1921 S Morgan Dollar grading

[TreasureCatto]

Helping a friend of my father grade this Morgan dollar for his collection. Do you agree on the grade?

 

[MCH]

No expert, seems like very slight wear, grade 58 - 60; nice coin.

 

[Dozer D]

Might grade even better than MS-60

 

[cudamark]

Hard to be accurate just going by a photo with the coin in a holder. Marks on the plastic can look like marks on the coin.

 

[TreasureCatto]

Hard to be accurate just going by a photo with the coin in a holder. Marks on the plastic can look like marks on the coin.

I've been aware of that and those cases. I gently rubbed it with a cloth before taking the photos. He told me those marks have been on the coin before casing it and storing it in a box.

 

[Hobbs.]

Your Morgan looks fairly well struck. The holder and lighting do make it difficult to grade. I do see very slight marking on the cheek and neck, and I assume those are on the coin.

Helping a friend of my father grade this Morgan dollar for his collection. Do you agree on the grade?
View attachment 1778065View attachment 1778066View attachment 1778067View attachment 1778068View attachment 1778069

 

[A2coins]

Cant tell from a picture scrathes or marks coin shows have people who will professionally grade them free most times.

 

[Johnnybravo300]

Why does it need graded? Writing on a cardboard flip doesnt really mean anything but in the world of coins it would be considered "circulated" and that's about it. That's ms60 and theres millions of them.
Its basic circulated in decent shape.
I was just curious but it is in nice shape.