If you're hunting for t-shirts or a good tropical drink... you'll be all set!! As for land hunting in KW itself, most everything is built on and is either private or government property. And they don't allow hunting in the Fort Taylor either. The only place you stand a chance of finding anything is Smathers Beach and it would be for modern jewelry, etc. There are areas to beach hunt for shipwreck materials, but they are further up the Keys. Good luck with your hunting and enjoy your trip! Key West can be a fun town... if you can avoid the bar fights & local vagrants harassing you for money...
Phips