Battle of the Little Big Horn - Custers Rifles

[Scott (Mich)]

That is a later 1st model 1873 winchester.......the cocking lever and the pin above the trigger indicates that it was made after 1876......probably 1879.

Thanks for the info.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

DR.ÖTEK Metal Detector, Waterproof Gold Detector, Pinpoint & Terrain Modes, Professional Metal Detector - Grab it through Amazon!

[gunsil]

"RARE & HISTORIC CUSTER RANGE SPRINGFIELD TRAPDOOR CARBINE. Cal. 45-70. SN 39348. According to existing records this carbine was manufactured in February 1875, and subsequently issued. Companies “D”, “I” and “K” of Custer’s 7th Cavalry were the last to receive their carbines. Companies “D” & “K” were with Benteen and Reno while Company “I” died with Custer in 1876."

Again, Custer trapdoors did NOT have a serial number range of 1-500. The numbers on the one you show do not appear to be armory stamped anyways, looks like they were stamped in with individual number stamps which wasn't how they were originally marked.

 

[Real de Tayopa Tropical Tramp]

For general information the Springfield 45 70 was directly decended from the Springfield model 50 70, basically the same action with the exception of a smaller calibre It was succesfully tested out to over 1000 meters on hits on a mansized target.

The main trouble , which did not show up in the testing, was the brass used in the cartridge case was too soft, due to manufacturing processes and remained in the chamber after sustained fireing, due to black powder residue build up.. Continued attempts to clear the chamber merely resulted in the ejector pulling through the soft rim, resulting in the men useing whatever they had to try to pry the cartride case out of the chamber, in most cases their knives..

The design and workmanship of the 50 70 & 45 70 was well within the accepted standards, still is. The repeating rifles of the day were ingenious but by necesity of a much lower power.and subject to the same problem, but of less frequency.

In the end the Springfields were far better a choice for battle field conditions, as found in the recent Civil War, Than the weaker repeaing rifles.

The Spring fields were essentialy a long range firearm, if Custer had used them properly, the Indians could have been picked off beore they could even form into groups, but since they were a new arm aggressive stratigy had not been developed yet. The old cliche' " hold your fire men " still applied.

Incidenally the first cartridges were similar to a .22 rim fire, but actually center fired, this was corrected wth an external center fired primer assembly, indepent of the hardnes of the brass.rim fire.. The brass had to be drawn soft enough to enable the striker to fire the priiming charge. This was THE problem.

 

[cactusjumper]

For general information the Springfield 45 70 was directly decended from the Springfield model 50 70, basically the same action with the exception of a smaller calibre It was succesfully tested out to over 1000 meters on hits on a mansized target.

The main trouble , which did not show up in the testing, was the brass used in the cartridge case was too soft, due to manufacturing processes and remained in the chamber after sustained fireing, due to black powder residue build up.. Continued attempts to clear the chamber merely resulted in the ejector pulling through the soft rim, resulting in the men useing whatever they had to try to pry the cartride case out of the chamber, in most cases their knives..

The design and workmanship of the 50 70 & 45 70 was well within the accepted standards, still is. The repeating rifles of the day were ingenious but by necesity of a much lower power.and subject to the same problem, but of less frequency.

In the end the Springfields were far better a choice for battle field conditions, as found in the recent Civil War, Than the weaker repeaing rifles.

The Spring fields were essentialy a long range firearm, if Custer had used them properly, the Indians could have been picked off beore they could even form into groups, but since they were a new arm aggressive stratigy had not been developed yet. The old cliche' " hold your fire men " still applied.

Incidenally the first cartridges were similar to a .22 rim fire, but actually center fired, this was corrected wth an external center fired primer assembly, indepent of the hardnes of the brass.rim fire.. The brass had to be drawn soft enough to enable the striker to fire the priiming charge. This was THE problem.

Don Jose,

I believe the .44/.55 Model 1873 was the principle weapon of Custer's troops. I think they accounted for around 50% of the cartridge cases recovered during the 1984-85 archaeological investigation of the Custer battlefield. There is some debate over the armament of the 7th, in that they may have been outgunned by the Indians. The troopers also carried the model P 1872 Colt single -action revolver. They carried 50 rounds for their carbines, in their cartridge belt and 50 rounds in their saddle bags. In addition to that, they also carried 24 rounds for the Peacemaker.

Some carried their own personal weapons.

If there are any further questions, I have ongoing conversations with Sandy Barnard, one of the top historians and authors of the Indian Wars and The Battle Of The Little Big Horn. For me, he will be the final authority on the subject.

Take care,

Joe

 

[Real de Tayopa Tropical Tramp]

Joe, I assumedthat you made a typo ont he 44-55. The standard Springfileld load was '45' -55. 55 graims of black powder, where as the standard load was a 45-70 grains of black powder. The men were so ill prepared by being only alloted some 20 rnds a year, that they coud not become used to the recoil - or shoot accurately -- demanded a lesser recoiling load. Yer well enough to join me in a cuppa.

 

[cactusjumper]

Joe, I assumedthat you made a typo ont he 44-55. The standard Springfileld load was '45' -55. 55 graims of black powder, where as the standard load was a 45-70 grains of black powder. The men were so ill prepared by being only alloted some 20 rnds a year, that they coud not become used to the recoil - or shoot accurately -- demanded a lesser recoiling load. Yer well enough to join me in a cuppa.

Don Jose,

You are, of course, correct. I do, on occasion, make a mistake.

Take care,

Joe

 

[Simon1]

Before my dad had passed, this was one of his favorite areas of interest. He spoke of searches for the cache of rifles. He never found the answer, just as he spent time looking for the lost colony of Roanoke, that was another area of interest as my maternal side of the family was descendants of Sir Humphrey Gilbert who was Sir Walter Raleigh's half brother. He never found that answer either. Story of most treasure hunters, except the distinguished Don Jose, most never do find the answer they are looking for, but they don't give up.

 

[Real de Tayopa Tropical Tramp]

Now your talking Simon, a fresh pot of coffee always brewing. also for an excellent article. What DID he findon Roanoke ??>

The last that I heard of them, they had been masacred by the Inidians, or assimulated.

 

[Simon1]

He believed in the assimilation theory, but never felt he had enough evidence and therefore kept it to himself. After he passed, we found nothing on it in his files or computers. Sad, but that is what happens when you do not leave a record, ( or a BOOK ), behind for family members or friends to enjoy the life you led, or pick up your journey where you had left off.
You will always have a fresh pot of coffee Don Jose, we will petition McDonalds or Starbucks to come out with a new blend called Tayopa" !
Has your drinking habits and Oro's smoking habit ?

 

[NWMP]

Sitting Bull etc. came up here after the battle, and the various peoples stayed for a few years. Some went back later, some stayed and formed various reserves to this day. I have heard a few things that I will keep to myself for potential future digs...............I wouldn't hide my weaponry until I was well across the border.........."Medicine line".

 

[lgadbois]

 

[lgadbois]

 

[lgadbois]

For those that disagree with the serial numbers of the first 1873 Springfield Trapdoor Carbines, please read the resource at the below link. This is but one record of the first serial numbers of this weapon.
Springfield Trapdoor Rifles & Carbines

 

[lgadbois]

The monument that had the secret compartment still stands along Highway 212 near Busby, Montana. It is said that the cache is located at a point overlooking Chief Two Moons gravesite. Will anyone ever figure out where it is?

 

[SavvyJack]

I was told that this is one of the types of guns used in the battle, although most likely this was not one of those actual guns. The part that holds the bullet is made of brass and if fired too often would expand and the shell would not come out - it would jam. I read stories of Custer's men throwing these guns at the Indians in frustration.

View attachment 278078

View attachment 278079

a couple of more pictures

View attachment 278080

View attachment 278081

Only the Indians had leveractions. Yes, the Indians had 1860 Henrys, the Winchester 1866' and the Winchester 73'. The Winchester 73' was only three years old!

Here is a snip from http://www.friendslittlebighorn.com/2004scottfinalreport.pdf page 12

Winchester .44–40-Caliber Four cartridge cases of .44–40-caliber (FS 9612, 9624, 9730, 9801) were found during the 2004 investigations. These brass cases are centerfire and were primed with the Winchester-Milbank or Boxer type primer (Figure 13c). There were approximately 23,000 guns of the Model 1873 Winchester lever action rifle shipped from the Winchester warehouse by the end of 1876, all were .44–40-caliber (Madis 1979:132, 214). The Model 1873 was a great improvement over the Henry and Model 1866 because it had been adapted to handle the stronger and more powerful center-fire cartridge which could be reloaded. This model was produced in three variations, rifle, carbine, and musket. The firing pin and extractor mark analysis identified these four cases as being fired in three different guns. FS 9612 from Reno–Benteen matched to case FS 9730 from Custer battlefield. These two cases also matched to FS 1749, a case found on Custer field in 1984 in the Calhoun area. The 2004 finds add three Model 1873 Winchesters to the previous number for a total of eleven guns (Scott et al. 1989). FS 9612 represents use of a weapon at Reno–Benteen and at Custer battlefield (FS 9730 and 1749). The previous investigations identified two other guns used at both Custer and Reno–Benteen battlefields. The 2004 data demonstrates additional movement between the various areas of engagement by at least three warriors armed with a Model 1873 Winchester.

 

[Tiredman]

The monument that had the secret compartment still stands along Highway 212 near Busby, Montana. It is said that the cache is located at a point overlooking Chief Two Moons gravesite. Will anyone ever figure out where it is?

Pull it up with a topo map

 

[GoDeep]

After the battle, any serviceable weapons recovered by the Indians would have been put directly back into service and distributed among the warriors. Preparations would have begun immediately for further attacks and to counter any further forces that would no doubt be dispatched in short order. To think they buried a cache of weapons, rather then pressed into service said serviceable weapons to defend their homeland, makes for good treasure hunting stories, nothing more.

 

[Tiredman]

They left the Reservation due to lack of food, so they could hunt buffalo. I doubt any rifles were buried by the Native Americans. Apparently the Travel Channel is filming there in May from what I hear about the battle.

 

[Simon1]

They left the Reservation due to lack of food, so they could hunt buffalo. I doubt any rifles were buried by the Native Americans. Apparently the Travel Channel is filming there in May from what I hear about the battle.

================

Hope they wear their rattlesnake proof gear.

 

[Honest Samuel]

Snakes love to eat people, free food.