My apologies to eboy1960 ...........

creskol

Gold Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2007
Messages
13,624
Reaction score
22,704
Golden Thread
2
🥇 Banner finds
2
🏆 Honorable Mentions:
5
Primary Interest:
Other
Deftone made a post under eboy1960's post "confederate blanket buckle,/ also solid bronze buckle.? " in which he brought up a valid point when he said, "I think what get's me most is thread derailment like this that ruins this cats finds..." As a participant in this "derailment" please note that it was not my intention at all to hijack the thread and diminish eboy1960's finds in any manner, and if it was perceived in that fashion, please accept my apologies.

As a relic hunter, I am always in search for an accurate identification for the things I find as well as for those that others find, so when a topic such as these buckle covers pops up, I am always hopeful for more information that can be used in the future. As I pointed out in the BEST FINDS forum under Deftone's post on Buckle Covers!, I have dedicated much research to this topic, and the earliest patent I can find on any type of buckle cover was held by Henry Pott, circa 1874. His cover, however, was an integral part of the buckle itself, and mainly served as a buckle loop, rather than a shield. The first true buckle cover patent that I could find was held by David Mosman, issued in 1879, and it more closely resembles the solid brass covers with the rigid ends that we also see attributed to the Civil War. The first true buckle cover that resembles these that we see with hearts was patented by Ralph Wooding in 1892. Prior to these dates, the only reference to buckle covers/protectors/shields was the use of a secondary leather strap that covered the face of the buckle. My research is always continuing as new information and leads come about, but so far, I have not found anything that definitively dates these to the Civil War era.

At the same time, I posted an article under Eboy1960's post that was published in American Digger magazine that suggested that these covers did indeed exist during the Civil War, although no substantiating evidence was offered. .. Hence .. I am always hopeful for information that will bridge the gap from my own personal research, and the assertion that these are from the Civil War era.

At any rate, I just wanted to clarify my position with regards to my participation in the discussion, and apologize again to any I have offended.
 

Upvote 2
Always takes a big person to stand up and apologize, but you really didn't do anything wrong. You were only trying to stop the spread of mis-information. You made a correction and backed it up with data, that's a major function of any forum...

Besides, that last post of Deftone's was pretty contradictory. He's railing on about derailment and yet he slips in a zinger questioning the authenticity of another thread's finds like a shoulder-chipper...hmmmm.

peace,
cc
 

I just updated the thread you referred to, to say a similar thing although I thanked your input & I don't think we should shy away from the truth as we know it. Unless the poster has asked otherwise. You were not putting him or his find down & if we can't add value then I will leave because I'm not the person who sits back and adds 'nice find'. We are stronger by our combined knowledge, if we don't share, then we all loss.
 

I agree,and often come off as "cold",or "short",those are not my intentions ever!I as many here feel its our duty to set the record straight from what we know....not that it is always correct but,their is an assemblage of great minds here that have spent an extreme amount of time researching items that most people wouldnt even look twice at.It is a huge personal peave of mine when info is wrong and continues to be carried on....these forums are the best place for the discussions to be,to correct mis-information
 

you are all on top of the research you do, creskol i never worry about what you have to say i know you are speaking about a topic you know alot about.and i thank you for that,,i just love the hobby and think i have good spots ,,an bring an share my finds to you all, to learn about them,let us big and share these great finds,because this hobby is the best,,thanks again,
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom