Meteorite identification

[stuart7]

I found this a few months ago and I have had one geologist look at it and they couldn't tell me what it was, I have since had a search around online and found that it has alot of features that a meteorite would have, it is magnetic and pretty heavy for its size.
If anyone can help with this it would be much appreciated

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Treasure of Victoria Peak - Grab it through Amazon!

[Clay Diggins]

"Bread-crust" type volcanic bomb

That's more than 300 million years old?

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A Handbook of Civil War Bullets and Cartridges - Grab it through Amazon!

[Clay Diggins]

OK so curve ball🤣 I took this to 2nd geologist who specialises in minerals and she told me that this is just a pyrite nodule, she said it with confidence and with no excitement so I'm going to presume it's rubbish🤣, would you guys agree with this or?

A mineralogist told you it was Pyrite so you presumed their opinion is rubbish?

Am I on the Treasure legends forum?

The mineralogist may be incorrect in her assessment but her answer does fit the photos provided. Maybe a third , fourth or fifth opinion until someone comes up with an acceptable answer?

 

[stuart7]

A mineralogist told you it was Pyrite so you presumed their opinion is rubbish?

Am I on the Treasure legends forum?

The mineralogist may be incorrect in her assessment but her answer does fit the photos provided. Maybe a third , fourth or fifth opinion until someone comes up with an acceptable answer?

I meant I presume this is rubbish talking about the rock itself not her opinion, she seen the rock in person but she didn't spend much time looking at it as I took a few things for her to look at

 

[stuart7]

Personally, I wouldn't agree... but then I haven't been able to examine it in hand. Who am I to argue with a geologist?

View attachment 2105756

If it is pyrite then it will streak black or greenish-black on the unglazed side of a porcelain tile. Streak firmly once or twice rather than rubbing to and fro, then blow the dust away and examine the colour of the streak itself.

I'm definitely going to give that a try, time to lift the old cistern lid

 

[Clay Diggins]

The streak test is a method used to determine the color of a mineral in powdered form. In this test, the mineral is scratched against a ceramic plate known as a streak plate and the resulting colored streak is observed.

For magnetite, the streak is typically black. When the mineral is scratched against a streak plate, it will leave a black streak.

For hematite, the streak is reddish-brown. If hematite is scratched against a streak plate, it will leave a reddish-brown streak.

For pyrite, the streak is dark greenish-black or brownish-black. When pyrite is scratched against a streak plate, it will leave a dark greenish-black or brownish-black streak.

It should be noted that the streak color can sometimes differ from the actual mineral color, so the streak test is a useful tool in mineral identification.

 

[Clay Diggins]

At lower temperatures (<about 800 K) and higher oxygen concentrations, pyrite will be directly oxidized. The direct oxidation process follows the unreacted core model and may be controlled by chemical reaction or the inward diffusion of oxygen due to the pore-blocking effect by the formation of ferric/ferrous sulfate.

Iron oxides (mainly hematite, Fe2O3 and magnetite, Fe3O4) are the main products of the oxidation of pyrite. Hematite usually forms at lower temperatures (<1173–1273 K) and at high oxygen concentrations, whereas magnetite usually forms at higher temperatures and/or at low oxygen concentrations.

 

[Clay Diggins]

It is not possible to make pyrite (also known as fool's gold) at home. Pyrite is a natural mineral that is formed in geological processes over long periods of time. It is not something that can be artificially created in a home setting.

 

[dougachim]

Don't cut it, there is nothing spectacular inside, it is more valuable uncut

If it is a meteorite it doesn't hurt the value.

 

[stuart7]

If it is a meteorite it doesn't hurt the value.

The hopes of it being a meteorite are gone I'm afraid 🤣

 

[Digger RJ]

I found this a few months ago and I have had one geologist look at it and they couldn't tell me what it was, I have since had a search around online and found that it has alot of features that a meteorite would have, it is magnetic and pretty heavy for its size.
If anyone can help with this it would be much appreciated
View attachment 2104969View attachment 2104970View attachment 2104971View attachment 2104973View attachment 2104970

Nice!!! Congrats!!!

 

[Tesorodeoro]

Just ask chatgpt and it sounds almost exactly like what clay posted

Tell me this isn’t true. I have much disrespect for those that use AI to appear intelligent.

 

[Clay Diggins]

Tell me this isn’t true. I have much disrespect for those that use AI to appear intelligent.

Anyone using AI to appear more intelligent is going to be very disappointed. There are several on these forums who use it extensively, anyone who actually reads their posts would recognize something out of place.

Real AI doesn't exist yet. The recent media hype seems to be directed towards the IPO of Open AI. Once that monetization of the fake AI is complete look for media interest and AI stock prices to take a nosedive.

What is called AI today is basically the consensus of the masses as found on the internet. In other words it's wrong more than half the time and when it's right it gets the details wrong. But it does provide content for those individuals and routines unable to rely on their own knowledge or thought processes.

If the trend continues It will, in my opinion, eventually lead to the death of forums and reasonable internet communication among humans. It's already happened to several forums and social media apps. This will continue until either people wake up to the fact that our means of communication are being co-opted or until the "AI" dumbing down is complete and all your content/conversation is controlled by poorly designed machines with an agenda.

Or all this could be wild speculation and your suspicions about AI content on this forum are mistaken.

 

[stuart7]

Anyone using AI to appear more intelligent is going to be very disappointed. There are several on these forums who use it extensively, anyone who actually reads their posts would recognize something out of place.

Real AI doesn't exist yet. The recent media hype seems to be directed towards the IPO of Open AI. Once that monetization of the fake AI is complete look for media interest and AI stock prices to take a nosedive.

What is called AI today is basically the consensus of the masses as found on the internet. In other words it's wrong more than half the time and when it's right it gets the details wrong. But it does provide content for those individuals and routines unable to rely on their own knowledge or thought processes.

If the trend continues It will, in my opinion, eventually lead to the death of forums and reasonable internet communication among humans. It's already happened to several forums and social media apps. This will continue until either people wake up to the fact that our means of communication are being co-opted or until the "AI" dumbing down is complete and all your content/conversation is controlled by poorly designed machines with an agenda.

Or all this could be wild speculation and your suspicions about AI content on this forum are mistaken.

🤦‍♂️

 

[Garscale]

This thread has been so great. I hate to see it die.

 

[stuart7]

This thread has been so great. I hate to see it die.

I'm going to need to do the streak test on it to get people talking again 🤣, took a bit of an AI turn in here

 

[Tesorodeoro]

I'm going to need to do the streak test on it to get people talking again 🤣, took a bit of an AI turn in here

Seriously though, setting AI aside..

“Slicing or cutting a meteorite can have varying effects on its value, depending on several factors:

1. Type of Meteorite: Some meteorites are valued for their internal structure and composition. Slicing or cutting these meteorites can reveal their unique features, potentially increasing their value. However, for meteorites prized for their intact, natural shape, cutting can decrease their value.
2. Aesthetic Appeal: The way a meteorite is sliced and displayed can significantly impact its value. If the slicing and presentation enhance its aesthetic appeal, it may fetch a higher price among collectors.
3. Scientific Research: Meteorites are essential for scientific research, and cutting them may be necessary to study their interior or conduct specific tests. In such cases, the value for scientific purposes can outweigh any decrease in collectible value.
4. Rareness: If the meteorite is exceptionally rare, cutting it may be acceptable if it serves a scientific or educational purpose. However, cutting a more common meteorite can decrease its value, especially if it damages its unique features.
5. Size: Reducing the size of a meteorite through cutting may decrease its value since collectors often prefer larger specimens.
6. Provenance and Documentation: Proper documentation of the meteorite’s history, including any cutting or slicing, is crucial. Transparency about any alterations can help maintain or even increase its value if the modifications serve a legitimate purpose.

In summary, the impact of slicing or cutting on a meteorite’s value depends on its type, how it’s done, and the purpose behind the modification. For valuable or rare meteorites, consulting with experts and collectors is advisable before making any alterations. Proper documentation is also essential to maintain the meteorite’s authenticity and provenance.”

Personally, I’d get a rock saw and cut a slab off.

First it will aid in positive identification. It will always be just a rock without confirmation it came from space.

Second, it would serve as an even base for display purposes.

That’s just me.

 

[Al D]

What you have is one of the most unique and perfect examples of a lava bomb that I have ever seen.
Enough knowledgable people here have told you that it is not a meteorite, but if you choose to not believe them, then go ahead and cut the damn thing.
you will come to regret that decision.

 

[Emil W]

What you have is one of the most unique and perfect examples of a lava bomb that I have ever seen.
Enough knowledgable people here have told you that it is not a meteorite, but if you choose to not believe them, then go ahead and cut the damn thing.
you will come to regret that decision.

Agreed.

Absolutely, positively, without question--bet my life on it--NOT a meteorite.

It's like thinking a Lincoln cent may be an Indian Head, it's that obvious.

 

[dougachim]

Seriously though, setting AI aside..

“Slicing or cutting a meteorite can have varying effects on its value, depending on several factors:

1. Type of Meteorite: Some meteorites are valued for their internal structure and composition. Slicing or cutting these meteorites can reveal their unique features, potentially increasing their value. However, for meteorites prized for their intact, natural shape, cutting can decrease their value.
2. Aesthetic Appeal: The way a meteorite is sliced and displayed can significantly impact its value. If the slicing and presentation enhance its aesthetic appeal, it may fetch a higher price among collectors.
3. Scientific Research: Meteorites are essential for scientific research, and cutting them may be necessary to study their interior or conduct specific tests. In such cases, the value for scientific purposes can outweigh any decrease in collectible value.
4. Rareness: If the meteorite is exceptionally rare, cutting it may be acceptable if it serves a scientific or educational purpose. However, cutting a more common meteorite can decrease its value, especially if it damages its unique features.
5. Size: Reducing the size of a meteorite through cutting may decrease its value since collectors often prefer larger specimens.
6. Provenance and Documentation: Proper documentation of the meteorite’s history, including any cutting or slicing, is crucial. Transparency about any alterations can help maintain or even increase its value if the modifications serve a legitimate purpose.

In summary, the impact of slicing or cutting on a meteorite’s value depends on its type, how it’s done, and the purpose behind the modification. For valuable or rare meteorites, consulting with experts and collectors is advisable before making any alterations. Proper documentation is also essential to maintain the meteorite’s authenticity and provenance.”

Personally, I’d get a rock saw and cut a slab off.

First it will aid in positive identification. It will always be just a rock without confirmation it came from space.

Second, it would serve as an even base for display purposes.

That’s just me.

Can't get it tested and approved by anyone without cutting it.

 

[Tesorodeoro]

Yes and that comment was relating to a possible meteorite. A volcanic bomb is something else I’ve never heard of despite living in the immediate vicinity of a dormant volcano. We will see if this thread grows legs.