Okemah Treasure

Gypsy Heart

Gold Member
Nov 29, 2005
12,686
339
Ozarks
Almost every where on the Indian Territory side of Oklahoma from the Kansas border to Red River one can hear tales of Spanish treasure being buried, usually several "jack" loads. Practically every county on the east side of the state has a buried treasure location. In the book "Coronado's Children" written by a professor of Texas State University, two locations are mentioned in Oklahoma. Invariably the story is that the treasure was buried by Spainards because of hostile Indian bands, who sought to take it away from them. The following story varies from the usual form, in that the gold was buried by white men and it was California gold.

In 1899 Bud Andrews rented a farm from an indian by the name of Cornelius about ten miles southwest of Okemah, Oklahoma. This farm is now known as the Dave Maloy farm. Andrew's place was something of a half way stopping point between Wetumka and the Arbeka Trading Post, then being run by Mrs. Alice B. Davis, who later became Chieftainess of the Seminole Indian Nation.

Mr. William Marks, father of Mrs. Hardy Cochran, then lived in the "pot" country, and one November evening drove up to the Andrews place and asked for lodging for the night. It was nearly dark, he said and had been drizzeling and sleeting all afternoon. While he was unhitching his team, an indian by the name of Bob Deere, who was a neighbor of Marks, and an old man by the name of Timpkins also drove up, and asked to stay all night. Timpkins went into the house, while Deere took care of his team. Marks knew Deere very wel1, but Timpkins only by reputation.

According to Marks, Deere was a large man, six feet three inches tall, and weighed over 200 pounds, and had a 23 inch neck.

"Beside him" said Marks, who was an average sized ,man, "I looked like a boy. I asked Deere what he was doing over here, for Timpkins was never known to do a lick of work, and had the reputation of being a successful money hunter. This is the story that he told me:

"In 1852" said Deere, "I was scouting for the government, working out from Fort Gibson. A white man rode up to my house one night. He asked to stay all night. I lived between Ft. Gibson and what is now Muskogee. This man he bad wounded. I took, him in. My wife she nursed white man till he died two weeks. He and two white men started from California to go home to Tennessee. They had lots gold dust and nuggets. Took it two horses to haul it. Band of white men chased them for week. Going to take it gold. After they crossed Cayenne mountains they got away. Crossed Dog Ford on Canadanian. hid in brush, dug hole, put gold in ground. Four sacks in buffalo hide. Climbed big red oak tree, cut it picture of man with one arm, chopping knife in hand pointing down and to southwest. Started for Ft. Gibson. Fight with white men near mountain called Bald Hill. Two men killed, white man get away in dark, come to my house. See light in window. Shot all to pieces. Hurt bad. He die. Long time ago. Old man Timpkins come to my house, Shawnee town. Want me to take him to Dog Ford. He say he find that gold. Give me some when I show him Dog Ford."

The next morning according to Mr. Marks, it was still drizzling and Indian like, without saying anything to any one, Deere hitched up and drove away without his breakfast and without saying anything to Timpkins. It was about two weeks before Mr. Marks returned to his home below Shawnee-town, and then it was he fould that Deere had died with lung fever within a few days after returning home from Andrews in the Creek country.

Two years later in 1900 Mr. Marks moved from the Pot country to to the Creek Nation and rented 200 acres of land from Mrs. Alice Davis near the Arbeka trading Post. One morning in January while hunting squirrels down near Dog Ford he meet up with a Mr. Harve Malot who was at that time an employee in the Bank at Okemah run by W. H. Dill. While talking to Mr. Malot amd discussing the luck they had had that morning hunting Mr. Marks noticed a large hole near by, which had the appearance of having been recently dug and he called Mr. Malots attention to it.

"I dug that hole" said Mr. Malot.

"You did! What were you digging for?" asked Marks.

"I was digging for California gold that is supposed to be buried around here somewhere. My mineral rod located there, but I think it must have been working to gas, or something else."

Then Malot went to tell a story very similar to the story Bob Deere had told Marks, and added that about ten years before two skeletons were found on the west side of Bald Hill. They had been there a long long time by their appearance, and one of them had a bullet hole thru the skull. No solution according to Malot had been offered for them.

Marks did not tell Malot that he was acquainted with the story but he decided then and there to do a little prospecting for him self. Some two weeks after his conversation with Malot, Marks found a man's head and shoulders, and one arm, with the arem pointing downward and to the southeast, but it was carved on a big Post Oak tree, instead of a Red Oak as Deere had described it. There was not a red oak tree according to Marks ten inches through within a mile of Dog Ford.

The figure was about thirty inches long, and about six feet up from the ground. The end of arm which was supposed to have a chopping knife in the place of a hand had more the appearance of an anchor, and this was not discernable until the bark was cut' off which had grown over the carving. It all had the appearance of having been carved at least fifty years, and the fact that it was so high up on the trunk of the tree, there being a branch or two below it it had escaped the attention of hunters. Marks without further search decided he had discovered the one landmark which would disclose the place of the buried treasure.

He obtained a mineral rod, and over a peroid of 12 years dug number of holes, but he was not successful in locating the treasure. Mr. Marks thru the years did not take any one into his confidence, and it was not until 1931, over Twenty-five years later, when he took the writer to the locality and gave him the story as stated, and said:

"I am geeting old, I have never told this to a living soul before, but if you can find it you are welcome to it."

Mr. Marks died several years ago, and the story can now be released.

When we visited the place, the tree had been cut down which had the carving on it, either cut up for fuel or fence posts. However Mr. Marks went right to the spot, and pointed out the stump, which was still standing. In order to reach it one must travel the old road from Schoolton to Boley Bridge. It is approximately a quarter of a mile from the old Negro Church. Dog Ford was an old crossing on the North Canadaian river above Boley Bridge not far from the Dill ranch. Cayenne Mts. mentioned by Deere is a low range of hills in Pottawattomie county, and the Pot country was the name given to the section where Shawnee now stands. There were a number of holds but none dug in the vincity of the stump, and Mr. Marks said he could account for every one. No one has apparently prospected within a quarter of a mile of the tree which had the carving on it. Apparently mineral rod did not near it. No one has ever found the gold and again the buried money story runs true to form.

Stories of Early Oklahoma - A collection of interesting facts, biographical sketches and stories relating to the history of Oklahoma, Assembled by Hazel Ruby McMahan (Mrs. James W.), State Historian for Oklahoma Society Daughters of American Revolution, 1945. (Copy at Oklahoma Historical Society Library, call number F/699/S7)
 

RGINN

Gold Member
Oct 16, 2007
8,613
10,764
Summit County, CO
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
1
Detector(s) used
White's DFX, White's Classic 1 Coinmaster, Nokta Pointer
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Good info as always GH. 'Coronado's Children' was written by J. Frank Dobie and you should give him credit. He once said the real gold is to be found in writing about lost treasure.
 

docmann

Sr. Member
Jan 2, 2009
277
69
OKLAHOMA!
Detector(s) used
Rarely!
GH,
Interesting story! The only criticism I might add would be that the Indians, at the time of the Spaniards, would have had little interest in their gold. They would, however, have been very interested in their livestock and scalps. Otherwise, good story.
docmann
 

OP
OP
Gypsy Heart

Gypsy Heart

Gold Member
Nov 29, 2005
12,686
339
Ozarks
docmann said:
GH,
Interesting story! The only criticism I might add would be that the Indians, at the time of the Spaniards, would have had little interest in their gold. They would, however, have been very interested in their livestock and scalps. Otherwise, good story.
docmann

You know,I used to think that also, then after studying a few of the ancients,I came to realize that Indians would have gone after what they knew the Spaniards valued....They might not have known its true worth,but they knew others wanted it,which was a good reason to take it.
 

Monty

Gold Member
Jan 26, 2005
10,746
166
Sand Springs, OK
Detector(s) used
ACE 250, Garrett
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
The problem I have heard about much so called lost treasure in Oklahoma is that the stories are told so often they are always so distorted they haven't much merit. You will hear about a supposed treasure near Muskogee, but thenext year it will be the same story about Lawton, clear across the state. And wait awhile and it will be somewhere else. There is treasure legend about outlaw loot in a place called "Lost City". That's less than 5 miles from my house. Most of the lost city area has been developed and I grew up hunting and playing on the Lost City area. There is no treasure there and it is called lost city because the big rock bluffs look like buildings and they are out in the woods. I still have people asking me about it and there isn't 40 acres left that don't have something built on it including a county park! Mony
 

RGINN

Gold Member
Oct 16, 2007
8,613
10,764
Summit County, CO
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
1
Detector(s) used
White's DFX, White's Classic 1 Coinmaster, Nokta Pointer
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Once again, the real gold in treasure lies in writing about it...we all like reading it too. There always seems to be a main thread in treasure stories. Like '17 mule loads of gold' or 'Cave with the Iron Door'. The locations are different and the principal characters tend to vary. Most modern gossip is based on one little fact, however mis-perceived. I have heard stories since the 50's. Based on my research, I have come to the conclusion that there are 17 (not 15 or 16) mule loads of something, hidden in a cave with an iron door, somewhere between the Mexican and Canadian border. The stories still get me fired up, and like gold, treasure is where you find it!
 

docmann

Sr. Member
Jan 2, 2009
277
69
OKLAHOMA!
Detector(s) used
Rarely!
RGINN,
Amen! When I was just out of high school, I recall reading about the Lost Dutchman's Gold Mine. I was just sure that with a little persistence I could walk right into those Superstition Mountains and find that gold. After all, I just had to follow the directions regarding Weavers' Needle and lining up the shadows, or was that...em...finding the cactus skin moccasin cache and going due west...or, uh wait a minute, there was something about a hoya (hole), etc. After several decades, it occurred to me that Curt Gentry (author of Killer Mountains) found the gold, and he found a little bit more with each book sold. Not that there hasn't been gold buried and later found, but lets face it, if even a thenth of the stories about buried treasure were real, well, I could just about retire my medical school debt and half of the national debt. Most important, however, is your comment "treasure is where you find it". I'll take a flint arrow head over a hundred dollar bill any day--something that was formed and fashioned by human hands hundreds of years ago. Now that's treasure. Now my brother, sharp shooter, would probably say that same thing about a 19th century coin. (Personally, I think all that beepin he's listened to from his MD over the past few years has probably warped his mind so what does he know?!). Nonetheless, RGINN, I guess we wouldn't be American if we didn't have some pot of gold to chase after. By the way, have you heard about the gold hidden in Red Rock Canyon? Well, seems that back in 1872 some outlaws somewhere, robbed some bank for some small fortune and .....well,....you know the rest.
Come see us sometime,
doc
 

RGINN

Gold Member
Oct 16, 2007
8,613
10,764
Summit County, CO
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
1
Detector(s) used
White's DFX, White's Classic 1 Coinmaster, Nokta Pointer
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
Yeah I know that story Docmann, it was from the bank at Bridgeport. Or maybe Gracemont. Gypsy Heart does a good service to this website by passing on stories of buried treasure. I like to read them, and many folks have never heard them. There's also a certain feeling I can't really describe associated with holding an arrowhead in your hand that was last touched a 1,000 years ago. There's a connection there... And if I find one of the treasures Gypsy Heart tells us about, adios amigos, I'm gone, I will have my own website (if I care to) where I will be a 'treasure consultant'. Til then, the small pleasures like arrowhead hunting and Oklahoma treasure stories will keep me amused.
 

docmann

Sr. Member
Jan 2, 2009
277
69
OKLAHOMA!
Detector(s) used
Rarely!
[size=13pt]RGINN
Let's make a deal. The first one that gets rich with such a find hires the other one as a consultant, gold brick, and general sponge. I know a hundred places to hunt flint and I'll then be able to get to every darn one of them. Until then, we'll just plug along.
Take care,
docmann
 

dirtyray

Greenie
Jun 12, 2011
14
2
YES I AGREE THERE WAY TOO MANY "STORIES" ABOUT LOST GOLD I THINK ITS A BUNCH OF HOCKEY PUCK MYSELF IF ALL THIS GOLD IS IN OKLAHOMA ......"PROVE IT " LOL ILL CARRY IT OUT FOR YOU...................................................................
 

goverton

Sr. Member
Oct 9, 2010
407
45
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
dirtyray said:
YES I AGREE THERE WAY TOO MANY "STORIES" ABOUT LOST GOLD I THINK ITS A BUNCH OF HOCKEY PUCK MYSELF IF ALL THIS GOLD IS IN OKLAHOMA ......"PROVE IT " LOL ILL CARRY IT OUT FOR YOU...................................................................

All the Oil is in Texas and all the Gold is in Oklahoma.... :laughing9: :tongue3:
 

jhicks

Newbie
Aug 26, 2012
2
0
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I live in okemah and will be looking for it. Hope i find it!
 

Trooper733

Sr. Member
Apr 3, 2013
388
315
Eastern Oklahoma
Detector(s) used
Whites V3i,Whites DFX, Whites TRX, Garrett Pro Pointer
Primary Interest:
Other
Boley to Schoolton Bridge actually did exist

I know the area very well that is mentioned, the Boley to Schoolton Road/Bridge was located on the Okfuskee/Seminole County line over the North Canadian River. See attached image. Red line indicates old road bed and approximate location of bridge span - give or take due to change of river course. Also, the church mentioned is located approximately 1 mile North of the river, at the first county road intersection. I had an old friend and metal detectorist who has now passed away that told the story to me with differing and more precise details. Due to the loss of the landmarks it has been a fruitless search to date. I have actually interviewed elderly folks that remember seeing the landmarks. I would love to see it found if it does in fact exist, whether its me or someone else that finds it. I also listed the photo in dowsing for any help from a map or photo dowser, to see if anything pops. Like the others have said, entertaining at the least.
 

Attachments

  • Boley-Schoolton Road.jpg
    Boley-Schoolton Road.jpg
    200.8 KB · Views: 692
Last edited:

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Top