Thanks guys! Some of the engravings look to "messy" to be machine made and there appears to be some hammer marks. I found it in my Minelab bag in a zip lock with a bunch of metal beach debris. I found this years ago and probably assumed it was a corroded penny and never gave it a good look, I just opened that bag for the first time in years. It was found on a known treasure shipwreck beach in East Florida with no arcades in sight. I'm not saying that it is not a token, i'm just keeping an open mind for now. Any safe cleaning tips so I can see more of the object?
Thanks again!