Adam, you found a 1916 Buffalo nickel? It's worth as much as other common buffalo nickels. Dealers usually pay $.75 to $1.00 for a common date circulated Buffalo. I don't even think I have that date amongst the ones I bought when I was a kid. Nice find. I don't search nickels but am considering it just to find a buffalo. Yeah I have my share of 90%ers, 40%ers, 90% Roosies, Frankies, Walkers, wheats found from CRH but would like some variety. Buffalos and War Nickels would be nice to add but I don't know if the time is worth it to just find one or two per box because I'd have go throught the whole box. One can't tell be just looking on the side profile so one would have to open the rolls all up.