Any Ideas??

[Complex]

Help identify this Stone

 

Amazon Forum Fav 👍

Cry Of The Eagle: History And Legends Of The Cherokee Indians And Their Buried Treasure - Grab it through Amazon!

[50bmg]

a rock

 

[Itsmine]

small rock?

 

[Deftone]

Wheew!Some solid ID's there.

 

[diggummup]

Resembles garnet

 

[Charlie P. (NY)]

Resembles staroulite as well. And coal. And lots of things.

 

[Complex]

Does this mean could be a rare mineral? Its very hard to define

 

[galenrog]

The nature of the replies mean that it resembles at least a few things. There will probably be more opinions concerning your rock. The most important thing you should be able to take from this is that many rocks look similar to many others. It is frequently difficult to tell with photos alone.

When I collected my own lapidary rough, I found that on some rough, I was wrong far more than I was right. Even today, I will misidentify part of the time. Of course, some of that could be lingering effects of the stroke.

Past time for more coffee. But morning will come. Dutch Bros 911. Large.

 

[Complex]

The nature of the replies mean that it resembles at least a few things. There will probably be more opinions concerning your rock. The most important thing you should be able to take from this is that many rocks look similar to many others. It is frequently difficult to tell with photos alone.

When I collected my own lapidary rough, I found that on some rough, I was wrong far more than I was right. Even today, I will misidentify part of the time. Of course, some of that could be lingering effects of the stroke.

Past time for more coffee. But morning will come. Dutch Bros 911. Large.

Hahaha!!! applies to me too, with every step am taking to identify it the more am getting confused** I need a gemologist effective immediate Heheh!!!

 

[TheCannonballGuy]

Complex, welcome to TreasureNet.

The What-Is-It? forum is mainly for getting unknown "man-made" objects identified. Your rock is a "natural" object. To get a rock identified, you'll have better luck by posting it in T-Net's "Rocks/Gems" forum.
Rocks/Gems

 

[galenrog]

If you want to make viewing answers a lot easier, do not ask the same question in more than one thread. Since you are asking the same question about the same rock in no less than three threads, you serve only to confuse and irritate many who might be inclined to help you.

Moderators, would you please combine the threads on this topic, and move to correct section, if necessary.

 

[bradyboy]

Galen
This is a new member, he's learning and understanding how tnet works - try not to turn him off
ALL of us here started out newbies, not having a clue how to navigate and the rules, we learn as we go
Ive been slapped a few times
A suggestion works better than a lecture - IMO
Brady boy

 

[Complex]

Galen
This is a new member, he's learning and understanding how tnet works - try not to turn him off
ALL of us here started out newbies, not having a clue how to navigate and the rules, we learn as we go
Ive been slapped a few times
A suggestion works better than a lecture - IMO
Brady boy

Thanks for understanding, We all start from somewhere