yeah definitely a scraper, more than likely during the knapping process they hit a snag then just utilized it for household use. Second, looks like a rattlesnake rattle. Common iconography.
Edit: Probably not an ammonite, they would have more symmetrical lines and curves (even if deposition wasn't the greatest, at least part of it would be silica replacement. My opinion is that it's part of a rattlesnake petroglyph. Cool snizz though.
Edit 2: I didn't read your entire thing correctly, one of those days. Looks like Jasper and it's very very nice. Maybe that artifact was coveted, maybe it was a reworked projectile point. Regardless it's sweet.
Edit 3: it's one of those days, um reason I think it's a petroglyph is that it's associated with the scraper (let me know if I'm wrong about that and these two artifacts/fossils are from locations entirely).