Sorry, I forgot to mention that. It says Palmer, and after posting this I was able to do a quick google search of "Palmer medicine bottle" and found some results right away. Apparently its a hand-blown perfume or cologne bottle from the 1890s. There is nothing on the back of the President buckle, but I noticed the other one that has the 1892 date says "Shirley". That leaves the flat key. Can anyone put a date on that?