Nice pictures!
Your token appears to be NY630BV-7a which has a rarity rating of R6. Kanzinger's price guide give a value of $15 in VF for this token. That's the grade I would assign your piece.
Interestingly, the website justgeese found has one listed as a NY630BV-7a, but it is really a NY630BV-6a. Notice that the eagle's wing on yours is left of the A in AMERICA. On the one on the website, the eagle's wing is below the A. That's typical of the -6a reverse.
The E.S. at the base of the shield is the die sinker's initials. In this case, I think it stands for Emil Sigel.