Is this a real meteorite? help please!

[derin105]

This is claimed to be a Nantan meteorite. it weighs approximately 2800Grams. It is fully magnetic

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Agony and Death on a Gold Rush Steamer: The Disastrous Sinking of the Side-Wheeler Yankee Blade - Grab it through Amazon!

[traveller777]

Welcome to Tnet.

May I ask how you came to be in possession of it? Rather big chunk

Thanks for posting..

 

[derin105]

Welcome to Tnet.

May I ask how you came to be in possession of it? Rather big chunk

Thanks for posting..

I bought it from someone online.

 

[traveller777]

I bought it from someone online.

OK, well good luck. I am no expert, but it looks ok to me. Some real meteorite people will be around and comment for you.

Do you have any provenance on it or guarantee?

 

[derin105]

OK, well good luck. I am no expert, but it looks ok to me. Some real meteorite people will be around and comment for you.

Do you have any provenance on it or guarantee?

I dont unfortunately. I was under the impression real meteorites dont have any pitting or "holes" per say. So any feedback from people here would be greatly appreciated

 

[traveller777]

I have not looked in depth, but back in 2012 the price was around $1.00 a gram. I would say that piece you have is at least 8 pounds and likely more. That would put the 2012 value around $3600 if a real nantan and that price was right. If you got it for a fraction of that cost, I would be suspicious.

 

[derin105]

I have not looked in depth, but back in 2012 the price was around $1.00 a gram. I would say that piece you have is at least 8 pounds and likely more. That would put the 2012 value around $3600 if a real nantan and that price was right. If you got it for a fraction of that cost, I would be suspicious.

I guess my question is if not a meteorite then what? I paid around 500 for it but the seller wanted 700 ish

 

[traveller777]

A real nantan should have dimples, called regmaglypts. BUT as I said, I am not expert, but someone will be along to help you. I likely do not know much more than you about it.

 

[derin105]

A real nantan should have dimples, called regmaglypts. BUT as I said, I am not expert, but someone will be along to help you. I likely do not know much more than you about it.

Sure of course. I will wait patiently

 

[traveller777]

I guess my question is if not a meteorite then what? I paid around 500 for it but the seller wanted 700 ish

ok. I would be wary of that cost but maybe someone will give you better advise. I am going to leave you with it. Good luck.