I've been using a GTI-2500 for about 5 years. My experience with the 12 inch coil has been other than good. Part of the issue is the local soil conditions. By the time you turn down the sensitivity to the point the 12 inch will work, anything much deeper than 3 inches doesn't get detected. It was so bad when I first got it, I sent it back to Garrett to make sure it was working. They replaced the 12 inch coil, but the new one wasn't any better. Since that time (about 5 years as I said) I've stuck with the 9 inch one with very good results.
When I'm hunting kiddy lots, or a carnival sites, I use the Zero Discrimination setting, with the sensitivity set at about 8.5 which is somewhat higher than the factory reset setting (≈7.5).
I have recently obtained permission from the land owner to hunt a 25 acre plot which at one time had 5 houses situated on it. They're long since gone, and the site has been verboten for nearly 25 years. I've been using the all-metal mode, with the auto balance set on its highest setting. To date, the deepest find was a 3 inch long cinch pin that was ≈18 inches deep. The deepest coin (a very fine grade 1920S wheat) was down ≈9 inches deep.
Everybody has their pet detector, but the 2500 has been the best one I have owned overall. The only drawback is its weight, but I do use a bungie cord and strap which places the weight on my shoulder.
Have fun, and fine your riches!