Recasts or real deal?

[Beachkid23]

To me instinct says that these are remade. But I wanted to have you look at them before I toss them. They test for silver but they're so small I can't believe that they would be real. Are they old Spanish coins or ancient coins or sunken ship coins or are they just Sterling silver replicas? They are almost 3/8" in size mounted on earrings. Thanks!

 

[enamel7]

In my opinion they're just rough copies.

 

[coinsareawesome]

I agree

 

[Beachkid23]

Thanks! That's what I figured. But I wanted to make them sure before I just put them in a jewelry lot auction. Thank you for the help

 

[captain flintlock]

Test them for silver. They could actually be Atocha copies. Mel Fisher and Co. Would melt actual silver bars from the Atocha wreck and make copies of coins that were actually found on the wreck site and then sell them. I have a 1 reale necklace piece. If they acid test positive for silver then I would bet doughnuts for dollars that that's what they are. ☠

 

[captain flintlock]

The more I look at them, the more I think they are 1/2 reale Atocha copies. If they do test positive as silver, they are worth more than just sterling earrings. Not a ton more but worth selling separately.