[=Cornelius ]
Air - jets = construct them yourself
*****************
Actually not difficult, a few simple experiments and calc. will give you the correct dimensions for the particular project.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Well , a hydraulic motor works with pistons or vanes . The same will go for a air propulsion motor
****************
Agreed, but this would require a large pressure tank with obviously limited time unless you go via torpedo type motors which are prohibitively expensive. Also this would give more moving parts and expense.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Again what do you do with the exhaust air .
***************
Exhaust it into the surrounding medium, this is what gives it a reactive momentum.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Do you use an air regulator ?
***************
One could use an old mouth regulator for creating a set pressure above the ambient ATM
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Since the outside waterpressure could be 4 Ata , what would your working pressure be ?
**************
Whatever your calc, and tests show that is required. This would depend upon many factors. Obviously what would be required or a small ROV would not be suitable for say the Queen Mary.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Now , tell me are you using jets or are you using a trolling motor ?
**************
Both, the trolling motor for longitudinal movement, and the jets, for axial and vertical movements.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Reversing polarity with a DC Motor is well known .
Using additional servo motors etc etc . does not make the contraption simpler . It takes more electronics while not making the operation any better .
**************
Agreed, but there basically would be only one motor, the trolling motor. All of the other movements would be controlled by perhaps (4) small electrical on/off valves of low voltage.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
The movement you are after should be a constant motion , either forward , reversed or stationary .
***************
Quit correct, except the jets would control the axial /vertical movement while STATIC, On occasion you might wish to leasurely examine something up close for a period. You cannot do this while moving forward or backwards.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A remote controll to drop a ballast weight is not necessary when you make your ROV slightly positive buoyant . It will pop to the surface when anything fails while it only takes a little trust to send her down .
****************
Again correct, but if you are hovering in a static condition examining something closely, you no longer have this submerging thrust effect so would bob up to the surface. In my demonstration the ROV would be "slightly" negative. because of the disposal weight. In the case of extreme recoverability, the weight could be attached to a Strong breakaway line to be recovered separately.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
When building a ROV think about what you are doing , and think about what you want it to do . Keep it as simple as possible while not giving up on all the things you want it to do
*************
Again agreed, precisely what I am proposing for El Pegger to consider..
*************
Before you start building , plan ahead . It took me three months before I touched any material . Do away with electronics where you can ! It will only give you trouble . Don't make any shortcuts , they don't work in the long run . When you start building do a nice job . Finish evrything like factory made or don't start this project . It is still a nice project if you take your time to do a nice job . The final result will be something you can be proud of and which is the same as one that is factory made . If you are not handy with tools , don't start or you will end up with some junk . Cornelius
************
So far I see no disagreement between us, only in how to achieve the requred results at min. expense.
Tropical Tramp