Help identifying what looks to be a buffalo lance? Found in my grandfathers indian artifact box.

epiccow400

Tenderfoot
Jun 17, 2022
5
32
Rural Illinois
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
4C9F2040-0D51-4000-8B86-CB7BD530BB68.jpeg
BA9BA105-87FB-4D3B-B70D-98B150D978E9.jpeg
Hello, ive found this along with all of my grandfathers old indian relics. Ive done a little research and the closest thing i see to it is a buffalo lance? Can one of you guys with more knowledge please give your input? Is it a buffalo lance? Thanks.
 

Upvote 9

RustyRelics

Gold Member
Apr 5, 2019
5,906
32,358
Central PA
Detector(s) used
Equinox 600/Ancient Whites MXT
Primary Interest:
Relic Hunting
I don't know about Buffalo Lance, as most terms like that are fabricated by sellers looking to make a big bang for their buck, but what you DO have is a very rare, and amazing example of a ceremonial blade from a culture that figured out how to make copper objects. Do you know where your grandfather found it, or where most of his artifacts come from?
 

dognose

Silver Member
Apr 15, 2009
2,906
7,830
Indiana
Detector(s) used
Fisher F70
Very interesting.

What are the dimensions?

When laid on a table, does it lay flat? Any curvature to it?

Using a loop on this, do you see any faint lines?

What is the material? Is it copper, iron? what does a magnet do when held to it?

It could be made from hammered copper as RustyRelics referred to. Or it could be made from a repurposed large file. Or more likely a repurposed wagon wheel band. wagon wheels where made from wood, the hub, spokes and rim. On the outer rim was a band of iron fused together by a blacksmith.

If this is an authentic early historic relic, it could be rare.

I suggest taking to a relic show and get some opinions from others there. Find some locations here https://csasi.org/calendar_of_events_current.htm

I am sure some would give opinions. Take them for what they may be worth. Remember everybody has an opinion on things.
 

Older The Better

Silver Member
Apr 24, 2017
3,088
5,695
south east kansas
Detector(s) used
Whites Eagle Spectrum
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Hard to say without giving it a good look but from here my first impression is it’s authentic. If so that’s very cool, I’d lean to a trade era item vs copper culture but I also don’t have any experience with copper culture artifacts so I may be biased to trade items.
 

pepperj

Gold Member
Feb 3, 2009
37,021
136,958
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
Deus, Deus 2, Minelab 3030, E-Trac,
Primary Interest:
Relic Hunting
It looks like it could be made of a bronze/brass material.
The tip is folded back (curled) so it could be of a softer material.
For some reason the design looks more from what comes out of ancient Europe.
 

joshuaream

Silver Member
Jun 25, 2009
3,170
4,481
Florida & Hong Kong
A knowledgeable collector/moderator on another forum suggested checking it with a magnet. It looks iron based to me.

Buffalo lances were a historic artifact used by the Plains Indian groups that used horses. Some "fakes" are historic African spears that are simply passed off as Buffalo lances. Others are Spanish relics from Mexico/South America where Calvary troops used lances into the 1900's. Many others are simply decorative items that just look old. And then there are replicas made to deceive, but the higher dollars with historic artifacts tend to come with histories that tie an item to a specific person or to a battlefield. And with historic stuff the organic components are often still present. (Wood, leather, feathers, etc.)

Pinning down historic relics is a specialized area. It's a lot easier to create rust on a piece of iron than it is to create patina on flint, and the experts who know that stuff are typically looking at a lot of small details that I don't really get/observe. (Type of iron/steel, file marks, etc.)

The only expert on both prehistoric and historic items that I've ever known was John Baldwin. Forest Fenn also collected both areas, but he was more of an expert on the historic stuff. The dollar values on the historic stuff can also go higher, quicker than they do for prehistoric things.
 

Riverbum

Sr. Member
Jul 13, 2011
297
577
Colorado
Detector(s) used
Whites
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
A knowledgeable collector/moderator on another forum suggested checking it with a magnet. It looks iron based to me.

Buffalo lances were a historic artifact used by the Plains Indian groups that used horses. Some "fakes" are historic African spears that are simply passed off as Buffalo lances. Others are Spanish relics from Mexico/South America where Calvary troops used lances into the 1900's. Many others are simply decorative items that just look old. And then there are replicas made to deceive, but the higher dollars with historic artifacts tend to come with histories that tie an item to a specific person or to a battlefield. And with historic stuff the organic components are often still present. (Wood, leather, feathers, etc.)

Pinning down historic relics is a specialized area. It's a lot easier to create rust on a piece of iron than it is to create patina on flint, and the experts who know that stuff are typically looking at a lot of small details that I don't really get/observe. (Type of iron/steel, file marks, etc.)

The only expert on both prehistoric and historic items that I've ever known was John Baldwin. Forest Fenn also collected both areas, but he was more of an expert on the historic stuff. The dollar values on the historic stuff can also go higher, quicker than they do for prehistoric things.
I get the feeling its a Lance point , possibly a Mexican Solider's Lance Point but it might be a little heavy for that(I obviously don't know the weight of that one). I believe your right about it being a possible Calvary solider's. Its said they were so good using those that they could carve their initials into trees while sitting Horseback, that's got to be a little tough when the blade is mounted on a pole, Just speculation on my part.
 

11KBP

Hero Member
Oct 7, 2008
745
906
Central Great Plains
What part of North America was it found?

The patina on this particular piece and photo in general make it somewhat difficult to ID the material. However, as others have said, it appears it is made of iron rather than copper which would put it in the historic trade period.

If you could post pics of some of your grandfathers other relics it might be possible to narrow down the region where he hunted …assuming they are personal finds.
 

sawmill man

Hero Member
Jun 12, 2016
719
1,074
KENTUCKY
Primary Interest:
Relic Hunting
Look for hammer marks , any black smith made tools will show slight hammer work , move it around with different light angles, the long sanding grooves on the blade make it iffy for me , but thats just my opinion . im leaning toward a home made dagger , the tang and handle are typical looking file work for a armature knife maker . but thats my opinion. i would still have it looked at.
 

OP
OP
epiccow400

epiccow400

Tenderfoot
Jun 17, 2022
5
32
Rural Illinois
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Very interesting.

What are the dimensions?

When laid on a table, does it lay flat? Any curvature to it?

Using a loop on this, do you see any faint lines?

What is the material? Is it copper, iron? what does a magnet do when held to it?

It could be made from hammered copper as RustyRelics referred to. Or it could be made from a repurposed large file. Or more likely a repurposed wagon wheel band. wagon wheels where made from wood, the hub, spokes and rim. On the outer rim was a band of iron fused together by a blacksmith.

If this is an authentic early historic relic, it could be rare.

I suggest taking to a relic show and get some opinions from others there. Find some locations here https://csasi.org/calendar_of_events_current.htm

I am sure some would give opinions. Take them for what they may be worth. Remember everybody has an opinion on things.
Hard to say without giving it a good look but from here my first impression is it’s authentic. If so that’s very cool, I’d lean to a trade era item vs copper culture but I also don’t have any experience with copper culture artifacts so I may be biased to trade items.
A knowledgeable collector/moderator on another forum suggested checking it with a magnet. It looks iron based to me.

Buffalo lances were a historic artifact used by the Plains Indian groups that used horses. Some "fakes" are historic African spears that are simply passed off as Buffalo lances. Others are Spanish relics from Mexico/South America where Calvary troops used lances into the 1900's. Many others are simply decorative items that just look old. And then there are replicas made to deceive, but the higher dollars with historic artifacts tend to come with histories that tie an item to a specific person or to a battlefield. And with historic stuff the organic components are often still present. (Wood, leather, feathers, etc.)

Pinning down historic relics is a specialized area. It's a lot easier to create rust on a piece of iron than it is to create patina on flint, and the experts who know that stuff are typically looking at a lot of small details that I don't really get/observe. (Type of iron/steel, file marks, etc.)

The only expert on both prehistoric and historic items that I've ever known was John Baldwin. Forest Fenn also collected both areas, but he was more of an expert on the historic stuff. The dollar values on the historic stuff can also go higher, quicker than they do for prehistoric things.
What part of North America was it found?

The patina on this particular piece and photo in general make it somewhat difficult to ID the material. However, as others have said, it appears it is made of iron rather than copper which would put it in the historic trade period.

If you could post pics of some of your grandfathers other relics it might be possible to narrow down the region where he hunted …assuming they are personal finds.
Look for hammer marks , any black smith made tools will show slight hammer work , move it around with different light angles, the long sanding grooves on the blade make it iffy for me , but thats just my opinion . im leaning toward a home made dagger , the tang and handle are typical looking file work for a armature knife maker . but thats my opinion. i would still have it looked at.
Thank you all for the info, My grandfather found most of his artifacts by seeing them while farming in rural Illinois and in Wyoming, but truthfully this could of come from anywhere as he has a lot of this kind of stuff. Here are alot better photos, it is very magnetic.
 

Attachments

  • 86CDD28A-51B9-4274-98B6-786D2B5CA2AB.jpeg
    86CDD28A-51B9-4274-98B6-786D2B5CA2AB.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 66
  • F487375A-97C6-4774-B48C-86176AB4EFDB.jpeg
    F487375A-97C6-4774-B48C-86176AB4EFDB.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 67
  • 402C624C-58B6-42B3-BD3F-C7D808D4114E.jpeg
    402C624C-58B6-42B3-BD3F-C7D808D4114E.jpeg
    1.5 MB · Views: 68
  • BED62AE4-9016-4241-A5BA-A683E175CB14.jpeg
    BED62AE4-9016-4241-A5BA-A683E175CB14.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 71
  • 6077DCFB-A5C7-4383-AFD2-28154DE3722F.jpeg
    6077DCFB-A5C7-4383-AFD2-28154DE3722F.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 76
  • C9C6FBFC-DDAA-4B6A-B36F-29AD8B87DE55.jpeg
    C9C6FBFC-DDAA-4B6A-B36F-29AD8B87DE55.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 79
  • 513EDC1C-40E9-4D4D-8A1B-AC636684A225.jpeg
    513EDC1C-40E9-4D4D-8A1B-AC636684A225.jpeg
    1.9 MB · Views: 79
  • 4D282E18-D13B-43CC-9666-AF6167708435.jpeg
    4D282E18-D13B-43CC-9666-AF6167708435.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 69
  • B77599EC-1557-4E68-A139-F0A7DB694C8D.jpeg
    B77599EC-1557-4E68-A139-F0A7DB694C8D.jpeg
    1.5 MB · Views: 68
  • 11FD9083-4F9F-43BF-95A7-85EB4632F26F.jpeg
    11FD9083-4F9F-43BF-95A7-85EB4632F26F.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 63
  • A0E83873-015A-4ED8-A028-4BBDDEB33FB3.jpeg
    A0E83873-015A-4ED8-A028-4BBDDEB33FB3.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 59
  • AA061516-040E-47D2-9D23-AB823466708F.jpeg
    AA061516-040E-47D2-9D23-AB823466708F.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 51
  • 9E360F8C-C457-4778-BDF8-555D8DA7FA95.jpeg
    9E360F8C-C457-4778-BDF8-555D8DA7FA95.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 52
  • 8F69E51A-187B-438D-8AA0-8EB866598638.jpeg
    8F69E51A-187B-438D-8AA0-8EB866598638.jpeg
    1.5 MB · Views: 51
  • 9160EAC7-7A11-4B9E-ACC0-4AEA595932C8.jpeg
    9160EAC7-7A11-4B9E-ACC0-4AEA595932C8.jpeg
    1.3 MB · Views: 53
  • 0A36F0C8-8E71-4790-B2F7-C9AD408C83D4.jpeg
    0A36F0C8-8E71-4790-B2F7-C9AD408C83D4.jpeg
    1.4 MB · Views: 68

Rege-PA

Hero Member
Jul 13, 2007
620
328
A very nice piece.
After seeing these latest images I have no doubt about its authenticity and it could well be a trade lance from the northern Plains.
I like it, looks to be iron......old iron like a black smith would work. The weathering is authentic, I think it is, what you think it is, an Indian lance. Your Gpa did good, display it proudly.
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Top