Crazy Good Day with Nickles

[heymirth]

On the way home today I stopped at a BOA for an ordered nickel box. They bring the Lomis box to me and I notice it's all 2016 (thru the holes in the top) and I nicely asked them if they had any other nickel boxes, they said No, but we have like $48 in customer rolls. Okay, I'll take them, you could tel they were from all different people because of the rolls.
Open the very first teal writing roll and a 1945 S War Nickle jumps out along with a 1940. NICE START-- Then I notice that these "teal color rolls (8 of them) have a lot of filler Canadian and some Euro coins as spacers in them.
Next plain blue roll--- 2009 P. Heck Yeah!
A few more rollls of the typical mixed years , a few 1950-57 coins.
With 3 more Teal rolls to go and whammy--- another 2009 P Nickle! Very last teal roll pops out a 1945 P War Nickle but this ones got a "looks like" an Error Planchette Clipped along the top.

Wow-- this is a day to make me come back - I've been on such a poor coin streak.
Check these out.

QUESTION- how do I find out if this 1945P is an actual Error Planchette and are these rare and worth $$?

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!

[mrogers07]

I hate you. I have found multiple 2009-D's and I need a "P" for my album. LOL

 

[enamel7]

Definitely a clipped planchette!

 

[baddbluff]

Definitely a clipped planchette!

Agree
Not sure what it's worth but that's the first I've seen. Cool find.

 

[port ewen ace]

I sell clips at about $3. found them in nickels, cents. google "Blakesley effect" to grasp how a clip alters the coin. of my 500+ war nics, none have a clip. nice catch

 

[LooseChange]

Clipped war nick might get a premium over a more modern clip.
Ebay listing for 1944P (with similar clip) did not sell at $9.99 and hasn't sold yet at the reduced buy-it-now of $8.99.
1944-P Jefferson Nickel - Clipped Planchet - K65 | eBay

 

[heymirth]

Clipped war nick might get a premium over a more modern clip.
Ebay listing for 1944P (with similar clip) did not sell at $9.99 and hasn't sold yet at the reduced buy-it-now of $8.99.
1944-P Jefferson Nickel - Clipped Planchet - K65 | eBay

Thanks. Maybe I'll go undercut him for $8.49. Ha ha jk

 

[LooseChange]

Thanks. Maybe I'll go undercut him for $8.49. Ha ha jk

Nice idea.

For me, this is exactly the type of thing that I keep aside as a CRH trophy. Not enough value to spend time selling it for what it is worth, but unique enough to probably be a once-in-a-lifetime find.

 

[Twitch]

Clipped war nic is a heck of a keeper. Nice catch.

 

[jcole77]

2 2009-Ps in one day... I'm STILL waiting for that to happen... nice finds!

 

[heymirth]

ullyb

2 2009-Ps in one day... I'm STILL waiting for that to happen... nice finds!

I actually gave one of the 2009 Ps to a TNET user who has been on the forum looking for one

PAY IT FORWARD everyone. It was free to me and let's another user finish his book!

 

[7up2000]

Nice finds OP. I, too, went through a long cold streak with nickel boxes but am now coming out of it. I still get skunk boxes regularly but inbetween I will get a box that will produce 2-3 war nickels and the occasional V nickel. Congrats again.

 

[BobTheDigger]

Nice score on the nickels. I always found a lot of nickels with the AT Pro, not so much with the Deus. Maybe I should figure them out on the Deus. I like nickels.

 

[enamel7]

Nice score on the nickels. I always found a lot of nickels with the AT Pro, not so much with the Deus. Maybe I should figure them out on the Deus. I like nickels.

You do realize he found these searching rolls, not detecting?