Tell me what you see

[RustyRelics]

What do you notice about this guy, other than the fact that he is dead? Look closely.



Colorised photo of a dead rebel soldier, 1st Manassass.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Minelab PRO-FIND 35 Waterproof Pinpointer Metal Detector for Experts with Tone ID & Adjustable Sensitivity - Grab it through Amazon!

[RustyRelics]

1860's fake news...at least in photography.

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

A History of Mining on the Kenai Peninsula, Alaska - Grab it through Amazon!

[devldog]

Rusty,

I've seen this pic before in one of my civil war mags and I have to agree with Pull tab, this was a staged photo, hence the extra equipment as Smokey pointed out and the cartridge box around his waist with upside down buckle. If not mistaken this young man was restaged for another photograph by the same photographers...

"D"

I had heard some years ago that this pic. was a staged photo of a dead Confetrit Infantryman, supposedly a Georgia Sharpshooter.

 

[RustyRelics]

This is the picture that y'all are thinking about. This was taken at Devils Den in Gettysburg, on July 5th or 6th. He was supposedly a Georgia Sharpshooter. The one I posted is from First Manassas.

 

[Davers]

I'm not mad at you for posting a picture "For a Quiz" , If it were not 'already public' I'd see an issue , ie, a persons dead body in Iraq , SE Atlanta .

I like the black & white better , was this / these not photos that Mr Brady took / set up?

 

[RustyRelics]

I'm not mad at you for posting a picture "For a Quiz" , If it were not 'already public' I'd see an issue , ie, a persons dead body in Iraq , SE Atlanta .

I like the black & white better , was this / these not photos that Mr Brady took / set up?

I believe it was Mathew Brady that took the photograph.

 

[research guy]

Belt buckle upside down

I'm thinking that was the objective of this question, to point out that the buckle is upside down. But from the dead guys perspective, he was reading it properly when he put it on! Hahaha!

 

[ARC]

A picture can be worth 1000 words... and feelings go with those words... and war being an ugly business...
to hide it would be like putting blinders on and desensitize those who only hear about what others saw.

Sometimes a deterrent to crying for war... Is the crying done when one see's the aftermath of the one before it.

 

[moosescout]

View attachment 1724892

This is the picture that y'all are thinking about. This was taken at Devils Den in Gettysburg, on July 5th or 6th. He was supposedly a Georgia Sharpshooter. The one I posted is from First Manassas.

The only problem is there were no pictures of the dead taken at the first Manassas/Bull Run. The recorded first were Antietam. (So claimed) 2nd Manassas maybe? I don’t know.

 

[devldog]

I have the book A Journey in Time by Matthew Brady. This is a book of photo 's that Matthew Brady took right after the Battle of Gettysburg. Many of these photo's were made of specific areas of the battlefield just after the battle took place and then photo's of the exact same area in modern times to give the reader a chance to see how much or how little the areas have changed. Very interesting. The photo of the dead Confederate Sharpshooter is pictured a short distance away where he originally fell, and the second photo is where the body was photographed behind the stone wall position after the body was moved. This was a staged photo.

 

[RustyRelics]

The only problem is there were no pictures of the dead taken at the first Manassas/Bull Run. The recorded first were Antietam. (So claimed) 2nd Manassas maybe? I don’t know.

You are right. I just looked it up, and this guy was from Spotsylvania. An old book I read had it incorrectly labeled. Sorry 'bout that.

 

[Kray Gelder]

Obviously, some of you think differently about our war dead. Let's dredge up a photo from Afghanistan, from the last few years, of a dead American soldier. Then we can have another quiz. Is his belt buckle upside down? Is it even regulation? What other non-regulation gear does he have? How many wounds? What size boots? Is that where he died, or was his body posed? Was he a sniper or just a grunt? What state is he from? We can do it in black and white, because the contrast is so much better.
LACK OF RESPECT. Pure and simple.

 

[devldog]

I'm posting these photo's from the book I was talking about earlier, Gettysburg A Journey In Time. This is not done out of Disrespect to the fallen. I have the utmost Respect for those that died in that terrible war even 154 years later. When Mathew Brady and Gardner photographed the battlefields and at times the dead, he attempted to show the real horrors of that war. And True Horrors it was then and continues to this day. These photo's are a part of our countries History....and Horror. The main problem I had with the photo's was when the dead were moved and posted for cinematic effect, such as this poor Sharpshooter. Again, I posted this to show that this was unfortunately done in recording our History. Not out of Disrespect in anyway. View attachment 1726428 CH]

 

[Eagleone1025]

There is NOT in any way a disrespectful thing about this photo or the way it is being displayed. It is a major part of our history and that of the worlds history. We, as a people, no, as a species CAN NOT learn from the past or even the present if we can not be a part of it. The horrors of war are REAL and should be talked about, studied and ridiculed at times. There is no learning without witnessing. What this young man did, was, I believe to help those of us in the forum, especially us newbies learn about our history. This learning can bring a greater respect for our past as well as educate the historian/treasure hunter of the world in which we are dwelling in. NOW, if people were to make fun of the deceased, then that my brothers and sisters would be disrespectful.
May the Good God of all creation rest that young mans soul and all those who have gone before us. And may we learn from their experiences and our own to help build a better world, even in our own communities to prevent these things from continuing. May all of us "Treasure Hunters" be respectful with what we find and cherish the history behind them.

 

[devldog]

There is NOT in any way a disrespectful thing about this photo or the way it is being displayed. It is a major part of our history and that of the worlds history. We, as a people, no, as a species CAN NOT learn from the past or even the present if we can not be a part of it. The horrors of war are REAL and should be talked about, studied and ridiculed at times. There is no learning without witnessing. What this young man did, was, I believe to help those of us in the forum, especially us newbies learn about our history. This learning can bring a greater respect for our past as well as educate the historian/treasure hunter of the world in which we are dwelling in. NOW, if people were to make fun of the deceased, then that my brothers and sisters would be disrespectful.
May the Good God of all creation rest that young mans soul and all those who have gone before us. And may we learn from their experiences and our own to help build a better world, even in our own communities to prevent these things from continuing. May all of us "Treasure Hunters" be respectful with what we find and cherish the history behind them.

Amen Eagleone, and Well Said.

 

[4seasons]

Must have been CNN reporting.

1860's fake news...at least in photography.

 

[devldog]

Must have been CNN reporting.

Or, how about UNN? Union Network News? Lol