Morning,
Back from the near dead here.....attacked by the creeping crud that has assailed 90% of the population of Louisiana.
I dont know about other states, but would imagine their laws are similar to Louisiana. It is illegal here to dig in a burial whether on public or private land. That is the letter of the law. It is illegal to possess, trade or sell what are classified as "grave goods"....something that is hard to quantify. What constitutes a "grave good"...a pot? really nice point? gorget? axe? All can be found totally apart from any burial settings. So enforcing the law on these points is nearly impossible unless you are caught plundering in known sites or Federal areas.
Private land to me should be that, "private." What you do on your own property should be your business. Legally it no longer is. Personally I agree with D2, I would not call an archaeologist onto a site unless I could see that it was something of archaeological significance. A small village with a few points and broken stuff is NOT archaeologically significant, nor is grubbing up a few points off the bottom of a dry reservoir where water, wave and erosion have long since destroyed any stratigraphy. It seems the "professionals" come, take, leave. Any consideration of the amateur is abandoned as soon as the site location is divulged, but that is only my experience.
I am certain that in time laws will be passed to stop all digging and probably all trade, selling or even possession of relics. I am not in favor of plundering burial grounds to make a profit off relics, but some balance should be possible between the hobbyist and those who wish all such activities to cease. Until then, I indend to continue to look, dig, and enjoy this most interesting of hobbies.
Atlantis