The BH coils really are very reasonalbly priced. I have the 4 - 8 and 10, each has it's place. Depth at the exact center of the coil is really pretty simular, the arc of the field out to the 10 inch diameter will cover more ground at a deeper view per sweep.
The bigger the coil however the cleaner the ground needs to be, thats why the small coils are ran in the trashy stuff.
Good value for the money , Yes, are you going to find dimes at 12 inch , No .