MY FIRST COIN CACHE !!!

future

Jr. Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2016
Messages
28
Reaction score
72
Golden Thread
0
Location
Boise, Idaho
Detector(s) used
Whites MXT All Pro, Whites 6000 DI Pro, Whites GMT, Whites Surf PI Dual Field......want a Minelab e-trac
Primary Interest:
Metal Detecting
I have been metal detecting off & on since 1971. Most of that time was spent in Alaska were I hunted gold nuggets....at which I was very successful! But in 1982 and 1983 I attended college out in the "lower 48" and spent lots of time looking for old coins in the local parks. I used a Whites 4000 D Series 2 detector, which was really good for the time. I found hundreds of Mercury dimes, wheat pennies, and even dozens of silver quarters during those years because the parks were not so hunted out back then. But I never found a coin cache. Time warp ahead to 2015, when I was fortunate enough to acquire a new Whites MXT All Pro detector. After hitting city & state parks hard for a year, I only had 8 silver dimes and some silver rings to show for it. Silver coins are getting VERY hard to find anymore. So, I decided to head to the desert area of the state and do some detecting around old abandoned farms and houses in the country. Its very dry over there and any coins are always in excellent shape, unlike the coins dug at the coast or the wet Cascade range. I had detected several abandoned houses with good results, finding several old Mercury Dimes and even a couple Barber Dimes in excellent shape. I was busy detecting in the hot sun when a pickup stopped and a man approached me. I thought "oh great....here comes trouble!". But he was very nice and suggested I hunt an abandoned farm (he called it a spread) not too far away. So I loaded up and headed over there. It was certainly abandoned and there wasn't a "no trespassing" sign anywhere. After walking the "spread" and not seeing any recently dug holes by other detectorists I started detecting in earnest! I'll never forget this day, August 20th, 2016! After finding the usual wheat pennies, horse shoes, tin, and scrap iron I decided to hunt in angles as seen from the living room window of the old house. I figured that if there were any elusive caches around, their location would have been where the owner could have seen them from his favorite rocking chair in the living room. After hunting out about 200 feet I had found little. Now the address of this "spread" was 249 East - - - - Road. So I put on my thinking cap and decided to go 249 feet due east of the living room window. After detecting about 5 minutes I got a very weak signal which indicated it was deeper than the 12" that my detector reads. I marked the place and went back to my truck and got my clam shovel that I always carry. Going back to the target place I started digging and got down about 10", which took almost 20 minutes in the rock hard dirt. The signal was still there but I couldn't get my pinpointer to read anything. I dug another 3" of hard packed dirt and tried the pinpointer again, and this time it sounded off. Carefully digging a little further I exposed a small white lid and thought, great just another scrap lid. But it was attached to something & wouldn't budge. The lid was 14" deep! After digging around it for 10 more minutes I had it loose in the hole. When I pulled it out I about fainted! It was an old bird seed jar filled with coins! I tried opening it but the lid was stuck on solid! It was getting late in the day so I put it in my bag and headed home. After I had carefully cleaned the jar I saw that someone had applied wax all the way around the lid, apparently to keep moisture and water out. The lid came off with some effort and revealed Buffalo Nickels clear to the top of the jar. Dumping them out onto a towel on the table I as stunned to see 7 silver dollars at the bottom! The coins were very clean and looked like they had just came out of circulation. The wax job on the lid had really worked! There were 108 Buffalo Nickels and 7 silver dollars, 4 of which were the old Morgan dollars. The oldest silver dollar was an 1880 and the newest a 1922. The oldest Buffalo Nickel was a 1918 and the newest a 1937, and one had a key date of 1931-S. I wish I would have had a camera with me that day, as I would have loved to photographed the jar in the hole and just after recovering it. I'll always have a camera with me from now on! I can't wait to get back to that "spread" and see what else might be waiting for me! DSC02300.webpDSC02301.webp
 

Last edited:
Upvote 37
Wow great find, congrats!
 

That is one bodacious cache find and congrats to you - 108 Buffalos & 7 Morgan's and all in great shape, one in a lifetime find, anyway thanks for sharing your pictures and story & I wish you many more great treasures.

Texas ED
 

Congrats on the awesome Cache. :occasion14: I'd still be stoked if I dug that. If that's not a banner find, I don't know what is. My votes in.
 

I notice that the dollar coins have a date range of 42 years, but they each appear to be in mint condition....but the Buffaloes, for he most part are twenty years older than the dollars, and half of them are worn down dateless, like they were in circulation for 50 years or so....
I'm scratching my head as to how this could be....
I've never found a cache, so I guess anythings possible.
 

There are only a few buffalo's that are unreadable, the rest are in pretty good shape. There is indeed a 42 year date range for the dollars. I have no idea when the jar was buried or how the coins were collected for burial, all I know is that they were all in this jar when I emptied them out onto the kitchen table. The jar hadn't been opened in years as sealing it with wax was something that was done years ago. Looks to me like someone gathered up some coins they had been saving.....maybe in the 1940s, threw them into a jar, and buried them all for a rainy day......like you say.....who knows?
 

Now for some real detective work, research the jar, the type, brand, etc. That should give a good indication of when it was place there.
 

Last edited:
Amazing!! Find of a lifetime for sure! I'm voting Banner!
 

great idea!
 

That would be an awesome find, but I am a little skeptical. I cannot foresee getting that many coins into that small bottle. I am surprised that the paper is still somewhat intact on the out side of the bottle. I am aware that it would take a large amount of rainfall to penetrate that deep and cause deterioration of the paper. Thus, it is possible that the paper could have lasted. This is just my opinion.
 

Nice find, I found ads for PetPak Keet Treet in 1955 and 1956 newspapers maybe more research on the jar might help you date the cache.
 

Wow!!! A dream come true!!! Congratulations!!!
 

Great and awesome recoveries , would have made my day , congrats .. cheers Mick
 

First of all, congrats on the find.
I was wondering a bit about what was going through the mind of the guy who buried the jar. Why the buffalo nickles? Sure, the silver dollars are worthwhile, but why the nickles? One possibility was that the nickles were ended by 1938 and he just thought some of those would become valuable. At what point he put them in the jar and buried them is still questionable, but I suspect he didn't live too much longer to find out if any were valuable. I'll bet if you looked up the records that you will find somebody died in the late 30s to early 40s who lived there and don't forget that WWII happened in the early 40s.
 

Nice find, I found ads for PetPak Keet Treet in 1955 and 1956 newspapers maybe more research on the jar might help you date the cache.

Same here. I Mainly saw Sandusky Ohio area June 1955
from an add for Johnny's Petland, 809 Hancock-st.
 

Last edited:
I just nominated you for BANNER, future. A cache like that should not go unsung. Can you tell us what the oldest Buffalo nickel is?
 

Excellent find! Great job on solving the location.
 

A dream come true! You give the rest of us hope. Congratulations!
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Latest Discussions

Back
Top Bottom