Yeah dude, I really think so! I love old buttons. Here is my take on it; you can find an old coin, and that's great! They are very cool. You can think of the story about who and how someone dropped it, but in the end, it doesn't matter...it's money! A button was attached to someone's clothing or uniform. Someone specific, who, depending on what they did for a living, and if a button which depicts that same career, can almost surely be attributed to that person. I'm not sure how deep you dive into the history of the area where the button was found,
Oh my, yeah, I do understand that and I'm not belittling the buttons, personal items at all. I feel the same way. Money is money. But, to each their own and some would rather find gold rings, etc. While I'm not opposed to those either,

, I would prefer to find a good old silver/bronze/gold coin. Buttons, spoons, suspender clasps, buckles and other personal items fascinate me, but, I'm a coinshooter at heart. Not for the value, I never sell, and, I ALWAYS clean them. LOL
Still, I am VERY interested in the history of a place. I've traced this place back through 3 generations, back to the late 1700's. The trouble with personal items, like this button, is that there's no easy way to pin down who it's from or when. If I get a button that is known. Like a military button that's from say the 7th cavalry, well, I'd have a starting point to view it's history. I can imagine it belonged to Custer.
I can tell you where this particular button was found in regard to the pages of history, at least the ground it was found on. But, I can't tell anything about it, maker, period (except within a hundred years), whether it belonged to a particular historical figure, or was it just dumped there with the fill dirt that was brought in to make a garden. What can you tell me about a brass button that says "Plated"?
I enjoy finding ANYTHING I find. Too many times without. But, as for me, a good conditioned rare coin is what I enjoy most. But that's just me.
Thanks for the wonderful response and happy hunting out there!
HH!