My Insanely Massive Hoard of Historic Treasure

UnderMiner

Silver Member
Joined
Jul 27, 2014
Messages
3,976
Reaction score
10,466
Golden Thread
2
Location
New York City
🥇 Banner finds
2
Detector(s) used
Minelab Excalibur II, Equinox 800
Primary Interest:
All Treasure Hunting
So I found roughly 4.5+ pounds of 1800's silver treasure about two months ago. I wanted to post it to 'today's finds' the day I found it but it took me so long to document and research the whole thing that weeks had past by the time I was done. The histories behind many of the 72 pieces of treasure contained in the hoard are very fascinating. The oldest two spoons are from 1801 - the Napoleonic and Regency age - while King George III was still in power. The latest silver spoon in the hoard is inscribed with the date 1911 - when King George V was in his first full year of power - the year prior to the Titanic disaster. I pulled all of this treasure out of a dumpster - piece by meticulous piece. The house had been recently sold to new owners and they were throwing everything inside it into the trash. The previous owner must have collected silver spoons and the new owners must have been oblivious to the fact that silver spoons are valuable, so the treasure is mine now. I estimate it's worth at minimum $1,000.

I put all the treasure into a planter pot as I was digging it out:
In this first pic I am holding a Cartier sterling silver shot glass made in the style of the thimble, it was one of the few non-spoon treasures.
It was made in 1965 and is most modern treasure in the hoard.
spoons 9.webp
The majority of the silver spoons are American coin silver and date from the 1800's-1860's.
Spoons 4.webp
This is an image of the silver on a scale, note the weight in lbs. I tared out the container holding the silver so what you see is the true weight of only the solid silver items.
Spoons 10.webp

In the hoard were two Russian Imperial silver serving spoons, both from 1875. Made in the city of Kamenetz-Podolsk of the Russian Empire in what is today part of Western Ukraine. The Czar at this time was Alexander II. 8 years prior to the making of these spoons, Czar Alexander II sold Alaska to former Lincoln Secretary of State William H. Seward for $7.2 million, a move that made the US population ridicule him calling the move "Seward's Folly" little did they know that Alaska was rich in minerals like gold and oil which would benefit the US greatly well into the modern age.
kamenetz podolsk.webp

This set of three Sterling silver spoons includes one spoon with an inscription from 1911. The spoons were likely given as trophy prize for a tennis competition. I found only three, but it's likely the original set would have been at least six or perhaps even twelve, but those spoons have been lost to time:
20181220_231539.webp

These are the best find of all of the spoons.
They are a matched set of 1801 London George III 'Berry spoons'.
They are sterling with gold washed bowls over a 3-dimensional berry motif.
The scroll work on the handle is most likely a later addition from Victorian times.
20181220_231712.webp
20181220_231728.webp

A familiar face, the crowned leopard's head. It was used to hallmark Sterling in Britain from the 14th century until 1821. In 1821 there was a clerical error in the official silver hallmarking law that accidentally omitted the fact that the leopard's head had to be wearing a crown, the silver industry thus followed the law as it was written and omitted the crown. Thee leopard's head would remain uncrowned on British sterling to this day.
Spoons 7.webp

The bust of King George III himself! Some current events that were happening when this mark was impressed into this silver: Thomas Jefferson was sworn in as the 3rd US president. Napoleon loses the Siege of Cairo to British forces. Tripoli declares war on the USA following American disapproval of the Barbary Pirates and the First Barbary War begins. The first census is held in Great Britain. The population of England and Wales is determined to be 8.9 million, with London revealed to have 860,035 residents.
Spoons 8.webp

This is a picture of most of the treasure, I went back to the dumpster the next day and found a few more pieces. The long silver things on top are sterling silver straws:
Spoons 1.webp

In total there were 72 pieces of silver treasure including 50 silver spoons. Three spoons were of European origin made from 13 Loth or 81% silver, two spoons were Russian 84 Zolotnik or 87.5% silver and dated from 1875, two spoons were British Sterling from 1801, three spoons were Sterling from 1911, the other spoons were all 1800's American coin silver - 90% pure from various manufacturers - there were three complete sets and many one-off spoons, far too many to document in one post here. I suspect a few of the one-off American coin silver spoons are from the late 1700's as their styles are more similar to this earlier time period. I have yet to fully document all of the manufacturers of these American coin silver spoons.
 

All I can say is WOW!
 

I don't know if a "Dumpster Find" has ever been voted in as a Banner,, but I'm going to start the ball rolling.
Banner.
 

Last edited:
Here's what the inside of the dumpster looked like where the treasure was, I took a picture before I started digging because I knew this was gonna be big. There were other things in the dumpster that were not silver, like some copper and brass things that I took as well, made some decent money scrapping that stuff. All the forks were silver plated.
What A Massive Dumpster Hoard Looks Like.webp
The first spoon I pulled out, and I knew it was 1800's American coin silver. I began to freak out.
001.webp
 

Hi, wow, its a amazing find. Congrats:occasion14:
 

Biggest damn thimble I ever saw....lol WOW!!!!!!
 

Congratulations on an epic save. That is a fantastic find.
 

AMAZING and congratulations
 

Great saves.

Depending on the class/wealth a woman's silvers were often prized possessions.
Still a joke today to count the silverwear when someone of dubious character leaves the house.

I have not found any like yours in terms of value , but those around old sites I'm confident were noted as missed by someone....
Kids factored to be sure in those finds of mine , and kids/heirs in yours too. Though on a whopping scale/level. Well ,on your scale. Pun intended.

Congrats. And great write up.

Banner nomination in as stated , "One mans trash is another mans treasure".
And boy howdy is it in this case!
 

Last edited:
Banner banner banner. It deserves Banner just for being found in the dumpster by someone actually having the BALLS to look for treasure in a,well....DUMPSTER! B-A-N-N-E-R!!!
 

Great find and some excellent research to go with it! Congrats.
 

Thank goodness the world is full of dumb people or we'd never find anything lol. Thats amazing! I've always been a dumpster diver since my grandfather and I would walk the neighborhood on bulk trash day. He grew up in the depression so it it could be salvaged he would do it. Sometimes he'd even repair the item and ask the contributer if they wanted their now working lamp or tool back after he repaired it lol.
 

Beautiful finds, huge congratulations! :occasion14:
 

Amazing what people throw away. I agree that a banner vote does not necessarily require finding with a metal detector. Climbing into a dumpster shows that you deserve that vote. And thanks for posting it! A most excellent interesting presentation too.

(I almost didn't click on your post, thinking it might be someone posting a truckload of pulltabs...glad I clicked)
 

Last edited:
My banner vote is in, glad you saved that from the landfill
 

Life just never ceases to amaze me especially how blind some folks can be (myself as well from time to time). Whether a president is Damned for protecting the borders of our country (and by doing so is following U.S.A. laws and honoring the Constitution) or someone chooses to dump some nasty old used forks and spoons and does not notice from the color that they look odd and might be worth looking at. Congratulations on your find and willingness to go after the treasure before you. "I won't have much to drink tonight fellas, just a thimble full please"! Enjoy Christmas.................63bkpkr
 

UnderMiner,

Your' finds of thrown out treasures never has and never will cease to amaze me as most if not historic, they are valuable! Congrats on the awesome finds! I am not sure the finds will make Banner but I am voting Banner anyway. Nice Christmas present for you by the way!
 

From the Dumpster to the Banner. Nice saves sir. You have my vote!
 

Top Member Reactions

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom