Feb 09, 2017, 12:11 PM
The included pics are of silver found in the Grayson Lake area of Elliott county Kentucky. The 2 pieces were found 3 weeks ago and have been acid tested. Results-SILVER!!!! Not just silver but very pure silver as the acid had no effect on the pieces. They were tested in multiple areas and all showed same results, SILVER!! Can't say as to internal content but would venture to say the same results would be found. The smaller piece of the 2 weighs 3.3ozs. Larger of the 2 weighs 11.64 ozs.
Not able to confirm that these have ANYTHING to do with the Swift legend but it sure make me wonder anyway. I am not the lucky finder of the pieces but do know where they were found and know the finder personally. He is a man of great integrity and honesty. If he tells me he found them and where he found them then I have NO doubt as to the credibility of the information.
You can see in the pics, run marks and ripples from being heated. On smaller pieces a curved flat back indicates to me that it was heated and poured with resulting piece left to harden as either overflow or end of pour from container. Have no doubt as to the truth behind this story. It's more than just a story. IT'S A FACTUAL EVENT THAT DID TAKE PLACE AS DESCRIBED ABOVE.
Feb 09, 2017, 12:26 PM
When you say almost pure silver makes me think they could have been someone's sterling silver from a house fire or cabin burning down? Does not have anything to do with Swift Silver mines.
Feb 09, 2017, 12:43 PM
Considering location of find (6"-8" underground) and surrounding mines along with the Indian Way Bills.......It definitely has something to do with mines. Swifts mines...can't say myself or can anyone else with any certainty. I just know what was found, where found and it's general location to one of many proposed locations to Swifts mines. How can you say "Has nothing to do with Swifts Silver Mines." with certainty?
Last edited by DSL; Feb 09, 2017 at 12:47 PM.
Reason: Forgot to state that find was underground not a surface find.
Feb 09, 2017, 01:00 PM
How can you say it has everything to do with Swifts Silver Mines with certainty?
Originally Posted by DSL
I've detected over home sites that were burned and then buried.....bulldozer comes along, digs a three foot trench, pushes left over debris into the trench then pushes the dirt from the trench over top of the debris. The scenario that franklin proposes is very plausible and most likely closer to the truth than a silver mine.
However, I'm an optimist, perhaps more of the back story will convince me further.
Feb 09, 2017, 01:21 PM
Please read my post and my reply to Franklin again. I never said it had "everything" to do with Swifts Silver Mines in either post. Location found rules out your theory. Although a very plausible explanation indeed. Just that you couldn't get any kind of mechanized equipment into the area. Now or at any point in the past.
Originally Posted by 1320
Glad you do have an open mind as I'm just posting what I thought was a VERY interesting find. Especially for the location of the find.
"Forever an optimist!"
If more info or interesting finds are gathered I will post.
Feb 09, 2017, 05:58 PM
Given the location of the find I would suspect possibly Indian silver?
Feb 09, 2017, 06:25 PM
This is a very interesting find! Ive been wanting to see some physical proof of the Indian Silver Mines for awhile now. I live In Elliott and the Waybill has always intrigued me. I totally understand and respect everyones opinions, but Im like you; if that came from the cliffs in an area where there would not have been a home, then it is probable it is from native silver in that area. Awesome find my friend.
Feb 09, 2017, 06:42 PM
Then you too know where this was found? I have not read from DSL post exactly what type of terrain the silver slugs were found? He only said in the Swift Mine area that covers about seven states. Now he ruled out heavy equipment but I have metal detected old log homes most only had dirt floors but when a house or cabin burns it gets hot enough to melt silverware and sterling silver service ware and turn it into chunks just like those posted. I may be wrong but silver out of ore will have impurities such as copper, brass and lead usually about only sixty percent silver. Now when someone tells me it is almost pure silver or is pure silver immediately I say that it is silverware that has melted in a house fire. Now DSL has not ruled this out he only says that he knows where it was found. Well where, not the location of the find but the type of location of the find. Was it found on top a cliff where no one would build a house or log cabin. In a crevice on the side of a cliff, under a cliff or inside of the bowels of the rocks and cliffs. Now if he found it 6 or 8 inches deep in soil then as DSL said then yes there could have been a cabin there that burned down and over the years the silver would sink into the ground until coming upon hard packed soil or bedrock. I need more information to make a decision but pure silver is not smelted silver from ore.
Originally Posted by Brushy Bandit
Feb 09, 2017, 07:47 PM
I think Brushy is just assuming that this was found in the wilderness somewhere on the Grayson Lake area like I am. If it was found in a secluded spot where a home would not be then there is a chance its real. Don't think Brushy was saying he "knew" where it was found just putting together the relation of the Waybill and Grayson Lake. I understand what your saying though Franklin.
Feb 09, 2017, 07:49 PM
The heavier piece I think almost certainly Contains lead in my opinion from the weight and feel of it. The pieces have been acid tested
DSL gave the area as the Grayson lake area ,that covers 1 of the 7 seven states you mentioned.
Feb 09, 2017, 07:52 PM
I know the exact spots where the pieces were found. They weren't found together, and both were in wilderness, one very close to a rock cliff at Caney.
Feb 09, 2017, 07:53 PM
So you have seen these pieces Brushy?
Feb 09, 2017, 07:55 PM
I've checked em out a few times E.C.
Last edited by Brushy Bandit; Feb 09, 2017 at 07:57 PM.
Feb 09, 2017, 08:01 PM
Last edited by EC.Mason; Feb 09, 2017 at 08:24 PM.
Feb 09, 2017, 08:08 PM
I seen your message ya sent DSL. Id love to find out all I can about this area, and would appreciate anything you would show me.
By TwiztidNick1979@yahell in forum West Virginia
Last Post: Feb 13, 2017, 06:02 AM
By swiftfan in forum Clubs & Hunts - Kentucky
Last Post: Feb 06, 2016, 05:45 AM
By -Ki- in forum The Lost Silver Mines of Jonathan Swift
Last Post: Apr 19, 2012, 07:11 AM
By -Ki- in forum The Lost Silver Mines of Jonathan Swift
Last Post: Jan 29, 2012, 09:44 AM
By Kentucky Kache in forum Treasure Legends - Kentucky
Last Post: Sep 20, 2011, 09:21 AM