The Beale Papers has solution - Work with me to validate...

[Rebel - KGC]

​Home

Nice "site"; NOTHING CONCLUSIVE. WHERE are you looking...? Doesn't look like Bedford County, Va.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

DR.ÖTEK Metal Detector, Waterproof Gold Detector, Pinpoint & Terrain Modes, Professional Metal Detector - Grab it through Amazon!

[TN_Guest1523]

​Home

Interesting
'Not worth the candle' is ultimately of French origin. It appears in Randle Cotgrave's A Dictionarie of the French and English Tongues, 1611, where it is listed as:

"Le jeu ne vaut pas la chandelle."

 

[ECS]

Interesting
'Not worth the candle' is ultimately of French origin. It appears in Randle Cotgrave's A Dictionarie of the French and English Tongues, 1611...

"Game not worth the candle" is from Shakespeare's "TWO GENTLEMAN ON VERONA", a play about the main character being banished for killing a man in a fair fight. The main female character is named Julia and the story also involves an important letter.
Thomas Beale departed Virginia after wounding James Beverly Risqué in a duel that concerned Risque's niece , Julia Hancock.
Risque's son in law, Giles Ward, Father of copyright owner, James Beverly Ward, was co-owner of Ward & Diggs Booksellers, and along with John William Sherman, his nephew and printer of the Beale Papers, were members of the Lynchburg Thespian Group, and had full knowledge of Shakespeare's works.
From the May 9 Beale letter:
"Be the result what it may, however, the game is worth the candle, and we will play it to the end".
A homage to the Bard with a sly reference to the Beale/Risqué duel.

 

[ECS]

​Home

While E F Beale's 1850 BEALE PAPERS memoirs was used as source material for the 1885 Beale Papers, he is NOT the Beale character of the dime novel pamphlet.
Other source material was "borrowed from Lewis & Clark (Julia Hancock married William Clark), ciphers from E A Poe and Abraham Ree's Cyclopedia/Dr William Blair's "Writing in Cipher" (both were sold at Ward & Diggs Booksellers), and most telling was an article that appeared in the April 16,1879 edition of the LYNCHBURG VIRGINIAN (John William Sherman was a sub-editor) detailing the found treasure of Robert O Willis that was hidden in a Kentucky cave- $65,000 of gold, silver, and jewelry.
John Pickrell Risqué, brother of J B Risqué of the Beale duel, was murdered by Indians in Gold Gulch Arizona while inspecting gold and silver mines, 1882.
J B Ward's wife, Harriet Otey Buford, was born and raised 4 miles from Buford's Inn, and Ward's uncle was Robert Morriss.
The 1885 Beale Papers may well be the Great American adventure/treasure dime novel with ciphers added as a parlor entertainment, sold only in Lynchburg for the folks of Bedford/Botetourt counties, but since its 1885 publication, has grown to mythic status.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

While E F Beale's 1850 BEALE PAPERS memoirs was used as source material for the 1885 Beale Papers, he is NOT the Beale character of the dime novel pamphlet.
Other source material was "borrowed from Lewis & Clark (Julia Hancock married William Clark), ciphers from E A Poe and Abraham Ree's Cyclopedia/Dr William Blair's "Writing in Cipher" (both were sold at Ward & Diggs Booksellers), and most telling was an article that appeared in the April 16,1879 edition of the LYNCHBURG VIRGINIAN (John William Sherman was a sub-editor) detailing the found treasure of Robert O Willis that was hidden in a Kentucky cave- $65,000 of gold, silver, and jewelry.
John Pickrell Risqué, brother of J B Risqué of the Beale duel, was murdered by Indians in Gold Gulch Arizona while inspecting gold and silver mines, 1882.
J B Ward's wife, Harriet Otey Buford, was born and raised 4 miles from Buford's Inn, and Ward's uncle was Robert Morriss.
The 1885 Beale Papers may well be the Great American adventure/treasure dime novel with ciphers added as a parlor entertainment, sold only in Lynchburg for the folks of Bedford/Botetourt counties, but since its 1885 publication, has grown to mythic status.

Don't see proof, just a bunch of stuff thrown together that does not mean much when put together !

What a JOKE !

 

[ECS]

Don't see proof, just a bunch of stuff thrown together that does not mean much when put together !

What a JOKE !

An expected response from who is still attempting to fit the "right" Beale as proof that he "solved" the ciphers containing Reine Lister and a limerick.
Now that's a JOKE!
Have you found evidence that the Beale buffalo hunt that begins the tale ever happened?
Without that, the whole story as being true, collapses.

 

[TN_Guest1523]

An expected response from who is still attempting to fit the "right" Beale as proof that he "solved" the ciphers containing Reine Lister and a limerick.
Now that's a JOKE!
Have you found evidence that the Beale buffalo hunt that begins the tale ever happened?
Without that, the whole story as being true, collapses.

A historical document called the Beale Papers . A written history of the event with the original letters from Beale . What you got ?

 

[legrand]

Good things are done right. America's about to rock with revelation. Time is being taken. Spring will spring forth. Patience squabblers.

Word of the day: Enthusiasm.

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Good things are done right. America's about to rock with revelation. Time is being taken. Spring will spring forth. Patience squabblers.

Word of the day: Enthusiasm.

LOL!

 

[ECS]

A historical document called the Beale Papers . A written history of the event with the original letters from Beale . What you got ?

Once again, the 1885 Beale Papers job pamphlet is not a historical document, but an adventure/treasure novel with parlor entertainment ciphers that would have been long regulated to the dust of time if not for the Hart brothers and Pauline Innis publishing their books.
Now, read this slowly and understand later:
There exists NO historical document that can prove that anything in the Beale Papers job pamphlet ever happened.
One can find sources that influenced the Beale story in the text, but NO collaborating evidence of the events in the Beale story text, EXISTS.
It always reverts back to the imaginations of James Beverly Ward and John William Sherman, with contributions from F C Hutter, Max Guggenheimer, and Harriet Otey Buford Ward.

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Once again, the 1885 Beale Papers job pamphlet is not a historical document, but an adventure/treasure novel with parlor entertainment ciphers that would have been long regulated to the dust of time if not for the Hart brothers and Pauline Innis publishing their books.
Now, read this slowly and understand later:
There exists NO historical document that can prove that anything in the Beale Papers job pamphlet ever happened.
One can find sources that influenced the Beale story in the text, but NO collaborating evidence of the events in the Beale story text, EXISTS.
It always reverts back to the imaginations of James Beverly Ward and John William Sherman, with contributions from F C Hutter, Max Guggenheimer, and Harriet Otey Buford Ward.

And OTHERS!

 

[TN_Guest1523]

Once again, the 1885 Beale Papers job pamphlet is not a historical document, but an adventure/treasure novel with parlor entertainment ciphers that would have been long regulated to the dust of time if not for the Hart brothers and Pauline Innis publishing their books.
Now, read this slowly and understand later:
There exists NO historical document that can prove that anything in the Beale Papers job pamphlet ever happened.
One can find sources that influenced the Beale story in the text, but NO collaborating evidence of the events in the Beale story text, EXISTS.
It always reverts back to the imaginations of James Beverly Ward and John William Sherman, with contributions from F C Hutter, Max Guggenheimer, and Harriet Otey Buford Ward.

Historical documents are documents that contain important information about a person, place, or event.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_document

 

[TN_Guest1523]

Historical documents are documents that contain important information about a person, place, or event.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_document

1. The Beale Papers have all three of these and therefore is a HISTORICAL DOCUMENT

 

[TN_Guest1523]

1. The Beale Papers have all three of these and therefore is a HISTORICAL DOCUMENT

2. As a historical document it is the proof that it happened !

 

[Rebel - KGC]

1. The Beale Papers have all three of these and therefore is a HISTORICAL DOCUMENT

LOL! Naw... if it was, a copy would be in the Jones Memorial Library in Lynchburg, Va., Bedford Library in Bedford, Va., and Roanoke Library in Roanoke, Va.; AND! Their Historical Societies! NONE found... I LOOKED!

 

[Rebel - KGC]

2. As a historical document it is the proof that it happened !

LOL! WISHFUL thinking... STINKING thinking...

 

[TN_Guest1523]

LOL! Naw... if it was, a copy would be in the Jones Memorial Library in Lynchburg, Va., Bedford Library in Bedford, Va., and Roanoke Library in Roanoke, Va.; AND! Their Historical Societies! NONE found... I LOOKED!

That has got to be the most interesting comment I have seen here, wow you really just said that because a public library does not have something it is not a historical document ?

Possibly if you go to the Big City one day you may find it in a Museum like the one the NSA has !

 

[TN_Guest1523]

LOL! WISHFUL thinking... STINKING thinking...

As a historical document it is the proof that it happened !
That would be a Fact, That Is Why We Call Them Historical Documents

 

[Cryptography]

LOL! Naw... if it was, a copy would be in the Jones Memorial Library in Lynchburg, Va., Bedford Library in Bedford, Va., and Roanoke Library in Roanoke, Va.; AND! Their Historical Societies! NONE found... I LOOKED!

 

[Rebel - KGC]

Have YOU...?