Cleaning coins with a tumbler

[Turtleman]

To all who have cleaned clad with a tumbler,
I just got a tumbler to clean the couple hundred bucks of clad I found this year. What do all of you use in your tumbler, besides water, to aid in the cleaning process? How long do you allow the coins to tumble? Do you use different cleaning agents for different coins? Also any other tips about tumbling coins would be appreciated.
Thanks,
Turtleman

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Agony and Death on a Gold Rush Steamer: The Disastrous Sinking of the Side-Wheeler Yankee Blade - Grab it through Amazon!

[TORRERO]

I don't have a tumbler but I would use regular sand...
you can buy pellets that are made for cleaning brass....
But why would you if sand will do the same and you can steal some from
your kids playground....

 

[BJ in Okla.]

Turtleman,
This worked for me.
Don't mix coins.
Do zinks and copper together.
Dimes and quarters together.
I ran mine for about 4 to 8 hrs.
I used a small amount of Aquarium gravel.
1. tea spoon of Dawn soap.
1. tea spoon of Lemon juice.
add a little water, just to cover the coins.

One way to clean Nickels is to use 2 oz of white Vingar and 1 tea spoon of salt, check about ever 15 Min's. to see how they ear doing, I have used this with old V nickels that were in bad shape. Also used this on Buffs.
Hope this helps...
BJ in Okla.

 

[Michigan Badger]

BJ in Okla. got it right.

But after the cleaning dry them and get rid of them.

I've done a pile and a month later the coins looked worse than before cleaning.

Badger

 

[999slvrfx]

I use coarse sand or a fine gravel in mine.
Don't put pennies and clad together, it will turn
your clad a funky color. I usually run mine for a
couple of hours or until clean.

 

[IndianaSmith]

I bought a $3 bag of white aquarium rock at WallyWorld. I've tried it with & without dishsoap, didn't notice a difference. Also, change the water every so often, check it & you'll see how dirty it gets.

Smitty

 

[Silver Fox]

To all who have cleaned clad with a tumbler,
I just got a tumbler to clean the couple hundred bucks of clad I found this year. What do all of you use in your tumbler, besides water, to aid in the cleaning process? How long do you allow the coins to tumble? Do you use different cleaning agents for different coins? Also any other tips about tumbling coins would be appreciated.
Thanks,
Turtleman

It surprised me to see in the replies, so far, that no one mentioned that special white powder that is sold by Finch and it comes with pellets. I cleaned thousands of coins with that powder/pellets, rolled them and took them to the bank. I used to know metal detector dealer couple in The San Fernando Valley that used to use the liquid used by blueprint machines but you have to wear a mask when spilling it out as the fumes are potent.

For me, though, Finch did the job.

 

[Ant]

Check out my toumbling recipe, photos and my recycling tenique at this link:
http://forum.treasurenet.com/index.php/topic,60777.0.html

We all want to spend a less as possible when it comes to spending the coins we find or what’s the purpose.

 

[DaveNEPhila]

Another thing to consider is the type of tumbler rotary or vibratory. Vibratory are
usually used for polishing rings. I've been to a couple jewelry/gem shows and have seen powders for metal polishing.
The differences between the tumblers in processing stones is that the rotary will round the stones removing edges and the vibratory leaves stones with some of the edges.

I'd suggest taking a couple of the coins you'd like to clean with you to a gem show you'll find several jewelry makers and some might be willing to give some free advice.

Dave from NE Philadelphia, PA

 

[WV Hillbilly]

I use Ant's directions & works good for me . HH

 

[Treasure_Hunter]

I got a dual cyclinder tumbler at Harborfreight on sale for $29.00.

http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/ctaf/displayitem.taf?Itemnumber=90979

Like IndianaSmith, I just use white aquarium gravel from Walmart. Running it a couple hours gets them more then clean enough to cash them in if you want. Always seperate the pennies from the rest of the coins unless you want them a rusty color....

I just keep adding my clad coins to a 2.5 gallon plastic jug (pickle egg jar). I roll them ever so often, but put the rolls back in the jar. Maybe I will save enough up to buy a new truck when I retire.....

If it wasn't for Bernie Ebbers, I would be retired now...... Hope he is enjoying that cellmate !!!!!!

 

[RON (PA)]

Over the summer, I bought a single drum tumbler from Harbor Freight for about $19. Here is the recipe that I use.

Aquarium gravel (found at local pet store)
Fine sand (found at local craft store)
Tap water
A few drops of liquid dish soap
A splash of ammonia.


I initially tumble for approximatley 30 mins. and then I check them. Most of the time they come out great. If they are still cruddy, they go back in for another 30+ mins.


Hope it helps.

 

[srd1941]

Ron & Treasure Hunter
How are your Harbor Freight Tumblers holding up? Have you had any problems and if so what? I'm in the market for a tumbler and really don't want to spend a hundred bucks for a Thumbler.
Stan

 

[Treasure_Hunter]

So far mine has had no problems...............

 

[srd1941]

Treasure Hunter
Thanks for the reply. Why did you choose the double drum over the single drum tumbler? Doesn't it put more stress on the motor or does it have a bigger motor?
Thanks
Stan

 

[Treasure_Hunter]

One bin is for pennies, other one is for the rest of the clad coins.

I have yet to have a problem with it, but I dont run it till I have a full load of one so it is not like it is running every day.