Lightning Strikes Again: George Washington Inaugural Button!!!

paleomaxx

Hero Member
Joined
Aug 14, 2016
Messages
841
Reaction score
6,888
Golden Thread
6
Location
Upstate, NY
🥇 Banner finds
6
Detector(s) used
Deus XP
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
I took a chance on Sunday and boy did it pay off! I've been detecting this spot for years and it's produced some incredible finds including a GWI button last November. I know they were sold in sets so of course I continued to hit the spot trying to find the rest but without any luck. It's been getting progressively more frustrating and the hunt before this I found nearly nothing at all and I was almost at the point of retiring the spot completely. It doesn't help that 3/4 of the place looks like this:

thumbnail.webp

It's a nest of fallen apple trees and brambles all locked together with bittersweet vines. Right now is the best that it ever gets with all the leaves gone and some of the brambles trapped under the snow and it's still mostly impassable. But finding one GWI is a serious motivator so I decided to give it another shot and focused on an area that was well away from the cellar. There are next to no signals and the ones I did find were mostly shotgun headstamps. Finally I got a solid deep tone and pulled out an amazing piece:

DSC01222.webpDSC01224.webpDSC01225.webp

A complete colonial knee buckle! I've found quite a few in varying states of preservation but never before one that was 100% brass construction. That got the blood pumping so I started a careful sweep of the surrounding area and less than 10 feet away I got a solid and shallow 84 on the Deus. Usually that's a rifle casing, but to my complete surprise:

thumbnail3.webp

Dandy button, and not just any dandy button but exactly the one I was hunting for!!!

thumbnail2.webp

Even under the dirt I could see the tail feathers and the estoile. I packed that sucker in dirt and kept searching for three more hours until I ran out of light. A few other nice relics did turn up, but no more GWIs. That's okay though because one is in a hunt is more than enough! :hello2:

Cleaning these is always nerve-wracking. I already knew from other relics found here that the patina wouldn't be stable and would inevitably flake off so I let it dry and removed the flakes as carefully as I could. I whittle the tip of a bamboo skewer to a needle point and I tease the flakes off the surface so that there's no residue. The bamboo needs to be constantly resharpened, but it doesn't leave scratches and gets off all but the most stubborn bits. The few remaining spots I very carefully go after with a razor blade to shave off extremely thin layers of patina only without hitting the underlying metal. Finally I polish up the surface to give it contrast and the end result:

thumbnail1.webp

The bend appears to be plow damage; fortunately not from the shovel. Amazingly despite that the shank survived and is still upright:

DSC01219.webp

The details are sharp enough that I could count the edge indents (63) which makes this a GWI 12-C. According to georgewashingtoninaguralbuttons.com that's the scarcest variety of this type! And even more importantly that matches the other I found here last year so it fits that they're from the same set. Here they are reunited after over 200 years in the ground!

DSC01228.webp

The question is are there 2-3 more hiding in the ground? I will keep looking, but if they are there it's going to be a challenge getting to the ground I haven't already swept over. The other finds for the day include some older drilled-shank buttons and a nice piece of furniture brass:

DSC01213.webpDSC01221.webpDSC01226.webp

Talk about the perfect Christmas gift though. And, as if I needed further proof, a lesson in the concept of no spot ever being hunted out! :laughing7:

DSC01217.webp
 

Upvote 57
Great going - would the property owner let you pay to bring in a piece of equipment to move that stuff.
 

Fantastic find but I must say... early American Eagles sure were a sorry looking lot..
look more like a pigeon with mange than an Eagle. Congrats all the same on a well rewarded hunt!
 

Great going - would the property owner let you pay to bring in a piece of equipment to move that stuff.

I talked to them about some sort of a burn pile, but it's such a large area and so much brush that even cutting it up and tossing it in a brush fire would be a major operation. Applewood is tough stuff too. Even after decades on the ground it won't just snap and has to be sawed apart.
 

Both of them are exceptional finds! Congratulations!
 

I'm in awe of the condition of those buttons. Your cleaning technique looks to be super effective. What's your process for polishing the surface?
Major, major kudos on all of these magnificent finds!
 

Most of us will never see one of those GW's in person, let alone recover two of them!!!! Terrific, HISTORIC finds! Way to persevere in your search, and a nice cleanup job, too. Wow. Congrats.
 

Very Nice!!! Congrats!!!
 

I gave this a banner vote, not only for the exceedingly rare button, but for re-uniting a set that were almost certainly a matched pair!

Outstanding find! You have my admiration and my jealousy!
 

Nice to have a pair.

g
 

As one of those that will probably never see one, I am astounded and thrilled for you! Congratulations!
 

Two amazing finds! Can't retire the spot now!
 

Great job on the GWI !! The early brass is a great relic too ! - that's the sort of brass you see the Keno brothers getting excited about- on a Federal Period Highboy or sideboard or the like
on Antiques Roadshow !!
 

Outstanding to say the least. Those two belong together and I would keep them together. Well done:thumbsup:
 

AWESOME! This defines- “persistence pays off”! I’ll bet you could draw a map of the trees, gullies, and rises of that property from memory you have hit it so hard! -But there is the result! Two amazing pieces of history! Congratulations!
 

Beautiful button

Great job on the restoration. It only takes one good find to make a hunt and I'd say that one was well worth it.

Jer
 

First of all, great find !! Secondly, you know I don’t like you, right? Just kidding my friend (; if I were you, I would go back this time of year with a machete and do some clearing before it’s unswingable forever. I have a few spots like that and they do need “maintenance “ every now and then. I have a spot in Vermont that is absolutely brutal and I haven’t been back since this spring but the land owner told me there was a significant brush fire that cleared the area pretty good so I’m looking forward to gettting back at it. Keep up the hard work and get in there and find the other 5!!! Merry Christmas
 

They came in sets of 4...so there could be 2 more waiting for you!
 

This is just incredible!!! I thought I was on fire when I found a 2nd matching dandy to a really nice one I found. It's hard to comprehend this. Huge congrats on it! What a beautiful rare piece of history!
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom