measurement data for cannon balls, Grapeshot balls, and Canister-ammo balls.

Your observation is correct... the shallow depression you are seeing at 90 degrees from the mold seam is the mold's vent-hole mark. The molten iron at that spot often collapsed a bit at it cooled.

You sound like a good student. Sorry to have to say, I'm mostly retired from doing relic identification & authentification, due to major health issues.

Still praying for a miracle, though. My thanks go out to anybody who has been praying in Agreement with me.
 

Last edited:
Upvote 12
Solution
Matej, your correction of the ball's diameter measurement puts it back in the ballpark for a 12-Pounder caliber cannonball. Congratulations, your purchase is the real thing.

Let me also say, somebody educated you real good with several reasons why a genuine cannonball's diameter-&-weight measurements can be a bit "off" from the US 1861 Ordnance Manual's specifications. (12-Pounder = 12 lb 4 oz and diameter 4.52-inches.) Civil war cast-iron was notoriously porous, typically containing many internal casting-flaw airbubbles. Though the bubbles are usually small, the cast metal can contain enough of them to reduce a 12-Pounder ball's weight by several ounces. Due to the internal airbubbles, a genuine cannonball can be "too light" (according to the Manual), but it will never be "too heavy" (correct diameter but weighs more than the Ord. Manual says) -- unless somebody filled its cavity full of a much heavier metal, such as lead.

The "Shot Tables" in the US Ordnance Manual of 1861 can be viewed for free online at
www.civilwarartillery.com/shottables.htm
The Shot Tables contain very precise diameter and weight measurement data for cannon balls, Grapeshot balls, and Canister-ammo balls.

Your observation is correct... the shallow depression you are seeing at 90 degrees from the mold seam is the mold's vent-hole mark. The molten iron at that spot often collapsed a bit at it cooled.

You sound like a good student. Sorry to have to say, I'm mostly retired from doing relic identification & authentification, due to major health issues.

Still praying for a miracle, though. My thanks go out to anybody who has been praying in Agreement with me.
Thank you for your reply and I hope your health improves soon.
 

Upvote 1

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top