coolcash2004
Bronze Member
- Jun 9, 2006
- 2,005
- 41
- Detector(s) used
- ACE 250
Got the book earlier this morning. Not giving anything away though!
-CC
-CC
HARRY POTTER (May Contain Spoilers)
- Thread starter coolcash2004
- Start date
grizzly bare
Hero Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
Finished my copy a little earlier. Thought the writing in the first 100-150 pages was a bit weak for Rowling. Seemed a bit imprecise and wandering. Picked up well in the end though. I really like how Rowling plays with Harry's mind (and indirectly, that of the reader.) No real surprises...though I was upset by one death...
grizzlybare
Finished my copy a little earlier. Thought the writing in the first 100-150 pages was a bit weak for Rowling. Seemed a bit imprecise and wandering. Picked up well in the end though. I really like how Rowling plays with Harry's mind (and indirectly, that of the reader.) No real surprises...though I was upset by one death...
grizzlybare
gollum
Gold Member
- Jan 2, 2006
- 6,729
- 7,596
- Detector(s) used
- Minelab SD2200D (Modded)/ Whites GMT 24k / Fisher FX-3 / Fisher Gold Bug II / Fisher Gemini / Schiebel MIMID / Falcon MD-20
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
Re: HARRY POTTER
I had a .pdf of the book two weeks ago from a source in England. I just loved that all the spoilers out there were wrong. It is a possibility though, that Rowling rewrote the end of the book after that Italian Hacker posted the big spoiler.
Hey GB,
I think I know the one you're talking about. I never would have guessed F. Is that the one?
Best,
Mike
I had a .pdf of the book two weeks ago from a source in England. I just loved that all the spoilers out there were wrong. It is a possibility though, that Rowling rewrote the end of the book after that Italian Hacker posted the big spoiler.
Hey GB,
I think I know the one you're talking about. I never would have guessed F. Is that the one?
Best,
Mike
Attachments
roswellborn
Hero Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
I had to work yesterday, and coming home there was NO traffic. I mean it was like Thanksgiving day, there was so little traffic! That just isn't normal on a Saturday here.
All we can figure is that everyone was home, reading like mad. And still are - we aren't hearing any road noise today, either. wild.
I'm at Chapter 5, hubby has it right now (I'm leaving him alone so he'll read faster! )
Can't wait to get back at it
Nan
gollum! How the heck did you get a pdf?! I'm so jealous!
I had to work yesterday, and coming home there was NO traffic. I mean it was like Thanksgiving day, there was so little traffic! That just isn't normal on a Saturday here.
All we can figure is that everyone was home, reading like mad. And still are - we aren't hearing any road noise today, either. wild.
I'm at Chapter 5, hubby has it right now (I'm leaving him alone so he'll read faster! )
Can't wait to get back at it
Nan
gollum! How the heck did you get a pdf?! I'm so jealous!
gollum
Gold Member
- Jan 2, 2006
- 6,729
- 7,596
- Detector(s) used
- Minelab SD2200D (Modded)/ Whites GMT 24k / Fisher FX-3 / Fisher Gold Bug II / Fisher Gemini / Schiebel MIMID / Falcon MD-20
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
Re: HARRY POTTER
Someone in England brought the book home, and as you can see, went through page by page and took pics. Some of them are a little out of focus, but everything was readable.
I heard that the UK and the US versions are a little different.
Best,
Mike
Someone in England brought the book home, and as you can see, went through page by page and took pics. Some of them are a little out of focus, but everything was readable.
I heard that the UK and the US versions are a little different.
Best,
Mike
grizzly bare
Hero Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
gollum,
Yeah. That just didn't make any sense. Why kill off a great character when it doesn't add to the story or build on past foreshadowing? Anyway, I'm no great Potter scholar so maybe I didn't see something in an earlier book.
Personally, I think Rowling should write another book and call it Harry Potter and the Re-Built Hogwarts. Do a seventh year now that all this crap is out of the way.
I saw an interview she did and when the lady asked her if there was any possibility of another book, she hesitated and said ,"Well, anything's possible."
grizzly bare
gollum,
Yeah. That just didn't make any sense. Why kill off a great character when it doesn't add to the story or build on past foreshadowing? Anyway, I'm no great Potter scholar so maybe I didn't see something in an earlier book.
Personally, I think Rowling should write another book and call it Harry Potter and the Re-Built Hogwarts. Do a seventh year now that all this crap is out of the way.
I saw an interview she did and when the lady asked her if there was any possibility of another book, she hesitated and said ,"Well, anything's possible."
grizzly bare
Montana Jim
Gold Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
Did I just read something I should not have? Did you give something away?![:-\](https://www.treasurenet.com/smilies/undecided.gif "Undecided :-\")
I have not read it yet...
grizzly bare said:
Did I just read something I should not have? Did you give something away?
I have not read it yet...
Gypsy Heart
Gold Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
My children and I love these books.... what a wonderful journey of imagination Rowlings has given us. I hope they continue ,Harry has grandchildren and my children share them with theirs.
My children and I love these books.... what a wonderful journey of imagination Rowlings has given us. I hope they continue ,Harry has grandchildren and my children share them with theirs.
Leeame
Jr. Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
[/quote]
Did I just read something I should not have? Did you give something away? I have not read it yet...
[/quote]
No, you are still good. Book is great! Better than Order of the Phoenix, which was my favorite till yesterday!
tootles
Lisa
So Oregon
[/quote]
Did I just read something I should not have? Did you give something away?
I have not read it yet... [/quote]
No, you are still good. Book is great! Better than Order of the Phoenix, which was my favorite till yesterday!
tootles
Lisa
So Oregon
gollum
Gold Member
- Jan 2, 2006
- 6,729
- 7,596
- Detector(s) used
- Minelab SD2200D (Modded)/ Whites GMT 24k / Fisher FX-3 / Fisher Gold Bug II / Fisher Gemini / Schiebel MIMID / Falcon MD-20
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
Re: HARRY POTTER
I agree. No spoilers here yet. There are a BUNCH of people you wouldn't expect to get killed off.
Best,
Mike
I agree. No spoilers here yet. There are a BUNCH of people you wouldn't expect to get killed off.
Best,
Mike
OP
OP
coolcash2004
Bronze Member
- Jun 9, 2006
- 2,005
- 41
- Detector(s) used
- ACE 250
- Thread starter
- #11
Re: HARRY POTTER
Just finished it.
I would give it a 10/10. Best book I have ever read.
Yes: PLEASE, no spoilers on this post! In fact, no discussion of any kind about who dies/ doesnt for a while. Ratings are fine, but please no specifics. Thanks!
-CC
Just finished it.
I would give it a 10/10. Best book I have ever read.
Yes: PLEASE, no spoilers on this post! In fact, no discussion of any kind about who dies/ doesnt for a while. Ratings are fine, but please no specifics. Thanks!
-CC
grizzly bare
Hero Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
I don't believe there have been any spoilers YET...but I was confused when Dick Cheney showed up with a shotgun, but I totally saw that Martha Stewart frying pan thing coming long ago! And using an Explorer SE to find the missing ring was brilliant.
grizzly bare
I don't believe there have been any spoilers YET...but I was confused when Dick Cheney showed up with a shotgun, but I totally saw that Martha Stewart frying pan thing coming long ago! And using an Explorer SE to find the missing ring was brilliant.
grizzly bare
goldencoin
Gold Member
- Sep 27, 2005
- 5,669
- 446
- Detector(s) used
- Whites DFX & Beach Hunter ID
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
Re: HARRY POTTER
finished it this afternoon 8)
HH
-GC
finished it this afternoon 8)
HH
-GC
Montana Jim
Gold Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
grizzly bare said:
gollum
Gold Member
- Jan 2, 2006
- 6,729
- 7,596
- Detector(s) used
- Minelab SD2200D (Modded)/ Whites GMT 24k / Fisher FX-3 / Fisher Gold Bug II / Fisher Gemini / Schiebel MIMID / Falcon MD-20
- Primary Interest:
- All Treasure Hunting
Re: HARRY POTTER
Yes and the Frodo cameo was very nicely done!
Mike
grizzly bare said:
Yes and the Frodo cameo was very nicely done!
Mike
Re: HARRY POTTER
The ending of this book left me in a funk. It is the only one that has left me feeling a little sad. I think partly it was because after each book I was able to share with Harry the thoughts of the NEXT book. Yet, when this one ended, we all knew it was over, and there were no more. No more adventures. So, that left me saddened. But, more than that, the WAY it ended, in the last chapter (And no I won't put any spoilers here) make me think about what it talked about, and that, coupled with what I've written here made me feel even sadder.
There were a lot of things that happened that if you reflect on them, and how they affected the future of all the characters in the books (Again - trying to not say WHAT those things were) just ... made me feel a little depressed.
I won't say more, because then I'd have to say something that will give something away. In a few weeks we can discuss it more. :-) For those that haven't read or finished it yet, keep going. Like all the other books, it was long but worth the reading. :-)
John
The ending of this book left me in a funk. It is the only one that has left me feeling a little sad. I think partly it was because after each book I was able to share with Harry the thoughts of the NEXT book. Yet, when this one ended, we all knew it was over, and there were no more. No more adventures. So, that left me saddened. But, more than that, the WAY it ended, in the last chapter (And no I won't put any spoilers here) make me think about what it talked about, and that, coupled with what I've written here made me feel even sadder.
There were a lot of things that happened that if you reflect on them, and how they affected the future of all the characters in the books (Again - trying to not say WHAT those things were) just ... made me feel a little depressed.
I won't say more, because then I'd have to say something that will give something away. In a few weeks we can discuss it more. :-) For those that haven't read or finished it yet, keep going. Like all the other books, it was long but worth the reading. :-)
John
grizzly bare
Hero Member
Re: HARRY POTTER
jrf30,
Did the ending seem a little too generic for you? I totally went away feeling that I had read that before, that it wasn't a "Harry Potter" ending. I saw no need for the anger/dislike shown toward one character.
Of course, Harry's favorite dessert is treacle tart so treacle definitely fits in the end.
grizzly bare
jrf30,
Did the ending seem a little too generic for you? I totally went away feeling that I had read that before, that it wasn't a "Harry Potter" ending. I saw no need for the anger/dislike shown toward one character.
Of course, Harry's favorite dessert is treacle tart so treacle definitely fits in the end.
grizzly bare
OP
OP
coolcash2004
Bronze Member
- Jun 9, 2006
- 2,005
- 41
- Detector(s) used
- ACE 250
- Thread starter
- #18
Re: HARRY POTTER
Hmmm. If you ask me, the ending was perfect, it couldnt have ended any other way.
However, I do beleive it was kind of abrupt. After the big finale, it kind of just ended.
I do believe that the epilogue helped smooth things down a bit.
SPOILERS OK NOW! THANKS!
-CC
Hmmm. If you ask me, the ending was perfect, it couldnt have ended any other way.
However, I do beleive it was kind of abrupt. After the big finale, it kind of just ended.
I do believe that the epilogue helped smooth things down a bit.
SPOILERS OK NOW! THANKS!
-CC
OP
OP
coolcash2004
Bronze Member
- Jun 9, 2006
- 2,005
- 41
- Detector(s) used
- ACE 250
- Thread starter
- #19
THANKS MJ!!!
My response too, has been voided. Enjoy the book!
-CC
My response too, has been voided. Enjoy the book!
-CC
All the talk about the book for the past 6 months was saying that two of the main characters would be killed off in this book. (And depdning on who you call main and not, I counted more than two!) Rowling has said that herself. So, saying that deaths occurred is not a spoiler. Saying who or how would be a spoiler, but no one has yet. :-)
The epilogue is the area that DID put me in the funk. Coolcash, I'll email you with my reasons. See what you think.
John
The epilogue is the area that DID put me in the funk. Coolcash, I'll email you with my reasons. See what you think.
John
Top Member Reactions
-
2149 -
1001 -
945 -
940 -
846 -
797 -
781 -
680 -
565 -
551 -
476 -
473 -
454 -
O
444
-
442 -
433 -
417 -
400 -
375 -
367
