Open carry pistol while metal detekting

63bkpkr

Silver Member
Aug 9, 2007
4,069
4,618
Southern California
Detector(s) used
XLT, GMT, 6000D Coinmaster
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Bears are amazing animals! What do all animals do out there, they walk around every day, up and down hills through brush for most if not all of the year. That just happens to be quite an exercise routine. Then how do bears get food? If the grass, flowers, or berries are ripe they just eat them. Bears also hunt for squirrels mostly by digging for them, so just how easy is it for them to dig for squirrels. Bears also chase down young animals, like moose, fawns, etc. Bears climb trees for leaves, honey and maybe squirrels. What I am getting at is that all bears are quite strong. All bears can be standing still and in an instant be heading for 25 to 30 MPH, Momma Bear if she has Psyched herself up could even move a little faster and her mind is all about protecting her children, do you think she cares about you, NO.

So how far the bear is from you when 'You See It' makes a big difference in your reaction time, your reaction time needs to be quicker than the bear all the time!

IF a bear is charging you what is the best point to aim at? If you go to a "Where to shoot a bear to kill it" on an internet search site, any site worth its salt will tell you to shoot it right in back of the front shoulder/leg as that gets the bullet into the Bears vitals (heart, lung, organs the things that keep the bear moving). Here is a hint for you: Bears do not run at you sideways. The front of Any Bear is armored with big bones, heavy fur and skin, fat and the skull is heavy and angled which happens to deflect bullets fairly well.

Lets get back to timing - a charging bear encounter is generally going to happen very fast as they understand how to Stalk their dinner. Remember we are just another intruder dinner to them. So how do you aim at a "fast" moving target? Getting the front and rear sights aligned on a fast moving target is how you practice at the range, Right?? No!!! Well you'd better if you are going to be out in Mr or Miss' bears back yard. I prefer to practice shooting at a target by looking down the side of my barrel (454 Casull Revolver), for Semi-Autos you'd be looking down the side of your slide. At what distance? from 25' to 3'. How much time do you have, not enough to squeeze the trigger and poop your pants at the same time, its all going to go down real fast, especially if its Momma with Cubs.

Yes, some bears bluff charge which gives you a little more time to get your weapon out. Some bears are still Leary of humans and will walk away from you once they've seen you, try not to Startle any Bear. The ones that have become used to humans (trash can bears) or the ones that humans have hand fed (tree huggers and dummies), well they consider you just another source of where the food comes from. AKA - you are it, chewy on the outside, soft in the middle.

Caliber: YES, you will find accounts of people stopping a bear with a 9mm. Remember, it hurts when you accidentally stick yourself with a "pin" so any slug is going to hurt a lot worse (.22 and on up). The best kill shot on a bear is from the side but likely you won't have that shot, you will likely be looking at the bears face and chest, all mighty tough stuff. The bullets will hurt the bear which will excite the animal causing its adrenaline to spike and now you will have an Adrenaline Junky That Wants To Kill the Thing that Hurt it. Right, all of this is bad news for the human. With a 9mm you want to get all 14 rounds into the animal very quickly (some will miss) and then get another full clip into it (excuse me, magazine). Then immediately keep shooting the animal!!!! Be very capable of changing magazines in a high stress situation (Note: a bear wanting to kill you IS a high stress situation, this is no joke) Practice!

Now, personally I love being out in Extremely Wild Country, I've also had MANY encounters with bears. On one particular occasion if the bear in the bushes to the left of the trail had chosen me as a target, I would not be writing this right now! I happened to surprise the animal (recall I told you to not do this), both of my hands were full of things (one of those things being a wet canvas bag full of fresh caught Trout). When the bear exited the bushes I opened both hands and grabbed for my revolver which I keep in a shoulder holster in my left armpit. By the time I'd undone the snap on the holster the bear was gone over the next ridge about 30' away. That was many years ago and I camp in that country every year. Am I crazy, I like to think that I love that country so much that I need to be out in it every year. These are mostly wild bears with limited contact with people BUT back in the mid 1970's the Forest Service started Dumping Bad Bears (the ones the humans fed in National Parks) into MY Canyon (rugged mountain country). They began by taking my food bags that were hanging from a rope over a tree limb so the bears could not get the food which up until the dumping started worked (that would be from 1964 into the mid 1970's). I lost several food bags and ropes then I switched over to a steel cable and that ended the stolen food. They then turned to my camp itself. The trick is, do not zip up your tent. Leave it open so they can walk in, explore and then easily walk out. The tent will still be there, a few things may be torn up (that would include my squishy air mattress and some stuff sacks) and do not leave your first aid kit in your tent just way too many curious smells for bears. (Heck they go wild over hydrocarbon fumes, think gasoline in 5 gallon plastic jugs, the bears chew through the jugs to get at the fumes!!!) You try to chew through the wall of a 5 gallon jug!

Okay, I use my 454 as a noise maker and to date it always works and so far NO charging bears. How, close 15'. I have no interest in shooting a bear for any part of it, I absolutely want nothing to do with any part of a bear other than watching them walk around. I do wish they would leave my camps alone! Oh, the 454 IS NOT for everyone!! It is very heavy unloaded and a lot heavier loaded with 300 grain slugs (my choice). Why do I own it? It will shoot through 3/8" steel plate. Once I tested it on an 8" diameter pine tree but before I fired I lined up the target tree so there was a catch tree behind it, good thing I did. From a distance of ~ 8' the 300 grain solid slug went right through the center point of first tree and buried into the second tree. All I have to do is place the slug and it will do the rest no matter what I'm shooting at.

So around Bears be wise and keep your food out of their reach. Clean up really well after each meal. Bears can easily rip the lid off of a food cooler. If a bear smeels food in your car they will break into your vehicle. One of their tricks (this would be an educated bear) is to put a claw under the rubber strip that holds the windshield in place and pull the seal out, this happened on the Alaskan Pipe Line build! Make noise so you do not accidentally startle them. Also, be quick on the draw and practice high stress shooting!.......................63bkpkr [a candy bar in your shirt pocket or day pack on a hot day is not wise]
 

Last edited:

Charlie P. (NY)

Gold Member
Feb 3, 2006
13,004
17,108
South Central Upstate NY in the foothills of the h
Detector(s) used
Minelab Musketeer Advantage Pro w/8" & 10" DD coils/Fisher F75se(Upgraded to LTD2) w/11" DD, 6.5" concentric & 9.5" NEL Sharpshooter DD coils/Sunray FX-1 Probe & F-Point/Black Widows/Rattler headphone
Primary Interest:
Metal Detecting
Not in NY. At least not within city limits. But concealed carry is OK if you have a little less checkered past than Mother Teresa and can get an unrestricted permit.

My EDC is a S&W M&P Shield 9mm without thumb safety and MagGuts +2 followers and springs so I can get the max allowed 10 rounds. Speer 124 gr Gold Dot bullets.
 

IMAUDIGGER

Silver Member
Mar 16, 2016
3,400
5,194
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I understand. I just pray you will never have to use your weapon in defense. The feeling afterwards never goes away.
Thank you for your sacrifice. Really.
As I said, I respect your decision. I'm also very grateful that we have the ability to make these decisions for ourselves.

Hope I am never in the situation where it's him or me.
But if I do. I'm going to try like heck for it to not be me.
I feel that's what god intended us to do.
Do good to others and protect yourself, your family, and your fellow man from evil.
 

Last edited:

BC1969

Banned
Sep 4, 2013
5,827
10,449
Somewhere directly above the center of the Earth.
Primary Interest:
Other
Any of you guys open carrey a pistol while metal detekting, Im looking at getting a p320 M17 for protection aginst black bears, 17 rounds 9mm should be enough rounds to scare him away and have enough rounds left over if he doesnt scare easily, Black bears around here are usally around 250lbs....

Edit... This is a blanket statement for my Tnet family.

Good. You understand how bots work. Thank you!
Get a CPL and conceal it.
Being bent over or on your knees with headphones on with a tool fashioned onto your belt is suddenly pulled from its holster.... By someone other than you!

Don't be a victim for trying to protect yourself and your family. :icon_thumright:

BC
 

Last edited:

Grizz12

Sr. Member
Dec 22, 2018
317
517
Alaska
Detector(s) used
Nox 800
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Caliber: YES, you will find accounts of people stopping a bear with a 9mm. Remember, it hurts when you accidentally stick yourself with a "pin" so any slug is going to hurt a lot worse (.22 and on up). The best kill shot on a bear is from the side but likely you won't have that shot, you will likely be looking at the bears face and chest, all mighty tough stuff. The bullets will hurt the bear which will excite the animal causing its adrenaline to spike and now you will have an Adrenaline Junky That Wants To Kill the Thing that Hurt it. Right, all of this is bad news for the human. With a 9mm you want to get all 14 rounds into the animal very quickly (some will miss) and then get another full clip into it (excuse me, magazine). Then immediately keep shooting the animal!!!! Be very capable of changing magazines in a high stress situation (Note: a bear wanting to kill you IS a high stress situation, this is no joke) Practice!

Now, personally I love being out in Extremely Wild Country, I've also had MANY encounters with bears. On one particular occasion if the bear in the bushes to the left of the trail had chosen me as a target, I would not be writing this right now! I happened to surprise the animal (recall I told you to not do this), both of my hands were full of things (one of those things being a wet canvas bag full of fresh caught Trout). When the bear exited the bushes I opened both hands and grabbed for my revolver which I keep in a shoulder holster in my left armpit. By the time I'd undone the snap on the holster the bear was gone over the next ridge about 30' away. That was many years ago and I camp in that country every year. Am I crazy, I like to think that I love that country so much that I need to be out in it every year. These are mostly wild bears with limited contact with people BUT back in the mid 1970's the Forest Service started Dumping Bad Bears (the ones the humans fed in National Parks) into MY Canyon (rugged mountain country). They began by taking my food bags that were hanging from a rope over a tree limb so the bears could not get the food which up until the dumping started worked (that would be from 1964 into the mid 1970's). I lost several food bags and ropes then I switched over to a steel cable and that ended the stolen food. They then turned to my camp itself. The trick is, do not zip up your tent. Leave it open so they can walk in, explore and then easily walk out. The tent will still be there, a few things may be torn up (that would include my squishy air mattress and some stuff sacks) and do not leave your first aid kit in your tent just way too many curious smells for bears. (Heck they go wild over hydrocarbon fumes, think gasoline in 5 gallon plastic jugs, the bears chew through the jugs to get at the fumes!!!) You try to chew through the wall of a 5 gallon jug!

Okay, I use my 454 as a noise maker and to date it always works and so far NO charging bears. How, close 15'. I have no interest in shooting a bear for any part of it, I absolutely want nothing to do with any part of a bear other than watching them walk around. I do wish they would leave my camps alone! Oh, the 454 IS NOT for everyone!! It is very heavy unloaded and a lot heavier loaded with 300 grain slugs (my choice). Why do I own it? It will shoot through 3/8" steel plate. Once I tested it on an 8" diameter pine tree but before I fired I lined up the target tree so there was a catch tree behind it, good thing I did. From a distance of ~ 8' the 300 grain solid slug went right through the center point of first tree and buried into the second tree. All I have to do is place the slug and it will do the rest no matter what I'm shooting at.

So around Bears be wise and keep your food out of their reach. Clean up really well after each meal. Bears can easily rip the lid off of a food cooler. If a bear smeels food in your car they will break into your vehicle. One of their tricks (this would be an educated bear) is to put a claw under the rubber strip that holds the windshield in place and pull the seal out, this happened on the Alaskan Pipe Line build! Make noise so you do not accidentally startle them. Also, be quick on the draw and practice high stress shooting!.......................63bkpkr [a candy bar in your shirt pocket or day pack on a hot day is not wise]

Excellent write up but you missed one important point, type of bullet.

A round nose or hollow points are not nearly as affective as any solid (lead or copper) with a flat nose. The round nose and HP's will simply slide around the bones while the flat points are more likely to punch through and break stuff
 

OP
OP
Toecutter

Toecutter

Bronze Member
Nov 30, 2018
2,433
7,443
🥇 Banner finds
1
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
1
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
All great advise, going conceled makes most sence to me, Iv bin on 2 bear hunts using dogs and rifles, that was with 2 other guys, I will have my 13 year old daughter with me on alot of my metal dtecting advenchures, I live in a ruel area and rarly detect in the city but do occasionally...

63bkpkr thank you for the great info and taking the time to put it out their...

Iv grew up hunting and he did alot of target practice, I learned alot from being in boy scouts one more year i would of had eagle scout, Im comfortabe in the woods and dont scare eaisy, Im not looking to kill but to deterr, bears would not be the only reson as drunk hill billys can be worse then the bears and the Upper Peninsula of Michigan has a bunch of em, I will be doing what is called "primitive camping" basically camping off the 2 track trail fare away from any camp ground...
ALAWYS BE PREPARED (scouts motto)
 

RTR

Gold Member
Nov 21, 2017
8,180
32,469
Smith Mt. Lake Va.
Detector(s) used
Teknetics Liberator
Falcon MD-20
***********
Blue Bowl
Angus MacKirk sluice
Miller Table
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I'm not going in woods (that I know have bears) w/a stinking 9mm. IF, it came time for point blank defense with a Bear,you Might get lucky,you might Not... Bigger IS better in this situation.
 

tinpan

Silver Member
Sep 4, 2004
4,664
1,586
Eaglehawk
🥇 Banner finds
1
Detector(s) used
GPX
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Hi, No offence but no one else in the world shoot animal that weighs more than 200 pounds with a hand gun. What stupid idea'. TP
 

Bodkin

Sr. Member
Oct 9, 2017
463
1,128
Bold Coast & Treasure Coast
Detector(s) used
Blue Excal 1000, Enox 800
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
YES, YES, YES!!! Bears, coyotes and if need be people with bad intentions. Springfield .45ACP XD MOD2
 

cyzak

Bronze Member
Jul 14, 2018
2,342
3,803
Mountains of Western Colorado
Detector(s) used
Garrett, General Mathematics, Geometry,Pentax,,Do the math it's there.
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Never leave home with out it Kimber micro 9 its my sweetheart.
 

CoinHunterAZ

Hero Member
Feb 18, 2013
858
1,498
Flagstaff, AZ
Detector(s) used
Tesoro Sidewinder Umax, Garrett ATPro, Minelab Equinox 800, Garrett Pro Pointer
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I live in Arizona. It's a "right to carry state" either open or concealed. While there is plenty of bears that live here, they are the very least of my worries. I'm more concerned about the two legged vermin, and rattlesnakes to a lesser degree. I had a bear come within 15 feet of me while elk hunting a couple of years ago. He never even knew I was there, until I finally yelled at him and cussed him out. He took off like a scalded cat. I carry a 3" S&W Model 10 38 SPL with snake shot in the first two cylinders, +P heavy cast bullet handloads in the remaining 4. I have never felt "under-gunned" with it. YMMV.
 

Jon Stewart

Bronze Member
Jan 11, 2011
1,029
931
Nope. I am a retired LEO that has an un restricted CCW permit. I retired 19 years ago last month and have yet to carry. Not many spend as much time in the woods as I do or on the desert in the winter months as I do and yet I am still here.

I killed a bear while hunting with a recurve at 7 yards two falls ago and had only the bow, no side arm. Sometimes I think folks walk around and look for trouble.
 

IMAUDIGGER

Silver Member
Mar 16, 2016
3,400
5,194
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Nope. I am a retired LEO....Sometimes I think folks walk around and look for trouble.

You must appreciate the fact that your career has probably played a role in your view of the world. LE is always dealing with the culls, always on guard and expecting the worst from people.

I bet you still watch people's hands when you talk with them without even realizing it.

By the way..stalking a bear with a recurve bow IS the definition of walking around looking for trouble isn't it?
 

Last edited:

63bkpkr

Silver Member
Aug 9, 2007
4,069
4,618
Southern California
Detector(s) used
XLT, GMT, 6000D Coinmaster
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Hi Tinpan, we are Not Hunting FOR Bears, we are only talking about personal safety in bear country while metal detecting. I know of a fellow who is an excellent marksman, he went out hunting for a black bear with a 41 Magnum Revolver. His first shot hit the animal well and the bear just ran off. He took the empty out and inserted another round so he was back up to six in the cylinder and then went in after the animal. It took 6 more 41 Magnums to finish the bear off (7 rounds total) so yes, hunting for bears with smaller hand guns is not the best idea. Self protection, well you carry what you have or can.........63bkpkr

IMAUDIGGER, hunting bears with bows - I've watched a few videos of hunting black and grizzly bears with a bow by both men and women and I think it is ridiculous! I would guess it is quite a Thrill to Properly Place the arrow into the animal but it is asking for way to much potential trouble if you do not kill it with the first arrow. Playing with Dynamite is also a thrill but I got over it, personally I'd Never hunt any Bear Species with a bow as I've way more respect for their abilities to survive and Kill other things!............63bkpkr IMHO
 

Last edited:

Jon Stewart

Bronze Member
Jan 11, 2011
1,029
931
#1 I was hunting bear in a blind, never said stalking and if I was stalking for a bear that would be called hunting and not looking for trouble.
#2 you are correct. I watch people all the time and it drives my wife nuts. When we go to a restaurant I have to sit with my back to the wall and facing the door. I remember one time my neighbor asked me to help load a semi and for pay they bought me breakingfast. On the way out the door he told me that I watched every person coming and going. Just a habit I guess.

I am not putting anyone down for carrying. I am all for that if you want. It is just not for me anymore. I was in the Marines in the 60's and they taught me how to shoot. I joke that I an shoot fly **** out of pepper at a 100 yards. Well maybe not that good but I can shoot.
 

Last edited:

Bodkin

Sr. Member
Oct 9, 2017
463
1,128
Bold Coast & Treasure Coast
Detector(s) used
Blue Excal 1000, Enox 800
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Conceal carry in public, open carry in the woods. I've been chased by a bear and had to chase coyotes away from my buddy who got surrounded by five while setting up his climbing treestand for bowhunting. Now, I rarely go anywhere without one. Yes, it is personal choice and I totally respect that. And, "Sometimes I think folks walk around and look for trouble". But those are folks one is just trying to have an even playing field against.
Better to have it and not need it, than to need it and not have it. If your choice is to carry, practice, practice, practice. And then, practice some more!
 

GaRebel1861

Gold Member
Jun 16, 2011
5,758
6,783
South Carolina
🥇 Banner finds
4
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
3
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
If you see me anywhere, I'm likely carrying a pistol. The world is a very evil and dangerous place now days.
 

DeepseekerADS

Gold Member
Mar 3, 2013
14,880
21,725
SW, VA - Bull Mountain
Detector(s) used
CTX, Excal II, EQ800, Fisher 1260X, Tesoro Royal Sabre, Tejon, Garrett ADSIII, Carrot, Stealth 920iX, Keene A52
Primary Interest:
Other
When I lived in the burbs of Detroit, I held a CCW. Yet I never carried. I'm a combat veteran, and I know what it is like to take a life - as a Christian. After I took all the training and passed all the testing, and had the CCW - then I started considering the responsibilities, and my own faith. I was ready right there, and then I chose not to carry.

But I do know I need to protect my loved ones, and will when the time comes
 

Apr 17, 2014
2,033
1,326
Tartarus Dorsa mountains
Primary Interest:
Other
Hi, No offence but no one else in the world shoot animal that weighs more than 200 pounds with a hand gun. What stupid idea'. TP

cept me? routine, unless you mean dressed out v live weight? oh wait, that be me again. I'll go up against any north American animal with a hand gun any time any day 24/357. just that they gots to be unarmed!
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Top