If I were to sell silver, where would I take it?
I called American Precious Metals Exchange (APMEX) on Wednesday, 7/22/20 at around 4:50pm EST, just to get a feel for what their buy prices would be. I've bought from them several times over the years during dips.
I've only sold once, and it was also to APMEX. It was back when silver was on its run up to $40+. I sold some of my 40% Kennedy halves when the spot price was just shy of $30/oz. so that I could take some profit from CRHing and upgrade to .999 when the price dropped, which I later did. I only sold a portion of my 40%ers to see what the market would do and hung on to all of my 90% US silver because I like to have some variety sitting around. All of my transactions with APMEX have been great. Their communication has been clear both on the phone and through emails confirming the transactions and providing shipping information. When I sold my 40%ers, I got 94% of melt value.
I'd bought some 1 oz. .9999 and .999 rounds back in Sept. of 2018. Since they don't sell those types anymore (because RMC went belly-up), I figured that they'd just buy them at the secondary market rate (plus I've got some other secondary market 1 oz. rounds that I picked up here and there over the years). I figured that if I decided to sell, that I'd unload some of those first and hang on to my ASEs and other stuff. The spot price at the time that I requested the quote was $23.27/oz. and their buy price on the 1 oz. rounds was $22.85/oz. or $0.42/oz. under spot. I then asked what their buy price was on 40% Kennedy halves because I figured that maybe I'd just sell some more of those. The guy on the line asked, "How many?" and I figured that if I decided to sell, it would be in $100 increments face value. His quote was $6.19/$1FV or $619.00 for $100 in face value 40% halves. I thanked him for the information and told him that I'd keep an eye on the price for a while and if I decided to sell, that I'd give them a call back.
When I sold to them back in 2011 or 2012, I went with APMEX for peace of mind, following their shipping instructions with insurance and whatnot.
You could try local or Craigslist, but in my experience, I've had better luck finding deals when buying locally. When I've considered selling some and asked local buyers what their buy prices would be, I've never found one that I considered acceptable. Plus, if selling on Craigslist and not to a known, reputable dealer, you'd have to meet them in a safe location (police station parking lot?) and watch your back on your way home or to the bank, to make sure that the buyer doesn't decide to follow you... Even if I could get a decent local price, I don't figure that the extra hassle would be worth it.
Kindest regards,
Kantuck